Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
Latest Breaking News
In reply to the discussion: Experts: Clinton emails could have compromised CIA names [View all]
http://www.digitaltonto.com/2016/the-technology-behind-hillary-clintons-email-scandal-explained/
In fact, government operates under the presumption that email messages will be intercepted, and uses two methods to keep sensitive information secret. The first, for the most highly secret material, involves hard copies of classified documents. These are not allowed to be copied or sent electronically and can only be transferred by a government courier.
The second method involves something called a Sensitive Compartmented Information Facility (SCIF), a facility which is used for electronically encrypted information. This is done by using large random numbers to scramble messages so that, even if they are intercepted, they cant be read by anyone who doesnt have the key. Truly secret information is never sent by regular email.
So, for the purposes of security, it really doesnt matter whether Hillary Clinton was using a government issued email or her own personal server. To a large extent unencrypted email is unencrypted email, no matter where the server resides. And while it is true that Clinton used her own private server for unclassified business, she also regularly used a SCIF for secure communication (one was installed at her residence).
http://www.newsweek.com/2016/02/19/colin-powell-emails-hillary-clinton-424187.html
But Powell and Rices aides did nothing wrong. (Im going to focus on them so that partisans who say Clinton broke the law have to attack respected Republicans first.) Start with this: Powell and Rice, like all modern secretaries of state, each had at least two email accountsone personal and the other for communications designated as highly classified at the time of their creation . For classified information, both of themand their aides with appropriate clearancehad a sensitive compartmented information facility, or what is known in intelligence circles as a SCIF. Most senior officials who deal with classified information have a SCIF in their offices and their homes.These are not just extra offices with a special lock. Each SCIF is constructed following complex rules imposed by the intelligence and defense communities. Restrictions imposed on the builders are designed to ensure that no unauthorized personnel can get into the room, and the SCIF cannot be accessed by hacking or electronic eavesdropping. A group called the technical surveillance countermeasures team (TSCM) investigates the area or activity to check that all communications are protected from outside surveillance and cannot be intercepted.
Most permanent SCIFs have physical and technical security, called TEMPEST. The facility is guarded and in operation 24 hours a day, seven days a week; any official on the SCIF staff must have the highest security clearance. There is supposed to be sufficient personnel continuously present to observe the primary, secondary and emergency exit doors of the SCIF. Each SCIF must apply fundamental red-black separation to prevent the inadvertent transmission of classified data over telephone lines, power lines or signal lines.
In fact, government operates under the presumption that email messages will be intercepted, and uses two methods to keep sensitive information secret. The first, for the most highly secret material, involves hard copies of classified documents. These are not allowed to be copied or sent electronically and can only be transferred by a government courier.
The second method involves something called a Sensitive Compartmented Information Facility (SCIF), a facility which is used for electronically encrypted information. This is done by using large random numbers to scramble messages so that, even if they are intercepted, they cant be read by anyone who doesnt have the key. Truly secret information is never sent by regular email.
So, for the purposes of security, it really doesnt matter whether Hillary Clinton was using a government issued email or her own personal server. To a large extent unencrypted email is unencrypted email, no matter where the server resides. And while it is true that Clinton used her own private server for unclassified business, she also regularly used a SCIF for secure communication (one was installed at her residence).
http://www.newsweek.com/2016/02/19/colin-powell-emails-hillary-clinton-424187.html
But Powell and Rices aides did nothing wrong. (Im going to focus on them so that partisans who say Clinton broke the law have to attack respected Republicans first.) Start with this: Powell and Rice, like all modern secretaries of state, each had at least two email accountsone personal and the other for communications designated as highly classified at the time of their creation . For classified information, both of themand their aides with appropriate clearancehad a sensitive compartmented information facility, or what is known in intelligence circles as a SCIF. Most senior officials who deal with classified information have a SCIF in their offices and their homes.These are not just extra offices with a special lock. Each SCIF is constructed following complex rules imposed by the intelligence and defense communities. Restrictions imposed on the builders are designed to ensure that no unauthorized personnel can get into the room, and the SCIF cannot be accessed by hacking or electronic eavesdropping. A group called the technical surveillance countermeasures team (TSCM) investigates the area or activity to check that all communications are protected from outside surveillance and cannot be intercepted.
Most permanent SCIFs have physical and technical security, called TEMPEST. The facility is guarded and in operation 24 hours a day, seven days a week; any official on the SCIF staff must have the highest security clearance. There is supposed to be sufficient personnel continuously present to observe the primary, secondary and emergency exit doors of the SCIF. Each SCIF must apply fundamental red-black separation to prevent the inadvertent transmission of classified data over telephone lines, power lines or signal lines.
TopBack to the top of the page
AlertAlert this post for a rule violation
ShareGet links to this post
PowersThere are no powers you can use on this post
Cannot edit, recommend, or reply in locked discussions
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
103 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
How many went to jail over releasing Plame's name? And that action really was a crime.
tonyt53
Jun 2016
#1
That's OK because Cheney, Rove were involved in Valerie Plame & they weren't punished
Chasstev365
Jun 2016
#2
No is not excused necessary: Hillary was cleared: the was no clarity to the rules
lewebley3
Jun 2016
#17
No this is over except for a political attack on Hillary that has not worked.
lewebley3
Jun 2016
#10
not LBN - could have/may have is analysis and opiniion not news. AP? the reviled enemy AP lol nt
msongs
Jun 2016
#12
I've never bad mouthed the AP. I've only questioned their motives of their announcement
NWCorona
Jun 2016
#25
No, the same situation would have occurred. They would have seen the exact same emails --
pnwmom
Jun 2016
#46
They know that the .gov system was hacked. They have said that there is no evidence
pnwmom
Jun 2016
#83
The emails are small cake compared to accepting money, through her foundation, from saudi royals
DemMomma4Sanders
Jun 2016
#37
She donates to the foundation. She doesn't get any funds "through" the Foundation. n/t
pnwmom
Jun 2016
#47
None of them get paid any salaries, so I don't know why you included the salary info.
pnwmom
Jun 2016
#64
I only get four paragraphs for the excerpt but I'm open to debate that with you if you'd like nt
NWCorona
Jun 2016
#38
You implied it with you assertion that FBI said there is "evidence," so stop playing coy.
SunSeeker
Jun 2016
#57
re: "the FBI officially confirmed that they recovered files from Hillary's server"
thesquanderer
Jun 2016
#66
The pdf of the court filing on Monday specifically mentioned materials gathered from
NWCorona
Jun 2016
#71
A fricken joke.. these experts are clueless when they give an actual traitor like Darth Cheney
gohuskies
Jun 2016
#79
At this stage I would say it would be inappropriate for anyone to endorse her
Rosa Luxemburg
Jun 2016
#97