Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

CommonHumanity

(246 posts)
23. When to sit it back v. when to stand up?
Sun Apr 19, 2020, 12:54 PM
Apr 2020

I wonder about this. Not saying it is right or wrong, just that I wonder. My mother's family fled Nazi Germany. I was very close to my maternal grandmother. Momentos of the life of my grandparents left behind were characters in my childhood, especially one small sculpture of a beautiful woman. My grandmother's brother was an artist and it was a sculpture of the woman he loved. He planned to follow my grandparents to the United States but was apprehended by the Nazis as he went to find this woman before leaving. He later died in the Terezin concentration camp.

Anyway....this is not the worst "holocaust impacted the next generation" story. There are so many that are far, far worse. All I am saying is that this history started me thinking at an early age about what I would do in the face of great injustice. Would I be willing to die to protect life and all that is sacred? I found myself thinking this as I read the post. Didn't many otherwise good people in Germany fail to protect the jews because they feared for their own lives and families? PLEASE UNDERSTAND I am not saying Trump and CV19 are in any way akin to the holocaust!!!! What I am saying is Trump has the potential to use this crisis to further consolidate power through his usual disgusting, lying, criminal, constitution-defying tactics and layers and layers of further harm could ensue.

Maybe I should be taking a stand right now on the capitol steps. Holding a sign every day and hoping others join. OK, maybe not that, but something to boldly stand up rather than hunker down and protect myself simply because it is the right thing to do in the face of evil life-destroying actions. Problem is, here is where I don't want to leave my house and expose myself to the virus. I don't want to risk my income or jeopardize my business. I want to hunker down and wait it out, but isn't this what allows things to go so awry for the earth and humanity-hunkering down because we don't want to risk it all. Those Germans that really spoke out or harbored Jews or aided the resistance risked it all. Again, this is not the holocaust, but still, this disturbed individual, his immediate cronies and the type of capitalism that lets the scum rise to the top are threatening the health of our people and the ability of our beautiful planet to sustain life and all that is good.

This probably sounds like naive idealistic inertia. Maybe I am a coward, but I wonder about really stand for despite all risk and when to do it and this post just brought these thoughts to mind. Wondering if anyone has comments or can relate. (Try not to be too terribly hard on me or at least don't totally demolish me. Although I have been reading DU for some time this is my first comment).

100%. My own sister let her son sleep over a friend's house last nite!! And wants to have a few jmg257 Apr 2020 #1
This is our problem bluestarone Apr 2020 #3
I think we should arrest them. LakeArenal Apr 2020 #2
Well, I'm high risk, so I will not be coming out until there is a vaccine or ooky Apr 2020 #4
Pretty HIGH risk myself! bluestarone Apr 2020 #10
I'm in my 70s agingdem Apr 2020 #12
I'm to the point where I couldn't care less about the Teabagger "reopeners"... SMC22307 Apr 2020 #5
YES I feel exactly the same as you! bluestarone Apr 2020 #7
Their protest signs laid it out yesterday... they want to golf and get their hair cut. SMC22307 Apr 2020 #15
That's the real problem. smirkymonkey Apr 2020 #34
Yes! The more people who follow the basic guidelines, the slower MineralMan Apr 2020 #6
Yes we have to be SMARTER bluestarone Apr 2020 #8
Yep. Texaswitchy Apr 2020 #9
These people think of NO ONE but themselves! bluestarone Apr 2020 #11
Really Timewas Apr 2020 #13
Right on! Their plan is their plan bluestarone Apr 2020 #17
The problem is that there are innocent people who will be hurt... Silent3 Apr 2020 #19
Your argument has holes big enough for any Coronavirus to pass right through lunatica Apr 2020 #33
Sure Timewas Apr 2020 #38
That's my plan. Nothing I can do about pnwest Apr 2020 #14
There aren't enough of them to keep it up for long 2naSalit Apr 2020 #16
True words here. bluestarone Apr 2020 #18
They will expect front of the bus care. 2naSalit Apr 2020 #20
NO DOUBT! bluestarone Apr 2020 #21
I have a strong sense of intuition... 2naSalit Apr 2020 #22
LOL ... "front of the bus" care. Iggo Apr 2020 #25
I don't know where it came from... 2naSalit Apr 2020 #29
Perfectly illustrative. Iggo Apr 2020 #31
I thought it was was apt and profound. lunatica Apr 2020 #35
You're exactly right Windy City Charlie Apr 2020 #36
When to sit it back v. when to stand up? CommonHumanity Apr 2020 #23
Welcome to DU! It's a great place to get some peace of mind that's for sure! bluestarone Apr 2020 #26
But they're killing us, too. Iggo Apr 2020 #24
I won't argue this bluestarone Apr 2020 #27
Goddam right. Iggo Apr 2020 #28
My thoughts exactly. nt DesertRat Apr 2020 #30
This is how I see it. LizBeth Apr 2020 #32
The vast majority of deaths are still over 65 forthemiddle Apr 2020 #37
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Maybe our ONLY option is ...»Reply #23