Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Warpy

(111,652 posts)
8. OASDI is an insurance program, so I tell them that
Tue Jan 1, 2013, 11:39 PM
Jan 2013

if they allow means testing for it, they can expect means testing for other insurance.

"Your accident claim has been denied. Our records show you have enough money in your bank account to buy a new car so your claim is disqualified. Thank you for your business." Never mind the money was being saved for a down payment on a house or for retirement or for a kid's college tuition.

"Your claim has been denied. Our records show you have adequate equity in your home to pay for the chemotherapy treatments. Thank you for your business."

"Condolences on the death of your spouse but your claim for death benefits has been denied. Our records show that you are making an adequate income to support your children alone if you'll just be an adult and move to a cheaper apartment."

You see where that could go. Unfortunately, the Republicans have decades of convincing idiots that Social Security is some sort of welfare, money for nothing, even though recipients have paid into it their whole working lives.

And this is why means testing is a really, really bad idea.

6 Reasons Top Economists Think Means-Testing Medicare & Social Security Is a Destructive Idea Demeter Jan 2013 #1
War on the Weak, the Elderly, the Disabled, the Outsider Demeter Jan 2013 #5
Ok, here’s my theory about why the Masters of the Universe want to kill the social insurance program Demeter Jan 2013 #6
People won't be putting anything into a 401K account Warpy Jan 2013 #9
Is it time to post "The Chart" again? Hugin Jan 2013 #36
They sure as hell are resistant to anything Warpy Jan 2013 #52
Where is that chart again? DemReadingDU Jan 2013 #57
OASDI is an insurance program, so I tell them that Warpy Jan 2013 #8
Sadly, I concur. Hugin Jan 2013 #37
Everything You Need to Know About the Emerging ‘Fiscal Cliff’ Tax Compromise Demeter Jan 2013 #2
Lousy Deal on the Edge of the Cliff By Robert Reich Demeter Jan 2013 #3
How Damon Runyon Would Have Explained Jon Corzine Demeter Jan 2013 #4
Revenge of the Reality-Based Community: My life on the Republican right—& how I saw it all go wrong Demeter Jan 2013 #7
My sentiments, exactly. The British are so polite. Fuddnik Jan 2013 #10
Uh huh. Ghost Dog Jan 2013 #17
Leadership---Teabag Style Demeter Jan 2013 #11
One website says it's 13F at 6:30 AM, the other says 2F Demeter Jan 2013 #12
So, supposedly there is a temporary patch in the fiscal cliff Demeter Jan 2013 #13
i had a slight wardrobe malfunction for my Dying Swan. it went so well in rehersal... xchrom Jan 2013 #14
Spain will start to create jobs at the end of 2013, says economy minister xchrom Jan 2013 #15
In the long run Demeter Jan 2013 #27
i don't know where those jobs are going to come from. xchrom Jan 2013 #29
Main parties close to deal on reducing public administration{spain} xchrom Jan 2013 #16
Willy Loman Turns to Windows as Web Spurs Sales Changes xchrom Jan 2013 #18
DESPITE DEAL, TAXES TO RISE FOR MOST AMERICANS xchrom Jan 2013 #19
beware, I got nothing but shit for merely pointing pointing out that fact. corkhead Jan 2013 #42
Never should have had that to begin with Roland99 Jan 2013 #44
AVIS BUYING ZIPCAR IN DEAL WORTH NEARLY $500M xchrom Jan 2013 #20
PORTUGAL'S HIGHEST COURT TO ASSES STATE BUDGET xchrom Jan 2013 #21
CYPRUS PRESIDENT: NO PRIVATIZATION IN BAILOUT DEAL xchrom Jan 2013 #22
Rocketing Rents Become Election Issue in Germany xchrom Jan 2013 #23
Karma is a bitch Demeter Jan 2013 #25
Merkel vulnerable, polls suggest xchrom Jan 2013 #26
MORGAN STANLEY: The BRIC Era Is Over xchrom Jan 2013 #24
US 'fiscal cliff' deal prompts global stock markets rally xchrom Jan 2013 #28
Glad it's so amusing Demeter Jan 2013 #34
seems like they've been trying to float that balloon for a while. xchrom Jan 2013 #35
What next for Turkey's application to join the European project? xchrom Jan 2013 #30
Irish manufacturing growth slows xchrom Jan 2013 #31
French to pursue wealthy despite 75% tax rejection xchrom Jan 2013 #32
U.K. Manufacturing Revives as Euro Factories Struggle: Economy xchrom Jan 2013 #33
Singapore growth beats estimates as it avoids recession xchrom Jan 2013 #38
India rolls out cash transfer scheme for poor xchrom Jan 2013 #39
AIG to America: Thanks, guys! xchrom Jan 2013 #40
Stocks Soar on 'Fiscal Cliff' Deal DemReadingDU Jan 2013 #41
11:00 a.m. elleng Jan 2013 #43
Champagne hangover hasn't kicked in yet Roland99 Jan 2013 #45
I need some champagne, first Demeter Jan 2013 #46
6 Things You Won't Believe That Are In The Fiscal Cliff Bill... Demeter Jan 2013 #47
FULL TEXT OF THE BILL Demeter Jan 2013 #48
The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly in the Fiscal Cliff Package (NEOLIBERAL-FASCISTS) Demeter Jan 2013 #49
Why do you hate asparagus? Fuddnik Jan 2013 #50
Time to get your eyes checked, doc. I don't see asparagus Demeter Jan 2013 #53
Post 47, Item 6 Fuddnik Jan 2013 #54
Ah! I thought you were referring to the cartoon Demeter Jan 2013 #55
As goes January, so goes the year? siligut Jan 2013 #51
I hope not. It was ZERO last night Demeter Jan 2013 #56
Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Economy»STOCK MARKET WATCH -- Wed...»Reply #8