Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Puzzler

(2,505 posts)
48. Why doesn't she revise the value of pi while she's at it?
Sun Apr 15, 2012, 08:11 PM
Apr 2012

Seriously!

It happened in Indiana. Although the attempt to legislate pi was ultimately unsuccessful, it did come pretty close. In 1897 Representative T.I. Record of Posen county introduced House Bill #246 in the Indiana House of Representatives. The bill, based on the work of a physician and amateur mathematician named Edward J. Goodwin (Edwin in some accounts), suggests not one but three numbers for pi, among them 3.2, as we shall see. The punishment for unbelievers I have not been able to learn, but I place no credence in the rumor that you had to spend the rest of your natural life in Indiana.

Just as people today have a hard time accepting the idea that the speed of light is the speed limit of the universe, Goodwin and Record apparently couldn't handle the fact that pi was not a rational number. "Since the rule in present use [presumably pi equals 3.14159...] fails to work ..., it should be discarded as wholly wanting and misleading in the practical applications," the bill declared. Instead, mathematically inclined Hoosiers could take their pick among the following formulae:

(1) The ratio of the diameter of a circle to its circumference is 5/4 to 4. In other words, pi equals 16/5 or 3.2

(2) The area of a circle equals the area of a square whose side is 1/4 the circumference of the circle. Working this out algebraically, we see that pi must be equal to 4.

(3) The ratio of the length of a 90 degree arc to the length of a segment connecting the arc's two endpoints is 8 to 7. This gives us pi equal to the square root of 2 x 16/7, or about 3.23.


http://www.straightdope.com/columns/read/805/did-a-state-legislature-once-pass-a-law-saying-pi-equals-3

Aw, Jeez, shut the fuck up, Jan. Arizona, I'm so sorry. gateley Apr 2012 #1
I think this just raised the iq of other states several points. This is beyond embarrassing. roguevalley Apr 2012 #21
When does Brewer's term end? hyphenate Apr 2012 #2
2014, with a term limit sofa king Apr 2012 #23
Thank you hyphenate Apr 2012 #34
This is a straight-D year if I ever saw one. sofa king Apr 2012 #43
Hahahahahahahaha! savannah43 Apr 2012 #3
How dare libruls claim a war on woman.... Grassy Knoll Apr 2012 #4
Wait SmileyRose Apr 2012 #5
geesh, I thought the R's love the Constitution & Roe v. Wade is constitutional wordpix Apr 2012 #6
Post removed Post removed Apr 2012 #7
so, do you think that is a good insult? Kali Apr 2012 #8
+1 Orrex Apr 2012 #10
thank you. La Lioness Priyanka Apr 2012 #12
Thanks for pointing that out, Kali. yardwork Apr 2012 #26
So, she has signed immaculate conception into law???? dixiegrrrrl Apr 2012 #9
My last period connecticut yankee Apr 2012 #11
Yes of course, you immoral hussy! Orrex Apr 2012 #15
Holy crap... christx30 Apr 2012 #44
If you're having sex and don't know it, then I blame your partner Orrex Apr 2012 #45
Let's assume all girls are pregnant as of their FIRST menstruation.... radhika Apr 2012 #13
Snark? No, not at all. This is the logical endpoint of their rationale. stubtoe Apr 2012 #30
Someone has to liberate Arizona with its own Freedom Summer. nt EFerrari Apr 2012 #14
How precocious of her! bluedigger Apr 2012 #16
So she really is as stupid as she looks, huh? Zoeisright Apr 2012 #17
So.... beac Apr 2012 #18
Then what of Deuteronomy 22:13-21? KansDem Apr 2012 #38
Nah, it's all part of their effort to bring back good, old-fashioned beac Apr 2012 #39
Election Year Politics OmahaBlueDog Apr 2012 #19
Okay, so this is fine as far as it goes... Permanut Apr 2012 #20
Arizona = New Texas. BlueIris Apr 2012 #22
Ejaculations are next on the list of things to ban. USA! USA! USA! sarcasmo Apr 2012 #24
Next up: Having a twinkle in your eye will be recognized as a life IDemo Apr 2012 #25
First we had Preventative War, now we have Preventative Legislation. patrice Apr 2012 #27
I'm pro-choice, and thankfully the majority of abortions are performed secondwind Apr 2012 #28
through the backdoor rms013 Apr 2012 #29
The backdoor is one way to keep Roe v Wade out of it! sofa king Apr 2012 #33
And she wants the Post Office to fund their retirement too! lonestarnot Apr 2012 #31
Next step is for them to outlaw menstrual cycles because of the death of a "potential" child. gtar100 Apr 2012 #32
Or, if menstruation must occur, last rites over the toilet each month. Vinca Apr 2012 #35
This woman hasn't had a sperm near her in decades..... secondwind Apr 2012 #36
I hate comments like this OKNancy Apr 2012 #41
Let me get this straight... KansDem Apr 2012 #37
Wow, what an opportunity. Think of the possibilities! freshwest Apr 2012 #46
So, technically, a woman can still be a virgin and yet be pregnant SwissTony Apr 2012 #40
Perhaps this will win Gov. Brewer the endorsement of "Ladies Against Women": Ken Burch Apr 2012 #42
.."common sense measures"!!!! MY ASS! and-justice-for-all Apr 2012 #47
Why doesn't she revise the value of pi while she's at it? Puzzler Apr 2012 #48
Umm....I know it sounds ridiculous - Ms. Toad Apr 2012 #49
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»Jan Brewer signs abortion...»Reply #48