General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsIf Trump were to win election, would you accept him as a legitimate President?
Would you accept as your President a criminal defendant with 91 charges against him? Sooner or later, he must stop saying he is the "victim".
Would you accept someone who stole military secrets and incited insurrection against our country? And has spoken out against the Constitution which defines our very being as a nation.
Do you think that guy would be a legitimate president?
I think the Republican Party needs to get its shit together. The people are not going to accept this criminal wannabe autocrat. Be careful what you wish for, you just might get it?
Personally, I could not accept him as the Leader of our Country. That is just one opinion.
If he were to win, it would be a most divisive and angry victory.
How that would manifest itself, I do not know.
samplegirl
(11,555 posts)The man should be behind bars.
Goddessartist
(1,931 posts)He will not win! So mote it be!
Bettie
(16,175 posts)that I could. I can not envision him winning legitimately. I really can't.
Two far-right leaders just won national elections in the past week, one in Argentina and one in The Netherlands.
brooklynite
(95,254 posts)If he meets the eligibility requirements and is elected within the format of our Constitutional system he's a legitimate President. What I think about him personally is irrelevant.
kentuck
(111,111 posts)Would be my guess.
brooklynite
(95,254 posts)As President he can appoint officials, nominate Judges and implement national policies that you'll have to live with, whether you recognize his authority or not.
kentuck
(111,111 posts)What kind of country would we be defending?
Que Sera, Sera?
brooklynite
(95,254 posts)It is.
I deal with reality, not hopes and dreams.
kentuck
(111,111 posts)That is one opinion. I suppose the same would apply to you?
brooklynite
(95,254 posts)If the point was to have everyone agree that we hate Trump, that should have been clearer.
kentuck
(111,111 posts)And people will take sides, be it wise or not.
In my opinion, some will not be agreeable to accepting whatever happens as "legitimate". I personally could not accept Trump as "my president". And whether he wins by hook or crook, is irrelevant to me. I am almost certain the other side feels the same way about Joe Biden.
As an added point, when did it become acceptable to threaten prosecutors and officers of the court and anyone except witnesses in a possible trial?
It seems to me it should be illegal to threaten anybody?
Should the 14th Amendment be taken literally?
It's almost as if the Justice System itself is on trial?
PJMcK
(22,126 posts)Whether or not I personally accept Trump as a legitimate president is irrelevant. Consider the dead-enders who dont accept President Bidens legitimacy. They have next to no influence in the policies and actions taken by the President.
Were Trump re-elected an unthinkable tragedy! he would hold the office and I assure you, he wont give a damn what anyone else thinks. His legitimacy would be the least of our concerns.
If that calamity occurs, well probably move overseas.
kentuck
(111,111 posts)First, they came for the communists....
When do people make a stand?
tritsofme
(17,477 posts)Are you advocating for Democrats run their own J6? I know we saw a OP to that affect earlier this week. Just trying to understand your suggestion.
brush
(54,085 posts)before exporting them. I doubt it'll be long before he gets around to progressives and others on the left. I'm pretty sure the extreme maga zealots keep tabs on left-leaning web sites, including DU.
He's also said he'd jail top military officers and to execute Gen. Milley specifically.
Once the executions start, who knows when their blood lust will be satisfied with Steven Miller playing the role of Robespierre (who eventually got it himself IIRC).
Ms. Toad
(34,191 posts)Either we believe in the rule of law, or we don't. I want nothing to do with those who reject the rule of law - regardless of whether they support or oppose trump.
Your arguments sound like the arguments of those charged in Georgia, who still refuse to recognize the legitimacy of Biden's win.
NJCher
(35,914 posts)your unpopular opinions which nearly always lack nuance.
Never mind the fact that no one can agree on what "reality" is, so it's your opinion of reality.
brooklynite
(95,254 posts)...they are, however, grounded in political reality, rather than community orthodoxy.
If Trump is duly elected, Majority Leader Schumer and Speaker Jeffries will do what then can to counter his actions, but they won't claim he's "illegitimate".
Polybius
(15,587 posts)We're already 99.99% gonna be down a Senate seat in WV. If Trump wins, he likely pushes at least one or two more.
Bettie
(16,175 posts)relocate if it turns really bad and the connections/wealth to thrive no matter who is in charge.
Patton French
(815 posts)But, as repulsive as it is, its accurate.
Ferrets are Cool
(21,131 posts)brooklynite
(95,254 posts)womanofthehills
(8,837 posts)Polls that include independents are concerning.
PJMcK
(22,126 posts)In 2016, I was convinced there was no way Trump could win
Ive learned my lesson.
Ferrets are Cool
(21,131 posts)mahatmakanejeeves
(57,918 posts)Thu Nov 16, 2023: The most popular choice in 2016 was "did not vote," with
471 electoral college votes. Clinton would have come in a distant second, with 51 electoral college votes, and Trump an even more distant third, with 16 electoral college votes, carrying only Iowa and Wisconsin.
Source: https://brilliantmaps.com/did-not-vote/
BlueTsunami2018
(3,528 posts)So it doesnt matter if hes accepted or not, he would be the President.
Half the people didnt accept President Obama as legitimate, half didnt accept W. They were still the President.
womanofthehills
(8,837 posts)He is a Republican obsession.
Mariana
(14,864 posts)someone will finally prove that he wasn't eligible to be President, and then all of his eight years in office will somehow be reversed.
ProudMNDemocrat
(17,013 posts)onenote
(42,948 posts)Do those that say they won't accept him as a "legitimate president" intend to file lawsuits challenging his election? File lawsuits challenging every action he takes? Refuse to obey any law he signs, orders issued by judges or agencies he appoints?
Not sure I understand the point of the question.
brush
(54,085 posts)Sec. 3 but we're lacking judges who have the guts to enforce it, as what just happened in Colorado.
spanone
(136,034 posts)betsuni
(25,956 posts)Charging Triceratops
(175 posts)The ONLY way he has a chance of winning is through the asinine Electoral College system, which is a total fraud.
brooklynite
(95,254 posts)You can also claim that its "illegitimate", but its the process we follow until someone changes the Constitution.
milestogo
(16,829 posts)When he won in 2016 people marched around saying "not my president". It didn't change anything.
LymphocyteLover
(5,690 posts)but that's not going to happen. It just won't
if..fish..had..wings
(671 posts)However, "legitimate" is a Republican word. The person who got the most votes is, simply, the President.
Oh, I would also hang myself.
NJCher
(35,914 posts)chouchou
(676 posts)brush
(54,085 posts)ones in the nation as witnessed by her recent exhortation to her millions of social media followers to register to vote. And thousands did.
Be glad she's on our side.
chouchou
(676 posts)She's a popular brand and that's fine.
MorbidButterflyTat
(1,918 posts)Travis Kelce has bad hair but he and Taylor together are heartwarming. IMO.
Plus she gets her fans MOTIVATED to vote!
She's awesome.
Ponietz
(3,102 posts)Last edited Fri Nov 24, 2023, 11:51 AM - Edit history (1)
Some here have a too narrow definition of lawful or legitimate. Myopically focusing on the election result ignores that the very foundations of our criminal justice system were undermined to permit it.
I OWE NO ALLEGIANCE TO THAT.
Zambero
(8,985 posts)Whether the U.S. is still a legitimate democracy.
kentuck
(111,111 posts)Thanks for that recognition.
brush
(54,085 posts)tavernier
(12,461 posts)which is very uncertain. But if that was the case, yes, I would have to. Theres an old saying that people get the leadership they deserve, so perhaps our country needs a little dose of what it deserves before it can fix itself.
Raven
(13,919 posts)feel I would have to accept it because, after all, that is what we have stood for. So, I would grieve for the US and probably start packing my bags.
Polybius
(15,587 posts)Would you count that as winning legitimately?
tritsofme
(17,477 posts)Polybius
(15,587 posts)I just wanted to see if you would count it, not if it was legally legitimate.
tritsofme
(17,477 posts)It would be extremely frustrating, but it is still winning under the rules.
We already know that they cheat on that and admit it
EX500rider
(10,903 posts)There have been four elections in which the person elected president won the electoral vote, but lost the popular vote (1876, 1888, 2000, and 2016)
Polybius
(15,587 posts)Did someone say it was only once? I'm not seeing that post.
EX500rider
(10,903 posts)Then this case would be so also, the winner is who the EC picks.
Polybius
(15,587 posts)Yet some say an EC winner who loses the popuar vote is illegitimate. I completely disagree with them, that's why I asked the question.
Shrek
(3,990 posts)Other than 270 electoral votes?
Where can I find these criteria and who enumerated them?
Ponietz
(3,102 posts)All is lost without it.
Demsrule86
(68,977 posts)womanofthehills
(8,837 posts)Can we win without Michigan??
Just asking!!
NPR - In Michigan, where every vote counts, Arab Americans are turning away from Biden
https://www.npr.org/2023/11/17/1213668804/arab-americans-michigan-voters-biden-israel-hamas-palestinians
ExWhoDoesntCare
(4,741 posts)It's a year out. Panicking and predicting the end of the world based on iffy polls at this point makes zero sense.
Ritabert
(684 posts)Voltaire2
(13,441 posts)KPN
(15,697 posts)will be equally if not more so should he win in 2024. I never viewed him as a legitimate President the last time, but did not have a choice beyond my vote in 2016. Im afraid the same is true for 2024. There is no option.
lees1975
(3,981 posts)I would hope that we have some judges who are willing to enforce the law, since he has been found guilty of insurrection, and prevent his name from appearing on the ballot, disqualifying his candidacy. Clearly, Republicans do not have the integrity or the character to stand up for what is right, so every possible effort must be made to make sure that as many of them are defeated as possible.
Quit playing games. Enforce the law.
But, I doubt we'll have to worry about this. He is NOT going to be elected.
a kennedy
(29,874 posts)Chainfire
(17,757 posts)The first on the list being that Democrats and progressives in general have become inconsequential. We would have to accept a single party system of government going forward. We would have to accept that the law and justice were two separate concepts, and that law enforcement is based on a sliding scale based on the wealth and power of the individual. We would have to accept that as a group, we were in danger for our heresy for denying the new President of the proper reverence; past and present. We would have to accept an acceleration of the transfer of wealth from the workers to the wealthy. We would have to learn to accept policies like, Night and Fog, punishment without trial and forced relocations. We would have to accept concentration camps and mass executions, persecution of women and minorities, death sentences for those who's sexual preference did not fit the new standards. We would have to accept a new national policy of forced religions; those religions that the government approved.
Trump, and his far-right friends, have told us what their goals are and we damn well better believe them.
bluestarone
(17,220 posts)I, as an American citizen have got to accept it. Now, if i see him start to commit to the things he says he WILL do, i got to look further at how to stop his BULLSHIT. Cross that bridge when we get to it.
GreenEyedLefty
(2,073 posts)Because he can only become president when good people fail to turn out to vote, vote third party, vote for a phony write in, or some other bullshit.
If he becomes president, we only have ourselves to blame.
brush
(54,085 posts)bloviating, near-senile, wannabe dictator criminal insurrectionist. You'd think the magats even could do better.
doc03
(35,516 posts)in 2016.
DemocratInPa
(393 posts)I would start to really question the Democratic Party and it's leadership..
This election should not be close and if Trump wins it means Dems stayed home on Election Day which means the Dems messaging was awful.
If Trump does win and it's a fair election, I just don't know how anyone can not accept him as President as sad as it sounds. Remember how mad we got when Repubs did this to Biden in 2020.
Aristus
(66,633 posts)or smear shit on the walls of the Capitol Building, if thats what youre asking.
Im an American citizen and patriot, not a red state traitor. I managed to get through four years of Trumps one and only term without breaking any laws, or even any civic ordinances.
I could probably do it again, but God willing, we wont be forced to go through that horror a second time.
Dan
(3,602 posts)But, because he has threatened my life and freedom.
sinkingfeeling
(51,539 posts)Maeve
(42,346 posts)Put the house on the market, up and leave. It wouldn't be my country anymore, not the democracy it has tried to be, not a place I can give allegiance to. And not a community I'd want to belong to.
That said, I believe we won't go down that path. I still have faith in the justice system and in my fellow Americans (especially the younger generations).
InAbLuEsTaTe
(24,131 posts)LiberalFighter
(51,664 posts)FelineOverlord
(3,617 posts)I will NEVER accept him in power ever again.
Army Brat
(151 posts)That's really just rhetoric on the part of a president's opponents
Enoki33
(1,590 posts)legitimate about tRump, l could never accept him as anything more than the head of a criminal organization and ruling junta. Self respect would dictate nothing more.
RobertDevereaux
(1,862 posts)mahatmakanejeeves
(57,918 posts)On November 27, 2020, three weeks after he lost reelection, Trump sent a nomination to the Senate.
Sat Nov 28, 2020: One Nomination Sent to the Senate; November 27, 2020
prairierose
(2,145 posts)Progressive dog
(6,940 posts)totodeinhere
(13,059 posts)However I doubt if he would care if I accept him or not. As long as he were inaugurated as president our country would be in big trouble whether I accepted him or not.
onenote
(42,948 posts)Did you challenge his election as illegitimate? Did you challenge his appointments as ultra vires? Did you refuse to obey laws he signed or orders of agencies and courts with his appointees?
Or is not "accepting" as meaningless as it seems to be.
kentuck
(111,111 posts)Does that mean you have to lead a revolt against his "government"? Otherwise, it is nothing more than a statement and therefore, meaningless?
In a democracy, no one can govern without the consent of the governed.
onenote
(42,948 posts)what does it mean to not "recognize" his presidency since you apparently are recognizing the legitimacy of the actions he takes as president.
Which is why not "recognizing" him as president is meaningless if one behaves as if the actions taken by him as president are legitimate.
kentuck
(111,111 posts)Perhaps I might be the only person in America that would think that way?
I would not support any violent means to overthrow him, such as attacking the Capitol or over-running the Secret Service at the White House.
I do not think words are meaningless.
onenote
(42,948 posts)you will refuse to abide by it?
If he signs an appropriations bill, you will refuse to have anything to do with the government agencies that are funded by that 'illegitimate" act?
kentuck
(111,111 posts)But I fear that is the direction we are headed.
In my opinion, if Trump were to win under these present conditions, the biggest loser would be the Democratic Party. If you cannot defend our democracy, what value are you?
onenote
(42,948 posts)I will defend our democracy by challenging and fighting, using the constitutional and statutory tools available, against specific actions he takes that threaten that democracy.
That's not refusing to accept him as president, it's opposing specific actions with which i disagree and have a basis for challenging.
kentuck
(111,111 posts)But that is an assumption, not a guarantee.
If he can beat the legal system on these charges presently against him, I doubt that further legal recourse would succeed.
In my opinion, there will be no second chances if we do not save democracy this time around.
claudette
(3,650 posts)and have less now, if that is possible.
kentuck
(111,111 posts)In 2016, he had not yet tried to overthrow an election or a coup, and had not stolen military secrets, etc, etc.
Much has happened since 2016.
totodeinhere
(13,059 posts)as it affected my state of mind and my resolve to support his opponent when he ran for reelection.
GuppyGal
(1,748 posts)North Shore Chicago
(3,389 posts)others who say I am more concerned about the 30% who wash his smelly, moldy feet.
Absolutely NOT!
And DU is one place I don't have to explain my answer.
Prairie_Seagull
(3,370 posts)As we approach the election season for real, I suppose I will be able to kick the can no longer. Until then, I suppose I will remain passport prepared and blissfully ignorant.
tritsofme
(17,477 posts)Or is this just some kind of fashion statement?
If he were to win by legitimate means, whether you or I accept it is completely meaningless.
kentuck
(111,111 posts)I think he should be disqualified by the 14th Amendment. What was he doing for 187 minutes as the Capitol was being ransacked?
How can he be "legitimate"?
We see already that the law does not apply to him in the same way as you or I. There is nothing fair or "democratic" about an election with him on the ballot, in my opinion.
tritsofme
(17,477 posts)My question still stands. Would you support a coup?
Or is not accepting just some sort of emotional reaction meant to signify your displeasure?
kentuck
(111,111 posts)If he finds a way around 91 charges, then somewhere our democracy has failed.
As for "emotional reaction", I think that is where almost everyone is at this time. As to how it might manifest itself if he is declared the winner of the next election, I do not know.
However, I do think it would be the Democratic Party that would pay the political price.
tritsofme
(17,477 posts)kentuck
(111,111 posts)But I would support non-violent actions by all means necessary to stop his dictatorial and autocratic agenda.
If you do not have a democracy, why would you be voting for Democrats?
If Trump were to win, politics would not carry on as usual.
Bayard
(22,343 posts)Is the same thing MAGAts were saying about Biden's win.
How do we determine a, "legitimate," election anymore? I do think Democracy is lost if the orange sleazeball gets in the White House again.
kentuck
(111,111 posts)How can you lose your democracy in a fair and legitimate election?
Bayard
(22,343 posts)Democracy is lost if trump is installed again, whether the election is legitimate or not. We suspect Putin gave him a lot of help last time, but there was no solid proof to prove it was an illegitimate election. There is solid proof that Biden won fair and square, but his minions refuse to believe it
Never did before and never will ever.
Polybius
(15,587 posts)Who should becomes President, Biden or his running mate?
LudwigPastorius
(9,349 posts)Polybius
(15,587 posts)It would be up to the SC, as there would be huge lawsuits everywhere.
LudwigPastorius
(9,349 posts)Polybius
(15,587 posts)Not what WILL happen, since that would be up to the SC. I think I'll do a topic on this.
https://www.democraticunderground.com/100218478735
brush
(54,085 posts)Last edited Fri Nov 24, 2023, 04:21 PM - Edit history (2)
If he does somehow steal another election there would be nothing to be done but wait for the round-up of progressives that's bound to come as I don't have the wherewithal to emigrate.
David__77
(23,721 posts)One need not concede or accept anything at all. On the other hand, if someone breaks a specific law, they can be prosecuted.
BigDemVoter
(4,161 posts)Not that my opinion matters, but he should not be eligible to even run again under any circumstance after having committed treason. I cannot accept a traitor as a 'legitimate' president.
republianmushroom
(14,126 posts)Sure wouldn't like it, but, that's the way it would be.
Paywall
Why are U.S. courts afraid of the 14th Amendment? Because its radical.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2023/11/24/us-courts-fear-14th-amendment-radical/?utm_campaign=wp_post_most&utm_medium=email&utm_source=newsletter&wpisrc=nl_most
LudwigPastorius
(9,349 posts)He will always be a criminal and a traitor in my eyes, but I only get one vote.
Marthe48
(17,214 posts)bush over Kerry? traitor over Secretary Clinton?
No. No. No.
When the FBI went after the mafia in the 1960s, I rooted for the FBI. I was glad when the FBI and other law enforcement worked tirelessly to find proof and arrest the mafia leaders trying to take over city, state and national finance and governance. I think the criminals finally found the soft underbelly of our rule of law and are working their way up to choke this country to death.
I'm not interested in being led by criminals. This last year, I learned on a personal level that people lie if it benefits them and other people are willing to believe the lies. If having criminals in control will benefit a rwnj, they will be glad to not only accept criminals lies as true, but also prop up the big lies with all the little lies that help them make a reality they like better than what is true.
Poiuyt
(18,141 posts)But I would seriously question what had happened to America.
(Actually, I do that now).
Kennah
(14,403 posts)His crimes are numerous, and his pursuit of chaos rivals that of Q and Lore (of ST TNG fame).
We don't, as voters, get election acceptance cards, but your question of how this would manifest is important.
Bottom line, I don't know. There are no doubt other scenarios, but broadly, I see two options.
1) The US devolves [further] into something resembling Gilead
2) The US devolves into inaction because mid-level bureaucrats in the civilian and military branches of government say no to Trump's attempt to overthrow Democracy
I'm about 50/50 on which way we go.
LW1977
(1,240 posts)SWBTATTReg
(22,350 posts)Congress on 1/6 is more evidence of his insurrection, although I don't understand the Colorado judge's ruling, they are appealing this.
In any event, the numbers are against tRUMP winning again anyways. Sure, tRUMP got his crowd still, but the numbers of such people are shrinking by the day, as some of them leave in disgust.
And, a lot of people do remember what he was like during the four years he was here (which was not much, and he refused to acknowledge COVID, or do anything about it, so in short, he made it worse, and probably caused the deaths of more Americans then necessary.
The only thing I recall was that he gave himself a tax cut. That's it. He's in it for solely himself. Slimebag.
Bludogdem
(93 posts)And, If the hugely unlikely occurs and tfg gets to 270, then our democratic republic will manage. Wont be easy but well manage. I doubt there will be a republican Congress to provide support. We dealt with it once, we can do it again.
marble falls
(58,018 posts)Bludogdem
(93 posts)Have his own airplane.
Trueblue1968
(17,260 posts)liberalla
(9,300 posts)B.See
(1,445 posts)ecstatic
(32,843 posts)To make sure that doesn't happen. I cannot go through that again. I won't go through that again.
I know it's going to be really tough haul because I talked to with quite a few idiots on Thanksgiving. I'm not talking about maggots either--I'm talking about women who should know better.
Between now and next spring, I am going to write a booklet that will be distributed to all my friends and family that will lay out every reason why trump and the republican party is dangerous and why we can't stay home next fall.
gulliver
(13,215 posts)We need to make sure Biden is elected, though. Trump is cracked. Say hello to chaos if he is reelected.
Arazi
(6,829 posts)Our country has enough brainwashed folks Id believe it if he won again. The numbers are too tight for me to hope theyre wrong. The fact is, hes massively popular on the right.
Our chances to beat him rest on slim margins (that are being eroded daily by the economy doomers, the I/P bashers - Genocide Joe ffs?! - and those who are falling for R lies about Hunters business shenanigans).
So yes I believe in our election system but if he wins Id make plans to move out of the country. I dont think we could save democracy here if he wins another term
Model35mech
(1,647 posts)before I can answer that, because that ruling would be critical in my analysis of his potential 'legitimacy', as well as that of the probable civil unrest which will follow his 'election'.
ArnoldLayne
(2,071 posts)roamer65
(36,749 posts)I will support Michigan secession.
Kaleva
(36,478 posts)Will we follow in the footsteps of the Magahats and believe that Biden is still President?
vapor2
(1,269 posts)i would join the protests which would certainly erupt nationwide.