Who here thinks Pink Floyd should get back together??

[I_like_chicken]

Its about damned time Roger Waters and David Gilmore settle their petty differences and have a reunion tour so I can get stoned and listen to them play live, damnit!

[Nicholas D Wolfwood]

1. No.

Haven't we all had enough of over the hill rockers getting back together for endless "our drug money ran out" tours???

[I_like_chicken]

3. my answer is no

how can we ever have enough over the hill rockers getting back together for endless "our drug money ran out" tours??

my hunger is insatiable.

well actually, i dont really care about anyother band, just Pink Floyd.

[flamingyouth]

2. Only if Syd Barrett joins them

[indigobusiness]

5. that would be wacky cool...

even for a studio album.

[carpetbagger]

4. Dude, it's over.

Remember the South Park episode with Rod Stewart demented and in a wheelchair? We're there. Pink Gilmour hasn't put out an album in almost a decade, and the last one was about two minutes of brilliance surrounded by 40 minutes of filler. Waters had his day, and has had plenty of opportunity to tour his little Wall thing.

The last time I saw Pink Floyd was 1987 or 88. That was more than 15 years ago. Even with Roger Waters, you've got old men, and they're just not playing music that would play well by people with gravely voices. Sure they could tour forever, but they will become more machine than man.

However, Pink Floyd Live At Pompeii is out on DVD. They will therefore live forever in the ashes.

[realisticphish]

11. that's a great performance

"We're not a drug oriented band. You can trust us"

[realisticphish]

6. not sure

only if they didn't charge ridiculus prices for the tickets; that always pisses me off on these reunion tours.

[matcom]

7. Fuck Waters

Gilmore has carried the torch

Waters is a fucking prick.

screw him

[stavka]

8. Have to disagree, I'm a RW fan....let's vote.

[matcom]

10. i vote no

Waters was a fucking PRICK when he broke the band up. Gilmore is a FAR better musician and MUCH more the gentleman

fuck Waters

[I_like_chicken]

12. i agree

but i think its the synergistic energy between the two that made pink floyd so great

[indigobusiness]

9. Maybe Yoko could get them back together...

it could happen.

[No2W2004]

13. Won't ever happen.

Gilmore is happy now living on his boat and sessioning once in a while with his buddies. Nick Mason played drums with Roger during one of the last stops on Waters tour last year. Waters has only done sporadic recording since Amused to Death came out. The song he did for "The Legend of 1900" was very good, and had Eddie Van Halen doing the obligatory guitar solo. He's also been working on an opera for over 10 years now :eyes:

Pink Floyd really stopped being ground breaking after "The Wall", and yes, I do think "The Final Cut" was a great album. It wasn't different, thats all. I'm watching the Pompeii DVD as I type. That's really when Pink Floyd was a creative force. If they toured now, it would only be so they could rake in the cash from geezers like me.