Reply #3: I have one dog eating Wellness and the other on Hill's Prescription I/D

[magellan]

Neither have been recalled. But MenuFoods does make some Wellness product and the feline Hill's M/D is now on recall, so let's just say I'm unhappy with both Wellness and Hill's Prescription at this point.

I've ordered Chicken Soup for the Dog Lover's Soul brand and will be seeing our vet next week to work out an alternative for the Hill's I/D. I want to know specifically what the Hill's I/D supplies that another brand won't because as far as protein/fat/fiber/moisture content, I see little difference between the I/D and the reduced calorie Chicken Soup kibble. And unlike I/D, the Chicken Soup brand doesn't have CRAP in it.