Reply #165: EVERYONE saw it move and EVERYONE ...

[plaguepuppy]

Glad to hear that all your invisible playmates are in agreement on this one. EVERYONE must talk to you quite often, or else your psychic talents are very finely tuned to allow you to know what EVERYONE was thinking.

But it still doesn't pass the simplest test of logic: There is some unspecified damage at ground level (though none is actually documented there), and suddenly 600 feet above the east 1/4 of the penthouse falls, but only till it is level with the roof, with no movement at all of the rest of the building. What exactly carries this mysterious "failure" up 47 stories without affecting anything in between? Is there a sliding rectangle of columns on tracks that runs up the east side of the building to hold the east penthouse up?

All in all it sounds more like a Chinese puzzle box than a steel-frame building. We're not talking about the top moving because the whole building moves, we're talking about an independent movement of a small portion at the very top of the building not related to any dropping or hypothetical shaking of the whole building.

Hint: repeating a dumb argument several times, with more sarcasm and a LOUD VOICE, doesn't make it any more convincing. And whatever the hell it's supposed to mean, I'm not your "dear chumbly."


http://home.comcast.net/~jeffrey.king2/wsb/html/view.cgi-home.html-.html