Reply #2: Tony Judt and Omer Bartov.

[gottaB]

Here is a reprint of Bartov's essay which was published in The New Republic: Did Hitlerism Die with Hitler?

Here is Tony Judt's piece, which serves a reply of sorts, written for The Nation: Goodbye to all that?

While Judt left a couple of Bartov's points unanswered, and presented a few questionable assertions as fact, his basic arguments are reasonable and decently supported. He offers some insights, and asks good questions. I don't entirely agree with the conclusions he draws, but they do merit serious consideration. Glick's characterization of him and this article in particular seem unfair.