Reply #4: Dude, it's over.

[carpetbagger]

Remember the South Park episode with Rod Stewart demented and in a wheelchair? We're there. Pink Gilmour hasn't put out an album in almost a decade, and the last one was about two minutes of brilliance surrounded by 40 minutes of filler. Waters had his day, and has had plenty of opportunity to tour his little Wall thing.

The last time I saw Pink Floyd was 1987 or 88. That was more than 15 years ago. Even with Roger Waters, you've got old men, and they're just not playing music that would play well by people with gravely voices. Sure they could tour forever, but they will become more machine than man.

However, Pink Floyd Live At Pompeii is out on DVD. They will therefore live forever in the ashes.