Reply #18: I didn't get the "theme" last night

[blue_onyx]

They said contestants had to pick songs that were popular downloads so we could see how they would fit in the "current" music environment. Yet, Megan picked Bob Marley, Anoop sang a 5 year old Usher song, Allison sang a 13 year old No Doubt song. Matt was the only one to sing a recent song and he did a pretty bad job, IMO. I original heard that the Idols would have to pick from the Top 100 songs on iTunes...that would've been a better theme.

Allison didn't do great but I still think she sounded pretty good. I wouldn't be surprised to see Megan leave but I think she may stick around another week. Anoop was so bad and weird. Kara was right...it almost seemed like he was doing it as a joke. Does he not know how ridiculous he looked? I think the judges were wrong about his vocals....they weren't very good.