Democratic Underground

Ask Auntie Pinko
August 9, 2001


Dear Auntie Pinko,

If the Republicans are good for business, why is my 401(k), which is 80% invested in stocks, doing so poorly?

Investor,
San Jose, CA


Dear Investor,

You brave soul! Asking Auntie Pinko to interpret the mysteries of Higher Finance is somewhat akin to casting the bones or examining sheep entrails, at least in terms of analytical reliability.

However, Auntie loves a challenge. I phoned up one of my many nieces and nephews who is a professional financial advisor and has worked as a fund manager for the Calvert Fund, and here is what she tells me:

While it's possible to make well-informed predictions about how any individual stock might perform in a given future period, the factors that influence "the Market," as a whole, are so many and varied that you might just as well take your money to the race track or the casino as attempt to make reliable predictions en masse, as it were.

Those of you who are familiar with the financial markets probably already know all this, but I'm so tickled to have learned about something new that you'll just have to indulge me. In any case, my charming young niece (she's single, by the way, loves dogs and lives in the Chicago area�) says that one of the strongest factors in whether "the market" gains money or loses it, is something called "confidence."

This is not, apparently, the kind of confidence Auntie Pinko is familiar with-a belief in one's own abilities and effectiveness-rather, it's the belief by investors that the market will, or will not, "perform well."

This sounded a little odd to me, something like The Power Of Positive Thinking-believe in making money and you'll make money. But my niece says there's more to it than that, because of all the other factors that control how the market does. It sounds fascinating, and I am planning on using the e-links and book titles she gave me to further research this fascinating byway of human behavior.

However, just taking the concept of "confidence" and applying it to your situation, Investor, might provide a clue to the lamentable performance of your portfolio. Obviously, there is a distinct lack of confidence somewhere, even among those Republican business moguls who control so much of our economic destiny.

Can it be that they lack confidence in the ability of our leaders to lead?

It does seem ironic, doesn't it, that one of the longest (and strongest) "bull markets" in living memory occurred under the auspices of Mr. Clinton's Administration. Obviously, there is more to this "confidence" thing than meets the eye.

Auntie Pinko will update you as she learns more, and thank you for writing!


Printer-friendly version
Tell a friend about this article Tell a friend about Auntie Pinko
Discuss this article

View Auntie's Archive

Do you have a question for Auntie Pinko?

Do political discussions discombobulate you? Are you a liberal at a loss for words when those darned dittoheads babble their endless rhetoric at you? Or are you a conservative who just can't understand those pesky liberals and their silliness? Auntie Pinko has an answer for everything! So ask away!

My name is:

My hometown is:

My email address is:

And here is my question: