Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
2016 Postmortem
In reply to the discussion: This email passed through HRC unsecured server twice. [View all]EndElectoral
(4,213 posts)45. This goes to the unfettered access of Blumenthal to the Clintons. See link below.
While not a fan of the Observer, it does detail aspects of who exactly Blumenthal is and how his access to Clintons is troubling to put it mildly.
http://observer.com/2015/11/just-who-is-sidney-blumenthal-the-clintons-closest-advisor/
Tina Brown, who hired Mr. Blumenthal at The New Yorker because he was close to the Clintons, later allegedly canned him for being too close to the Clintons.
To cite another striking example, Mr. Blumenthal sent then-Secretary of State Ms. Clinton reports on the political situation in Libya written by a former senior CIA officer, the recently deceased Tyler Drumheller. Those reports, which Mr. Blumenthal emailed to her in 2011 and 2012, apparently were intended to influence American policy toward Libya in a way favorable to a business project with which Mr. Blumenthal and Mr. Drumheller were involved.
Mr. Drumheller, who retired in 2005, was an incompetent head of the CIAs European division during the cold war and as Al Qaeda rose to prominence. And Europe was his primary area of expertise; he had no useful knowledge about Libya, multiple sources have told me. Tyler was probably just using information he got from his old retired friends in Italian intelligence, and all of those guys put their business interests ahead of everything else, one former senior CIA officer who knew Mr. Drumheller well said. Blumenthals the same way; theres something wrong with him morally.
According to The New York Times, the memos, written in the style of intelligence cables, make up about a third of the almost 900 pages of emails related to Libya that Ms. Clinton said she kept on the personal email account she used exclusively as secretary of state. (Note here that the Times story claimed Mr. Blumenthal had written the memos in question, when in fact he appears to have merely passed on Mr. Drumhellers work to Ms. Clinton.)
But put aside the whole issue of Benghazi and focus on a few other aspects of Sidney Blumenthals résumé and consider what it says about Ms. Clintons judgment that she considers him one of her closest advisors.
...
Going back to the Bill Clinton impeachment crisis, Mr. Blumenthal, then the presidents special adviser, spread false rumors that one of Kenneth Starrs prosecutors abused young boys at a Christian summer camp and that Monica Lewinsky was stalking the president. In 1995, Mr. Blumenthal told reporters that Alma Powell, Colin Powells wife, suffered from clinical depression and was thus unfit to be a first lady.
...
He encouraged the Clinton campaign to exploit Mr. Obamas relationship to Reverend Jeremiah Wright, and tried to push out to the media bogus stories about Mr. Obamas alleged ties to Louis Farrakhan.
...
When President Obama was running against Ms. Clinton in the 2008 Democratic primaries, Mr. Blumenthal sent dozens of anti-Obama articles from far-right publications to reporters and others, smearing Ms. Clintons rival. Much of what he sent was sub-conspiracy theory material and had no basis in fact. Mr. Blumenthal was also a proponent of playing the race card against President Obama in the most unsavory way.
...
Mr. Blumenthal was paid as a consultant at least $120,000 annually by the Clinton Foundation, though no one knows for sure how much he received because the foundations accounting procedures are shoddy. But whatever the amount, it was quite a tidy haul, and its not clear at all what work he performed for the foundation, or if the money was simply given to him as payment for past services performed for the Clinton family.
...
He was paid that money while he was offering Ms. Clinton unsolicited advice about Libya policywhich she passed around even after other administration officials concluded it was rubbishand when he was, according to the Times, also working on and off as a paid consultant to Media Matters and American Bridge, organizations that helped lay the groundwork for Ms. Clintons 2016 campaign. (Media Matters, which was founded by Blumenthal protégé and professional Clinton propagandist David Brock, pays him $200,000 annually, according to The New York Post.)
To cite another striking example, Mr. Blumenthal sent then-Secretary of State Ms. Clinton reports on the political situation in Libya written by a former senior CIA officer, the recently deceased Tyler Drumheller. Those reports, which Mr. Blumenthal emailed to her in 2011 and 2012, apparently were intended to influence American policy toward Libya in a way favorable to a business project with which Mr. Blumenthal and Mr. Drumheller were involved.
Mr. Drumheller, who retired in 2005, was an incompetent head of the CIAs European division during the cold war and as Al Qaeda rose to prominence. And Europe was his primary area of expertise; he had no useful knowledge about Libya, multiple sources have told me. Tyler was probably just using information he got from his old retired friends in Italian intelligence, and all of those guys put their business interests ahead of everything else, one former senior CIA officer who knew Mr. Drumheller well said. Blumenthals the same way; theres something wrong with him morally.
According to The New York Times, the memos, written in the style of intelligence cables, make up about a third of the almost 900 pages of emails related to Libya that Ms. Clinton said she kept on the personal email account she used exclusively as secretary of state. (Note here that the Times story claimed Mr. Blumenthal had written the memos in question, when in fact he appears to have merely passed on Mr. Drumhellers work to Ms. Clinton.)
But put aside the whole issue of Benghazi and focus on a few other aspects of Sidney Blumenthals résumé and consider what it says about Ms. Clintons judgment that she considers him one of her closest advisors.
...
Going back to the Bill Clinton impeachment crisis, Mr. Blumenthal, then the presidents special adviser, spread false rumors that one of Kenneth Starrs prosecutors abused young boys at a Christian summer camp and that Monica Lewinsky was stalking the president. In 1995, Mr. Blumenthal told reporters that Alma Powell, Colin Powells wife, suffered from clinical depression and was thus unfit to be a first lady.
...
He encouraged the Clinton campaign to exploit Mr. Obamas relationship to Reverend Jeremiah Wright, and tried to push out to the media bogus stories about Mr. Obamas alleged ties to Louis Farrakhan.
...
When President Obama was running against Ms. Clinton in the 2008 Democratic primaries, Mr. Blumenthal sent dozens of anti-Obama articles from far-right publications to reporters and others, smearing Ms. Clintons rival. Much of what he sent was sub-conspiracy theory material and had no basis in fact. Mr. Blumenthal was also a proponent of playing the race card against President Obama in the most unsavory way.
...
Mr. Blumenthal was paid as a consultant at least $120,000 annually by the Clinton Foundation, though no one knows for sure how much he received because the foundations accounting procedures are shoddy. But whatever the amount, it was quite a tidy haul, and its not clear at all what work he performed for the foundation, or if the money was simply given to him as payment for past services performed for the Clinton family.
...
He was paid that money while he was offering Ms. Clinton unsolicited advice about Libya policywhich she passed around even after other administration officials concluded it was rubbishand when he was, according to the Times, also working on and off as a paid consultant to Media Matters and American Bridge, organizations that helped lay the groundwork for Ms. Clintons 2016 campaign. (Media Matters, which was founded by Blumenthal protégé and professional Clinton propagandist David Brock, pays him $200,000 annually, according to The New York Post.)
The email in the op's writer from Blumenthal specifically gives a pertinent example of a man accountable to no one and unappointed can directly modify decisions at the highest levels of government.
Just one more example on the Mt. Everest pile of HRC's poor judgments.
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
72 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
Raises the question of the sources and methods used to gather this "confidential"
leveymg
May 2016
#1
Yes, that was reported last August. File labeled as unclassified was “TOP SECRET//SI//TK//NOFORN”
leveymg
May 2016
#44
So sickening. No wonder the delight over the (gruesome) end of Qaddafi that was displayed in that
bjo59
May 2016
#3
So what, she's just discussing how to get her hands on some gold. Big deal.
Major Hogwash
May 2016
#6
Reads like that Nigerian prince spam that asks for your ssn and money.
Baitball Blogger
May 2016
#17
Gee, if I was running a keyword search of IP addresses, clintonemail.com wouldn't interest me
leveymg
May 2016
#46
Hopefully, none of these emails were in clear text, that they were encrypted payloads.
TheBlackAdder
May 2016
#24
It's not the facts that are as sensitive as how the info was collected and by whom (HUMINT)
leveymg
May 2016
#47
There's the backstory of no-bid State Dept contracts with Blackwater/Xe that Osprey was angling for
leveymg
May 2016
#49
Blumenthal, Davis, and Bennett Ratcliff were all selling clients their connection to Clinton
MisterP
May 2016
#63
This goes to the unfettered access of Blumenthal to the Clintons. See link below.
EndElectoral
May 2016
#45
Still don't care. This was a wikileaks exposure after the fact. Still nothiing marked
Jitter65
May 2016
#72