Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
Gun Control & RKBA
In reply to the discussion: Please compare the Dem and GOP platforms re RKBA. Speculation welcome on how independent voters [View all]slackmaster
(60,567 posts)79. And now you have provided a perfect example of the Straw Man Fallacy
But yet you argue for a so-called "Pro-RKBA" view...
...that is nothing but a front for the unregulated proliferation of an assortment of deadly weapons to no purposeful end.
I believe I've stated my views on the subject of firearm law enough times in this group and previously in the Guns forum on DU2 that there is no excuse for another well-established user presenting such a grossly distorted representation of them, unless what you are really trying to do is "win" the discussion by pinning a manifestly unreasonable viewpoint on me.
You've presented a "view" of your own invention, given it a catchy name, then tried to attribute it to me.
You failed to tar me as an anti-choicer. You failed to hang "tax breaks for the wealthy" on me, and now you have failed to pin the straw man of "unregulated proliferation" on me.
Nice try. Maybe you could try ASKING me what I think about things first next time.
...that is nothing but a front for the unregulated proliferation of an assortment of deadly weapons to no purposeful end.
I believe I've stated my views on the subject of firearm law enough times in this group and previously in the Guns forum on DU2 that there is no excuse for another well-established user presenting such a grossly distorted representation of them, unless what you are really trying to do is "win" the discussion by pinning a manifestly unreasonable viewpoint on me.
You've presented a "view" of your own invention, given it a catchy name, then tried to attribute it to me.
You failed to tar me as an anti-choicer. You failed to hang "tax breaks for the wealthy" on me, and now you have failed to pin the straw man of "unregulated proliferation" on me.
Nice try. Maybe you could try ASKING me what I think about things first next time.
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
99 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
Please compare the Dem and GOP platforms re RKBA. Speculation welcome on how independent voters [View all]
jody
Sep 2012
OP
Agree, I'm drinking a martini, my favorite from Vietnam days. Wish you were here to join me. nt
jody
Sep 2012
#2
Makes sense. Bubba Carville said "It's the economy, stupid" and the more things change the more they
jody
Sep 2012
#4
I think the platform authors feel stuck with it, like the GOP and their zygote personhood plank
slackmaster
Sep 2012
#8
The new AWB bans both and plenty of others too, such as the M-1 carbine.
GreenStormCloud
Sep 2012
#47
That is exactly why this nonsense must be nipped in the bud every time it comes back
slackmaster
Sep 2012
#63
Being anti-gun will lose you PA. Guns are more popular than Jesus here. If you know how popular
rDigital
Sep 2012
#14
In post #17 there is no connection between the upper half of your post and your last paragraph.
ellisonz
Sep 2012
#23
Wow --- maybe we should just adopt all the Republican positions so they can't attack us?
ellisonz
Sep 2012
#27
Your interlocutor seems to have found your questions inconvenient...
friendly_iconoclast
Sep 2012
#87
Who are you to declare that a Democrat isn't allowed to disagree with one or two items...
slackmaster
Sep 2012
#24
I'm sure you consulted with the people of Aurora on our failed gun control policy. n/t
ellisonz
Sep 2012
#38
The people of Aurora deserve exactly as much say on gun control policy as you and I do
slackmaster
Sep 2012
#62
What do you mean by " supposedly Democratic website"? Do you believe Democrats oppose the natural,
jody
Sep 2012
#34
You seem to connect NRA with pro-RKBA Democrat. NRA has less than 5 million mbrs and perhaps 80m or
jody
Sep 2012
#51
"To be quite honest, I think terms like "industrialized", "developed" etc. are out dated."
ellisonz
Sep 2012
#59
In 2008 Obama said "I believe in the Second Amendment. I believe in people's lawful right to bear
jody
Sep 2012
#65
There is no legal definition in Federal law for "Assault Weapon". You claim Obama supports something
jody
Sep 2012
#75
The President has been silent on the issue. Nobody here is trying to obstruct him on anything.
slackmaster
Sep 2012
#64
Because the law does NOT say people aren't allowed to own such a weapon, we do have that right
slackmaster
Sep 2012
#80
The self-appointed zampolits do tend to end up contradicting themselves, don't they?
friendly_iconoclast
Sep 2012
#88