Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

unblock

(52,208 posts)
108. billy joel is a mixed bag for me.
Wed Oct 31, 2018, 11:22 AM
Oct 2018

i really like his piano work, he puts some real talent into his rock songs.

too many rock piano players, like elton john, are actually quite talented but the piano playing in their songs are nothing impressive.
billy joel has some songs like that as well, of course, but he also has some songs that really show off his talent (root beer rag, e.g.)

his songs are generally a bit to schmaltzy for me, and the more rocking songs sound like he wants to be a tough, rough, bruce springsteen rocker but it just doesn't fit.

then again, there are a few gems in there, especially if you like composition. billy joel learned classical music and it shows in his songwriting.

root beer rag
and so it goes
goodnight saigon
if i only had the words (to tell you)
tell her about it -- great song, though it got way overplayed
the longest time
shameless
the downeaster "alexa"
this night (the melody in the chorus is from beethoven's pathetique)

Beatles and Stones. GemDigger Oct 2018 #1
You poor thing! 2naSalit Oct 2018 #5
Wow...ok. Docreed2003 Oct 2018 #6
My mother woke me up when I was sick and the Beatles were on Ed Sullivan and all I heard was GemDigger Oct 2018 #21
That makes total sense Docreed2003 Oct 2018 #25
Oh nice they hit you in the stomach too! Corvo Bianco Oct 2018 #104
Don't think I've ever known anyone who like rock but "can't stand" the beatles unblock Oct 2018 #24
Since I was 11 the sound of Beatles music makes me nauseous. Corvo Bianco Oct 2018 #103
Rush, Styx MontanaMama Oct 2018 #2
Whew...I expected to catch hell over Rush Docreed2003 Oct 2018 #3
IMO one of the best finishes. Go to 4:40. But I'm an old guy so. Snotcicles Oct 2018 #20
+1 Crutchez_CuiBono Oct 2018 #127
Supertramp, Styx, and ELO. LisaM Oct 2018 #34
Sheepishly raises hand Docreed2003 Oct 2018 #45
I do as well. The Polack MSgt Oct 2018 #56
ELO... Crutchez_CuiBono Oct 2018 #128
ditto - and most country music. nt spooky3 Oct 2018 #79
Styx I get but you should be sacrificed at the Temple of Syrinx tymorial Oct 2018 #65
I have several 2naSalit Oct 2018 #4
I never liked Neil Diamond either... Docreed2003 Oct 2018 #7
Yeah 2naSalit Oct 2018 #14
Lol...I can do an incredible over the top Neil Diamond voice Docreed2003 Oct 2018 #26
My spouse does a mean Neil Diamond. MontanaMama Oct 2018 #93
i rather like the monkees' "i'm a believer". unblock Oct 2018 #102
And the Monkees! 2naSalit Oct 2018 #106
yeah the monkees as a group were just another assembled, produced, product. unblock Oct 2018 #110
Adele. Mariah. Croney Oct 2018 #8
Oh man...this is a good one for discussion Docreed2003 Oct 2018 #10
I almost added Adele Merlot Oct 2018 #12
Mariah is to singing what Eddie Van Halen is to lead guitar unblock Oct 2018 #19
Agreed, Rush is like fingernails on a chalkboard Merlot Oct 2018 #9
If you ask Mike Love.... Docreed2003 Oct 2018 #11
You mean the 4 lads with sex appeal, a sense of humor, and a new take on music? Merlot Oct 2018 #15
Right??? Docreed2003 Oct 2018 #41
I once read where someone described the Beach Boys as Singing Golf Caddies. NBachers Oct 2018 #28
Actually if you're thinking Saturday nite Special that was really an anti handgun song lunasun Oct 2018 #82
In fairness to Skynyrd The Polack MSgt Oct 2018 #98
Ignoring the gun song, I don't like Skynyrd music at all, just find it annoying. Merlot Oct 2018 #99
I loved those guys in the 70s The Polack MSgt Oct 2018 #100
Southern Rock can be great....tho this thread is about worst Merlot Oct 2018 #101
Since Greg left us the best band in America is The Polack MSgt Oct 2018 #105
Neil Young. His voice just grates on me. n/t TygrBright Oct 2018 #13
I don't care for his voice but I love many of the songs he's written. 2naSalit Oct 2018 #17
My wife shares that same sentiment about Bob Dylan Docreed2003 Oct 2018 #30
This message was self-deleted by its author Duppers Oct 2018 #121
Shakira, and sometimes Christina Aguilera. I admit that they are both extremely talented but alwaysinasnit Oct 2018 #16
Agree Duppers Oct 2018 #122
Agree. Glamrock Oct 2018 #18
I love you bro... Docreed2003 Oct 2018 #37
Love the man,respect the talent. Glamrock Oct 2018 #61
Nah I get it bro... Docreed2003 Oct 2018 #64
Musical tastes have no reason. Glamrock Oct 2018 #66
Got Your Back, Glam ProfessorGAC Nov 2018 #130
Thanks! Glamrock Nov 2018 #131
Bob Dylan unblock Oct 2018 #22
Totally agree. n/t luvs2sing Oct 2018 #69
The Grateful Dead. violetpastille Oct 2018 #23
JOURNEY The Polack MSgt Oct 2018 #27
They literally got a random dude to fill in on vocals Docreed2003 Oct 2018 #33
Tell us how you REALLY feel, Polack MSgt!! Ohiogal Oct 2018 #48
Bon Jovi JDC Oct 2018 #29
I'm not a huge fan either... Docreed2003 Oct 2018 #38
Best part of Bon Jovi was Richie Samborra The Polack MSgt Oct 2018 #52
Terrific Voice On Richie ProfessorGAC Nov 2018 #132
Billy Joel. LisaM Oct 2018 #31
Which is worse for you? violetpastille Oct 2018 #46
Oh God LisaM Oct 2018 #96
billy joel is a mixed bag for me. unblock Oct 2018 #108
Re-reading old threads in MA is a weakness of mine The Polack MSgt Nov 2018 #135
that's a good one -- he said it's composition is based on his bipolar disorder: unblock Nov 2018 #136
Foreigner, Michael Bolton, Michael McDonald, and, yes- Janis Joplin. Big Brother yes, Janis no. NBachers Oct 2018 #32
The 70's must have been a different time Docreed2003 Oct 2018 #50
The Beastie Boys agonizing Ponietz Oct 2018 #35
Twenty One Pilots... LW1977 Oct 2018 #36
Lmao...well played Docreed2003 Oct 2018 #49
I'll add another...Rod freaking Stewart Docreed2003 Oct 2018 #39
This! Adsos Letter Oct 2018 #51
Maroon Five n/t Stargleamer Oct 2018 #40
Nice modern act addition to the list Docreed2003 Oct 2018 #44
The three whiners: Neil Young, Bob Dylan & Tom Petty RainCaster Oct 2018 #42
Funny thing about Tom Petty - I wasn't ever pnwest Oct 2018 #109
The BeeGees ... yeah and Rush too RainCaster Oct 2018 #43
The Beach Boys Ohiogal Oct 2018 #47
i love their harmony, but they always seem so bored. unblock Oct 2018 #112
What Ohiogal Said ProfessorGAC Nov 2018 #133
I've been pretty clear about my disdain for what passes as "Country Music" these days The Polack MSgt Oct 2018 #53
The White Stripes Beaverhausen Oct 2018 #54
stares aghast The Polack MSgt Oct 2018 #57
Second that...love the white stripes Docreed2003 Oct 2018 #60
Can't stand Meg's drumming Beaverhausen Oct 2018 #70
i understand that The Polack MSgt Oct 2018 #72
It's been Carla Azar for the last three solo albums . She is drumming with him now on tour lunasun Oct 2018 #83
I did not see what everyone else was so enamored by when they were current cemaphonic Oct 2018 #95
Velvet Revolver. Crutchez_CuiBono Oct 2018 #55
The Right Brothers rusty quoin Oct 2018 #58
I guess if I included Toby Keith I can't tell you that only real musicians count. NT The Polack MSgt Oct 2018 #59
Just my sense of humor. rusty quoin Oct 2018 #94
Stones and the Eagles. tymorial Oct 2018 #62
and... 2naSalit Oct 2018 #63
Beatles Armymedic88 Oct 2018 #67
Michael McDonald.. luvs2sing Oct 2018 #68
Fleetwood Mac RazBerryBeret Oct 2018 #71
The voices of Geddy Lee and Neil Young. Cousin Dupree Oct 2018 #73
Neil is my all time favorite for 40 yrs MichMan Oct 2018 #119
I never liked Frank Sinatra mainstreetonce Oct 2018 #74
A couple The Genealogist Oct 2018 #75
On Board With Neil ProfessorGAC Nov 2018 #134
Kenny G. nt Grasswire2 Oct 2018 #76
Chicago. That's all I've got. dameatball Oct 2018 #77
Let me quote the dude Guppy Oct 2018 #78
This! Docreed2003 Oct 2018 #88
Holy shit! Duppers Oct 2018 #123
Aerosmith and ZZ Top exboyfil Oct 2018 #80
I love all the people/bands you list The Polack MSgt Oct 2018 #87
Such an interesting thread tparrett62 Oct 2018 #81
Billy Joel, The Eagles, Bruce Springsteen. And Dylan's last really great LP was Highway 61 Revisited argyl Oct 2018 #84
agree with knopfler vs. van halen 100% unblock Oct 2018 #114
The Eagles hibbing Oct 2018 #85
Pat Benatar (not sure if she's "loved"). I was tired of the Eagles until I saw them in concert underpants Oct 2018 #86
long list. country(NO TWANG!), eagles, neil diamond, the fucking grateful dead, the stones, pansypoo53219 Oct 2018 #89
Two Words: Pearl Jam Jake Stern Oct 2018 #90
Cher Ohiogal Oct 2018 #91
I enjoy Celine Dion's French songs but can't stand her English ones Jake Stern Oct 2018 #92
Beatles, Steely Dan, Led Zeppelin, Jamiroquai, damian marley, frank sinatra JHan Oct 2018 #97
Beatles & Jimmy Buffet. Both mostly due to pnwest Oct 2018 #107
interesting that the main objection seems to be the fans rather than the music or the artists. unblock Oct 2018 #115
Frank Zappa thucythucy Oct 2018 #111
His last live albums are called The Polack MSgt Oct 2018 #124
Musical spleen venting is fun solara Oct 2018 #113
Lol...I agree with a lot of your list. Docreed2003 Oct 2018 #117
I, too, was introduced to Rush by a guy who thought he had better musical tastes than anyone :) TeapotInATempest Oct 2018 #116
Chicago. They have been described as very talented, but I just didn't like the music. dameatball Oct 2018 #118
Rolling Stones, Foreigner, Joe Walsh MichMan Oct 2018 #120
A fair few London / Southern England bands The King of Prussia Oct 2018 #125
Led Zeppelin DBoon Oct 2018 #126
Doobie Brothers Jane Austin Nov 2018 #129
Latest Discussions»Culture Forums»Music Appreciation»Popular bands or artists ...»Reply #108