Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

thesquanderer

(12,552 posts)
21. To me, "virtually final" was a way to help explain the siginficance of this amendment being offered...
Tue Jul 2, 2024, 11:33 AM
Jul 2024

...i.e. that it was one of only two ways to "fix" the situation, neither of which is easy. Since the whole foundation of the article was the offering of this amendment, I think that was a fair point to make. I think it IS virtually (that is, "almost" ) final, it is indeed very hard to change it, it's certainly not something that will happen overnight, and these are the only paths to address it, only one of which is even conceivably under our control, at least as long as the current justices are sitting on the court.

Your additional idea of legislation is interesting, though also challenging without control of both houses, and I think, itself, possibly not immune from being struck down by the same court, if challenged...?

But tough as it may be, we have to keep trying to find ways to fight bad decisions. Sometimes bad decisions do ultimately get reversed, even if it takes many years. (I'm hoping I live long enough to see a reversal on Citizens United.)

Even a proposed constitutional amendment that seems likely to go nowhere serves a purpose, in promoting awareness, and maybe, eventually, success. I mean, we still haven't given up on the ERA.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Add to the amendment an ethics code, 18 year term limits and other sensible reforms Pepsidog Jul 2024 #1
Not IF, but when. aeromanKC Jul 2024 #2
Visibility is beneficial even if it's going nowhere now. /nt bucolic_frolic Jul 2024 #3
I am not as worried about this type of immunity Farmer-Rick Jul 2024 #4
This is little more than theatre at this time, it is going nowhere and everyone knows it. Bev54 Jul 2024 #5
Ah, the inevitable naysayer NJCher Jul 2024 #6
There currently are not enough votes in Congress to meet wnylib Jul 2024 #9
It might NJCher Jul 2024 #12
I hope that's true because, to pass it, we will need wnylib Jul 2024 #16
Yes NJCher Jul 2024 #22
No, I am not a writer. Not professionally anyway. wnylib Jul 2024 #24
-- NJCher Jul 2024 #25
"I am not saying that we shouldn't try it" BumRushDaShow Jul 2024 #14
I am hardly a naysayer, quite the opposite but I am realistic. Bev54 Jul 2024 #30
"Solutions need to be realistic" BumRushDaShow Jul 2024 #7
Oh and have you noticed NJCher Jul 2024 #8
You sure are quick to label someone, instead of calling someone down, maybe just make your argument. Bev54 Jul 2024 #31
I don't need your help in what to post NJCher Jul 2024 #35
Such a lovely person Bev54 Jul 2024 #37
You can call it theater, but it is important to do everything we can to bring this to the attention of the public. Many Martin68 Jul 2024 #29
Even if we could get the votes Miguelito Loveless Jul 2024 #10
Where did he say that? NJCher Jul 2024 #11
Have you been reading the rulings of late? Miguelito Loveless Jul 2024 #17
of course NJCher Jul 2024 #23
That does not mean you have read the ruling Bev54 Jul 2024 #32
here ya' go NJCher Jul 2024 #33
Roberts actually walked back some of the Clarence Thomas-written "Bruen" decision BumRushDaShow Jul 2024 #28
Dead on arrival The Grand Illuminist Jul 2024 #13
re: "the judgement is virtually final" -- "No it's not." thesquanderer Jul 2024 #15
My complaint WAS about how it was phrased BumRushDaShow Jul 2024 #18
To me, "virtually final" was a way to help explain the siginficance of this amendment being offered... thesquanderer Jul 2024 #21
To follow-up BumRushDaShow Jul 2024 #27
I hope I live to see the day when this SCOTUS ruling is declared null and void FakeNoose Jul 2024 #19
Worth a shot. BlueWavePsych Jul 2024 #20
Just wondering.... MorbidButterflyTat Jul 2024 #26
Do it and good luck to you. republianmushroom Jul 2024 #34
Question, Would the lynching of the VP been cover as an official act, republianmushroom Jul 2024 #36
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»New York Dem will introdu...»Reply #21