Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Igel

(35,387 posts)
12. Everybody stay home
Fri Mar 13, 2020, 09:26 AM
Mar 2020

until tested.

Only 330 million of us. And given false positives and negatives, testing each of us twice should be adequate. That's what's being said, and the "test, test, test" statement is both true, unworkable, and political (given the shoddy testing roll-out of the Trump administration).

Then there's what to do about those who refuse to get tested, who live in Podunksville, just outside of Hoople, North South Dakota, Jimmy Bob the homeless guy who's convinced people are out to kill him, and Yitzhak Ahmedovich Shen y Lopez who undocumentedly immigrated here last week and only speaks Soqotri but doesn't want to be sent back.

People hate uncertainty, some more than others. As one health person pointed out, the only reason for testing at this point is to confirm somebody needs to self-quarantine (as opposed to "I strongly suspect&quot and with the asymptomatic rate being what it is--and people *not* testing positive for a day or two after they've been exposed and *continuing* to test positive for it up to 10 days after they're better, the massive testing becomes virtue or fear signaling.

Wife insisted a doctor test our kid for flu a couple of years ago. (She repeated it a year later with strep.) The doctor said there was no point--flu-like symptoms, you treat the symptoms. But flu test. When the test came back positive, wife was relieved and asked what they should do. And got exactly the same set of instructions--but somehow seemed more satisfied. (I asked what the doctor would have said if the test came back negative and was told, "Same thing.&quot Waste of medical staff time, our time, and supplies.

It seems to me that those catching it are younger than BigmanPigman Mar 2020 #1
The reports of closures are coming fast and furious. pat_k Mar 2020 #2
I watched Pelosi's news presser this morning BigmanPigman Mar 2020 #3
Go Pelosi! Hope she backs up with legislation to fund efforts beyond CDC. pat_k Mar 2020 #4
THIS! Dem2theMax Mar 2020 #5
So what do we do about the asymptotic people in this country? cstanleytech Mar 2020 #6
Social distancing/good hygiene without isolation still makes a huge impact on flattening the curve. Pobeka Mar 2020 #7
Absolutely! pat_k Mar 2020 #9
True. But if we can do some amount of general "surveillance" testing... pat_k Mar 2020 #8
Everybody stay home Igel Mar 2020 #12
The problem I see with testing.... Bayard Mar 2020 #10
There must be some way to test for the presence of the antibody. pat_k Mar 2020 #11
People are commiting a category error. Igel Mar 2020 #14
Found this article. Not definitive, but most likely testing error or never actually "recovered" pat_k Mar 2020 #16
Great find, useful for understanding more about what might be happening. JudyM Mar 2020 #17
Thanks. I thought it was very useful too. pat_k Mar 2020 #18
If you walk through a room with a mask and it picks up virus that you would otherwise have inhaled JudyM Mar 2020 #19
If the mask doesn't fit, you are still breathing in the aerosol. pat_k Mar 2020 #20
Ok, complete agreement here. JudyM Mar 2020 #21
There's a possible resolution to the claim. Igel Mar 2020 #13
That makes sense Bayard Mar 2020 #15
OMG! "What's that?" Duppers Mar 2020 #22
Not that I don't think this is serious but Linda Ed Mar 2020 #23
In an information vacuum, people jump to their worst fears. pat_k Mar 2020 #24
Kick ck4829 Mar 2020 #25
Thx! pat_k Mar 2020 #26
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»Coronavirus: many infecti...»Reply #12