Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
Showing Original Post only (View all)Is it productive to repeatedly remind white people of how privileged they are? [View all]
38 votes, 5 passes | Time left: Unlimited | |
Yes. White people should be reminded of how privileged they are on a regular basis. Such constant reminders will surely help to end racism. | |
14 (37%) |
|
No. It's more productive to focus on specific issues such as racial inequality in the justice system, voting rights, and employer discrimination, that we can all agree need to be addressed in the fight against racism. | |
24 (63%) |
|
5 DU members did not wish to select any of the options provided. | |
Show usernames
Disclaimer: This is an Internet poll |
308 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Is it productive to repeatedly remind white people of how privileged they are? [View all]
Nye Bevan
Jan 2014
OP
yeah, I am all too familiar with this bullshit too. what an incredible leap to make. revolting...
bettyellen
Jan 2014
#27
"Are there some things we can do to foster better understanding?" Yes, like discussing
morningfog
Jan 2014
#32
I do note that President Obama's approach was not to lecture whites about their "privilege" (nt)
Nye Bevan
Jan 2014
#34
he is certainly hinting at it, in a pretty gutless manner. guess he follows that "x isn't allowed
bettyellen
Jan 2014
#89
Never been a fan of "only people of race X are allowed to talk about subject Y" (nt)
Nye Bevan
Jan 2014
#46
Seriously? I make an analogy to Watergate and I am "minimizing them as no big deal"?
Nye Bevan
Jan 2014
#250
not giving the person who concern trolls racial issues here the benefit of the doubt:
CreekDog
Jan 2014
#253
here's more bullshit from you: "Why are blacks overrepresented as NBA coaches?"
CreekDog
Jan 2014
#251
I understand why you want to change the subject from your ignorance of Watergate,
Nye Bevan
Jan 2014
#252
i understand why you don't want attention in your thread about racism to your "reverse racism" posts
CreekDog
Jan 2014
#254
yes, we are interested more interested in the opinion of a fellow progressive
CreekDog
Jan 2014
#290
I believe that my statement in the post you replied to has general applicability,
Nye Bevan
Jan 2014
#247
Again, you're playing games, trying to make it sound like I said you, a white person, couldn't talk
CreekDog
Jan 2014
#268
Sounds like someone wanting to (yet again!) remind white people how privileged they are.
morningfog
Jan 2014
#18
So, those OPs do bother you enough to post this poll. Never mind your 'interesting'
idwiyo
Jan 2014
#45
Not so much that they "bother" me, but they invariably seem to descend into bickering
Nye Bevan
Jan 2014
#48
the comparison to black crime makes it sound like something Sarah Palin would say…. or rather
bettyellen
Jan 2014
#128
The "white progressive versions of people of color" can be just as bad, if not worse,
Liberal_Stalwart71
Jan 2014
#257
Are you married?? *smile* Thank you so very much for this! We need more to speak out!
Liberal_Stalwart71
Jan 2014
#264
Again, about as useful as posting "(insert something negative here) is about blacks".
Nye Bevan
Jan 2014
#216
Black people DO NOT commit more crimes than whites. Your racism is showing right there!!
Liberal_Stalwart71
Jan 2014
#138
Don't post any Wikipedia shit! Post crime statistics! FBI stats! Not wikipedia. Most crimes ARE NOT
Liberal_Stalwart71
Jan 2014
#145
You posted violent crimes. Most violent crimes committed by blacks are directed at other blacks.
Liberal_Stalwart71
Jan 2014
#150
What does that have to do with the conversation about eradicating racism in this society????
Liberal_Stalwart71
Jan 2014
#162
you use every opportunity to downplay an instance of racism or racial inequality
CreekDog
Jan 2014
#270
you are completely right, now the OP is trying to bait you into getting a hidden post- this is
bettyellen
Jan 2014
#168
"This entire thread is incredibly offensive." As is 99% of the shit that comes from the OP
Number23
Jan 2014
#196
The only "useful strategy" for combating racism is to openly acknowledge its existence, period.
nomorenomore08
Jan 2014
#174
Nye doesn't want to talk about "white privilege" he wants to talk about "black privilege", look:
CreekDog
Jan 2014
#259
We all live in a racist society. We all have to examine ourselves for internalized racism.
LeftyMom
Jan 2014
#12
Language is important here, it is not productive to remind them "how privileged" they are
Hippo_Tron
Jan 2014
#13
I think most of us here agree that "stop and frisk" and voting rights are important issues.
Nye Bevan
Jan 2014
#44
It is racist and it is morally wrong, and it is another example of white privilege.
morningfog
Jan 2014
#78
Nice! I applaud you! We need more white people--especially white men like you and Tim Wise--to tell
Liberal_Stalwart71
Jan 2014
#233
When white people deny or dismiss or down play racism they need to be smacked with
morningfog
Jan 2014
#77
Then they don't understand that just by mere virtue of being born with white skin....
Tarheel_Dem
Jan 2014
#65
I'm not claiming that every white DUer objects to being lectured to about their privilege.
Nye Bevan
Jan 2014
#298
In theory a large enough dose of option 2 should eliminate the need for option 1
LadyHawkAZ
Jan 2014
#15
it won't. your views on racism against blacks, Benghazi and IRS are well known here
CreekDog
Jan 2014
#280
No but keep trying. Everyone knows the players here, they know what I would and wouldn't say
CreekDog
Jan 2014
#285
I don't think repeatedly throwing the idea of privilege in people's faces accomplishes much
stevenleser
Jan 2014
#22
Okay Steven, did you read David Brooks' ridiculous marijuana article yesterday?
Hippo_Tron
Jan 2014
#61
"Hectoring tone" is right. And that is being kind. (other words like self-righteous come to mind)
quinnox
Jan 2014
#88
like the tone of your screen name honoring a gun, rather than Eleanor Roosevelt
CreekDog
Jan 2014
#273
"...make white people feel guilty for being white." And we have *liberals* saying things like this?
nomorenomore08
Jan 2014
#177
Fuck! That's something that fucking Newt Gingrich would say!! When conservatives call liberals
Liberal_Stalwart71
Jan 2014
#263
And notice the high fives that followed. And from the most predictable of places too.
Number23
Jan 2014
#301
The way you worded the poll suggests the question of whether white privilege exists is up for debate
morningfog
Jan 2014
#35
A perfect illustration of the us versus "them" mindset that I don't think is especially productive.
Nye Bevan
Jan 2014
#52
I have no problem with "us" versus "them" if by "them" you mean MRA's, racism-deniers, and other
nomorenomore08
Jan 2014
#178
If 64% of DU'ers deny the existence of systemic racism then I am out of here yesterday!
nomorenomore08
Jan 2014
#182
We all have varying levels of overall "privilege" due to our individual characteristics.
nomorenomore08
Jan 2014
#185
The overemphasis on class is typically an attempt to dismiss the importance of race.
Liberal_Stalwart71
Jan 2014
#144
Sorry, I just looked through the thread for a post that denies that white privilege exists,
Nye Bevan
Jan 2014
#92
you missed people whining about their sorry white lives? or calling it "privilege" ?
bettyellen
Jan 2014
#93
Ah, so when a white person says that they are poor, they are "denying" that white privilege exists,
Nye Bevan
Jan 2014
#95
it's obvious from the pushback and lack of recs that everyone knows what you were saying when
bettyellen
Jan 2014
#103
I agree with the people who called you out on your use of scare quotes around privilege...
bettyellen
Jan 2014
#127
There is plenty as there is plenty of focus on various forms to avoid the biggest one, class.
TheKentuckian
Jan 2014
#107
it's a waste of time discussing random personal anecdotes whether it is Chris Rock or a single DUer
bettyellen
Jan 2014
#191
What the hell are you going on about Beyoncé for? I thought the quote was germane to what I wanted
TheKentuckian
Jan 2014
#218
It is possible to do things like campaign against the disgraceful racial bias in the death penalty
Nye Bevan
Jan 2014
#96
I prefer "do you agree that there is a racial bias in how the death penalty is applied?"
Nye Bevan
Jan 2014
#99
Like anything, it's possible to discuss issues without being militant about it.
ProgressSaves
Jan 2014
#104
The concept is valid, but misunderstanding and misuse of the word is rife
WatermelonRat
Jan 2014
#112
I think discussion is good. if you don't want to hear it you can trash the thread or don't read it.
hrmjustin
Jan 2014
#120
As long as state justices like Edith Jones tells us, "African Americans and Hispanics are predispose
LanternWaste
Jan 2014
#135
the OP dog whistled the same sentiment be introducing the concept of "black crime"…..*jaw dropped*
bettyellen
Jan 2014
#137
a knee jerk leap from white privilege to black crime is NOT Obamaesque, or merely lazy….
bettyellen
Jan 2014
#166
Well, on the positive side, out of 3000+ pageviews and 112 DUers voting in the poll,
Nye Bevan
Jan 2014
#167
Cheerleaders in high school get many views and are quite popular too, regardless of any irrelevance
LanternWaste
Jan 2014
#189
How about "part of white privilege is the ability to ignore white privilege, so just STFU
geek tragedy
Jan 2014
#139
People who don't see that they are priveleged will shut down when you mention it
Bettie
Jan 2014
#140
Absolutely & this thread is a perfect demonstration of why. The privileged don't like being
Egalitarian Thug
Jan 2014
#157
I chose "neither" because it's not an either/or. And honestly, framing it that way seems to border
nomorenomore08
Jan 2014
#187
okay, that helps, thx. I guess it is obvious, then, that white privilege exists.
Vattel
Jan 2014
#194
I'd like to remind people of all colors how destructive Republican politicians are to all Americans.
OmahaBlueDog
Jan 2014
#195
Suggesting that 68% of DUers are gullible enough for me to manipulate them by a "push poll"
Nye Bevan
Jan 2014
#208
i think you dont understand what privilege means in this context. it is not the
La Lioness Priyanka
Jan 2014
#206
the term was appropriated in academia and is used/understood incorrectly
La Lioness Priyanka
Jan 2014
#236
OP, I'm shocked, but I shouldn't be that this thread is still open and hasn't been locked.
Liberal_Stalwart71
Jan 2014
#223
Threads discussing issues on which DUers are split two thirds to one third are rarely locked.
Nye Bevan
Jan 2014
#224
67% of DUers are not racists. However, this thread is evidence that racism exists.
Liberal_Stalwart71
Jan 2014
#226
A thread that posts a poll question is necessarily not itself a solution for addressing racism.
Nye Bevan
Jan 2014
#227
That poll itself and how it was worked was not productive. It was hostile and biased.
Liberal_Stalwart71
Jan 2014
#231
I say it's unproductive because most people don't want to acknowledge being wrong
alp227
Jan 2014
#271
meh, some folks are guilty because of their white privilege, sorry, cant resolve you
randys1
Jul 2015
#308