Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

General Discussion

Showing Original Post only (View all)

PatSeg

(47,501 posts)
Thu Jan 19, 2023, 12:17 PM Jan 2023

Alarmed by A.I. chatbots, universities revamp classes [View all]

This is really disturbing.

While grading essays for his world religions course last month, Antony Aumann, a professor of philosophy at Northern Michigan University, read what he said was easily “the best paper in the class.” It explored the morality of burqa bans with clean paragraphs, fitting examples and rigorous arguments. A red flag instantly went up.

Mr. Aumann confronted his student over whether he had written the essay himself. The student confessed to using ChatGPT, a chatbot that delivers information, explains concepts and generates ideas in simple sentences — and, in this case, had written the paper.

Alarmed by his discovery, Mr. Aumann decided to transform essay writing for his courses this semester. He plans to require students to write first drafts in the classroom, using browsers that monitor and restrict computer activity. In later drafts, students have to explain each revision. Mr. Aumann, who may forgo essays in subsequent semesters, also plans to weave ChatGPT into lessons by asking students to evaluate the chatbot’s responses.

“What’s happening in class is no longer going to be, ‘Here are some questions — let’s talk about it between us human beings,’” he said, but instead “it’s like, ‘What also does this alien robot think?’”


Much more at link, no paywall:

https://www.nytimes.com/2023/01/16/technology/chatgpt-artificial-intelligence-universities.html?unlocked_article_code=DkTKD7fFDG3MH8dSMswxEpGm6IAA5s3xFIWqkL-aJsQ0C6WpYI9UsOB0CO-lI5ADWOVcwugXPTUlbLaRYLAIvuzV7aWBqnW7xv5BCEskUhv47Or5PyGmmoXbG31bM-27dtaeJeaUWJy99dFnDpYXDTfHVJlpPGBoCbB-uxCTXPeebYFVkGxGlOr-qTZ9RC8fZsx_-HzEq_Ce3Z20n7EdGyFiC6jwcf-i5kgU0bYmDbd9Spc1CMKrU5X6ddP_WUv2fCzt1HUDSGhh2od8ZVf58xjU6tkNaqU95p_1B3repxWZv9KGnaeYWfkZchL3CDy1rwKusoHz4X0F2rETGZSU-ibFbIESUwe8r0DqVMP540XnGjizAZz2UQo8&smid=share-url
70 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
I just saw a movie where humans have robots living their lives for them. Irish_Dem Jan 2023 #1
That sounds good to me nt intrepidity Jan 2023 #2
Except the robots go rogue and start killing people and causing problems. Irish_Dem Jan 2023 #14
Rodney Dangerfield had his secretary attend class to take notes for him. keithbvadu2 Jan 2023 #3
Jeez, when I was in college back in the stone age, intrepidity Jan 2023 #5
That doesn't sound PatSeg Jan 2023 #7
I know, the article above reminded me of the movie for sure. Irish_Dem Jan 2023 #15
What was the name of the movie? PatSeg Jan 2023 #17
Surrogates (2009) with Bruce Willis Irish_Dem Jan 2023 #19
I'm surprised I didn't see it PatSeg Jan 2023 #21
Yes I was surprised I missed it. Irish_Dem Jan 2023 #24
Bruce will was in 12 Monkeys PatSeg Jan 2023 #26
The Fifth Element was very good. Irish_Dem Jan 2023 #27
There are some movies PatSeg Jan 2023 #29
Yes that too. Irish_Dem Jan 2023 #34
My son and I bonded on Sci-fi when he was young PatSeg Jan 2023 #36
My daughter loved the Game of Thrones type show. Irish_Dem Jan 2023 #39
Between the two of them PatSeg Jan 2023 #46
I'm not much one for comedy but did like Big Bang. Irish_Dem Jan 2023 #50
Same here PatSeg Jan 2023 #53
I know, standup seems so boring. And I don't understand half of it. Irish_Dem Jan 2023 #56
Ya me too, love these types of movies, and thanks. a kennedy Jan 2023 #31
It's not on any of my streaming services PatSeg Jan 2023 #37
Amazon has it for rental. Irish_Dem Jan 2023 #42
Pat have you seen Life On Mars? Irish_Dem Jan 2023 #45
Oh yes PatSeg Jan 2023 #48
I agree, Ashes to Ashes got to be overdone. Irish_Dem Jan 2023 #52
And I think they ended Life on Mars PatSeg Jan 2023 #54
Yes they ended it well. Irish_Dem Jan 2023 #57
I'm surprised I'd never watched Marple before PatSeg Jan 2023 #64
Have you seen the French movie Big Bug? JanMichael Jan 2023 #35
Thanks I just put it in my Netflix queue! Irish_Dem Jan 2023 #43
Thanks, I added it as well! PatSeg Jan 2023 #49
Saw it Renew Deal Jan 2023 #60
Ready Player One and The Peripheral are similar Renew Deal Jan 2023 #59
Thanks! Just put eady Player One in my Amazon Queue Irish_Dem Jan 2023 #61
One more in this space that good is Ex Machina. Renew Deal Jan 2023 #62
Ex Machina is a great movie. Irish_Dem Jan 2023 #63
Liked the Peripheral so much I read Nueromancer. JanMichael Jan 2023 #66
And that's how cursive writing became a curriculum item again intrepidity Jan 2023 #4
I miss writing in cursive. There was something incredibly satisfying about filling a page Sky Jewels Jan 2023 #8
Yes and printing feels rather choppy PatSeg Jan 2023 #10
Very true. Sky Jewels Jan 2023 #11
When I started researching PatSeg Jan 2023 #13
My neighbor told me her granddaughter was given something written in cursive. Irish_Dem Jan 2023 #28
Yes, that is pretty unnerving PatSeg Jan 2023 #30
It never occurred to us that we were being taught a foreign language. :( Irish_Dem Jan 2023 #40
Yes, I've had to reluctantly PatSeg Jan 2023 #44
Remember diagramming sentences? Irish_Dem Jan 2023 #47
Oh yes, that is painful to remember PatSeg Jan 2023 #51
I was in AP English, during the diagramming classes we passed notes, or flew notes I should say. Irish_Dem Jan 2023 #55
Oh, I agree PatSeg Jan 2023 #9
Easily faked with a little effort Amishman Jan 2023 #20
It is about more than time and effort PatSeg Jan 2023 #22
Still not a fan given the time to learn and the total lack of utility in adulthood Amishman Jan 2023 #23
I think it could vary from person to person PatSeg Jan 2023 #25
This plays into a paranoia I keep in my back pocket Torchlight Jan 2023 #6
Yes, definitely cheaper PatSeg Jan 2023 #12
Jeepers creepers- one more thing I need to worry about Redleg Jan 2023 #16
I can imagine PatSeg Jan 2023 #18
Well, this finally explains why it took me a week to get into... Hugin Jan 2023 #32
That is rather scary though PatSeg Jan 2023 #38
I worry about that too, PatSeg. Hugin Jan 2023 #68
Yes, de-evolution PatSeg Jan 2023 #69
The abuse of essays needs to be revisited. My continuing ed program had me write over 130. TheBlackAdder Jan 2023 #33
Those are excellent suggestions PatSeg Jan 2023 #41
I was talking with a Harvard professor about this recently. honest.abe Jan 2023 #58
Yes, I think you're right PatSeg Jan 2023 #65
I don't get why ChatGPT can get its information base for free gulliver Jan 2023 #67
That is a good point PatSeg Jan 2023 #70
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Alarmed by A.I. chatbots,...