Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: Yo, brother Carville? Ain't no such thing as "too woke." [View all]LetMyPeopleVote
(145,242 posts)202. The Law and Order Election
It has been clear to me that you have never worked in a campaign and have no idea as to how campaigns work in the real world. Your emphasis on exit polls has been a source of amusement to me in that this is a great example as to how little you understand how the real world operated. Thank you for the laughs
I finally decided to humor you (after all you have provide me with some good laughs) and found some exit polls for you. https://www.realclearpolitics.com/2020/11/09/defund_the_police_backfired_on_democrats_528914.html
Instead of a blue wave for the Democrats, there was a red Republican wave in the 2020 elections. Many analysts are explaining this unexpected outcome in ways that confirm their prior assumptions. Anti-woke centrist liberals: The Democratic Party was too woke. Bernie Sanders-type social democrats: The Democrats blew it by not running on Medicare for All. Professional conservative pundits: Trump and Trumpism are more popular with Americans than we thought.
I beg to differ. I think this was a law and order election.
According to early exit polls, here were the reasons that voters voted for Trump and presumably other Republicans: The economy (82%), crime and safety (71%), health care policy (36%), the coronavirus pandemic (14%) and racial inequality (8%).....
Maybe the slogan defund the police backfired.
Democrats might reply: But Biden and Harris rejected the phrase defund the police. Indeed, they did. And Donald Trump has repeatedly denounced and rejected white supremacy and white nationalism. Nevertheless, the mainstream media and Democratic propagandists (but I repeat myself again) have told us for four years that by denouncing white supremacy in public, Trump is secretly approving of white supremacy, dog-whistle-style.
Turnabout is fair play. Having tried to persuade voters that all Republicans are closet Nazis whose public statements cannot be taken at face value, Democratic spinmeisters in the media cannot be surprised if it turns out that some swing voters have concluded that apparently mainstream Democrats are closet antifa sympathizers. Possibly many swing voters thought that actionsor, in the case of the summer riots, inactionspoke louder than words about the Democratic Partys attitude to law enforcement, particularly when many Democratic urban governments from Minneapolis to Austin proceeded relentlessly to cut police budgets in the name of racial justice, even as the violence was going on.
When you put together two factsthe fact that the Republican Party as a whole picked up voters, and the fact that 71% of voters for the Republican presidential candidate said they were motivated by crime and safetyit all adds up. The voter backlash following the urban riots of 1967 helped to produce the Nixon victory of 1968. And the voter backlash following the urban riots of 2020 helped to produce the Republican electoral wave in November 2020.
I beg to differ. I think this was a law and order election.
According to early exit polls, here were the reasons that voters voted for Trump and presumably other Republicans: The economy (82%), crime and safety (71%), health care policy (36%), the coronavirus pandemic (14%) and racial inequality (8%).....
Maybe the slogan defund the police backfired.
Democrats might reply: But Biden and Harris rejected the phrase defund the police. Indeed, they did. And Donald Trump has repeatedly denounced and rejected white supremacy and white nationalism. Nevertheless, the mainstream media and Democratic propagandists (but I repeat myself again) have told us for four years that by denouncing white supremacy in public, Trump is secretly approving of white supremacy, dog-whistle-style.
Turnabout is fair play. Having tried to persuade voters that all Republicans are closet Nazis whose public statements cannot be taken at face value, Democratic spinmeisters in the media cannot be surprised if it turns out that some swing voters have concluded that apparently mainstream Democrats are closet antifa sympathizers. Possibly many swing voters thought that actionsor, in the case of the summer riots, inactionspoke louder than words about the Democratic Partys attitude to law enforcement, particularly when many Democratic urban governments from Minneapolis to Austin proceeded relentlessly to cut police budgets in the name of racial justice, even as the violence was going on.
When you put together two factsthe fact that the Republican Party as a whole picked up voters, and the fact that 71% of voters for the Republican presidential candidate said they were motivated by crime and safetyit all adds up. The voter backlash following the urban riots of 1967 helped to produce the Nixon victory of 1968. And the voter backlash following the urban riots of 2020 helped to produce the Republican electoral wave in November 2020.
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
202 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
They do have the numbers in the states and that is a problem. While those of us on this board are
Demsrule86
Apr 2021
#21
I agree with your assessment of winning back states. We don't do that with internal squabbling.
ancianita
Apr 2021
#25
Sure gerrymandering is a fact of life. But South Carolina and other states are red period at the
Demsrule86
Apr 2021
#26
Carville is just plain scared if you ask me as I am. I live in Ohio. Now despite what you hear there
Demsrule86
Apr 2021
#188
I actually agree with you on Walker, especially if Manchin and Sinema block all or most of
Celerity
Apr 2021
#191
Great post. As I recall the same thing happened to the LGTBQ+ community during the fight for
PunkinPi
Apr 2021
#85
Wrong, be a melee mouth democrat who allows republican framing will lose us the house in 22
uponit7771
Apr 2021
#41
Fewer than 1 in 5 support 'defund the police' movement, USA TODAY/Ipsos Poll finds
LetMyPeopleVote
Apr 2021
#102
Need a poll on how it affected votes for down ballot candidates. P.S. There arent any cause it didnt
uponit7771
Apr 2021
#103
GOP Launches Ads Highlighting 'Defund The Police' To Target Vulnerable 2022 Dems
LetMyPeopleVote
Apr 2021
#105
Since when are GOP attacks on something we do or say the basis for not doing or saying it
StarfishSaver
Apr 2021
#113
Do you tire of being wrong? Have you ever worked on a campaign in the real world?
LetMyPeopleVote
Apr 2021
#136
Soooooooooo yeah, she would be the 'few' in the 'few to no one' like I stated in my post
uponit7771
Apr 2021
#170
Only if you use the racist definition of the word, if you use the black appropriated definition of
uponit7771
Apr 2021
#43
Woke ain't about Jesus level foreign policy talk. Woke is setting America's house straight first.
ancianita
Apr 2021
#17
No, you either support human rights or you dont. Regardless of WHERE the humans are.
oldsoftie
Apr 2021
#83
Doing the right thing for the wrong reason, whether it's corporate "wokeness" or voting, doesn't
ancianita
Apr 2021
#92
"Shhh ... you're making too much noise about your rights. You're getting in the way."
StarfishSaver
Apr 2021
#63
Yup, most of his comments are about how to kick Republicans in the nuts
BeyondGeography
Apr 2021
#66
And yet most of those commenting here are agreeing with and doubling down on his "woke" comment
StarfishSaver
Apr 2021
#67
How to read his whole interview is a fair party point. But that isn't the takeaway
ancianita
Apr 2021
#74
Do you really think an itty bitty Carville interview has this kind of impact?
BeyondGeography
Apr 2021
#77
I classify "defund the police" in the same group as "democratic socialsm".....
brooklynite
Apr 2021
#36
Can't believe 'defund', after all the polls and election results, is still being hung out
empedocles
Apr 2021
#60
I was talking about your misspelling of socialism then referring to the dictionary.
JanMichael
Apr 2021
#152
Cool. I saw Latinos on MSNBC say just the opposite. Has there been any formal polling?
ancianita
Apr 2021
#35
Of course I do. You don't want to, apparently. You gotta run? What's that about, huh?
ancianita
Apr 2021
#61
Yeah, if a democrat 04JohnKerry's something they never ran on they lose and they'll lose again
uponit7771
Apr 2021
#51
If you're having private one on one meetings with DCCC chairs you're probably not immediately impact
AZProgressive
Apr 2021
#173
Carville may have phased it wrong but in the end that is how Repugs win Congress...
Jon King
Apr 2021
#44
Yes. So if he wants to do some good, he needs to attack how Repugs talk. Not us.
ancianita
Apr 2021
#50
THIS !! 👉🏾 "admit to the kernel of racism that still exists within the party"
uponit7771
Apr 2021
#62
The message was framed by their fellow Democrats. Having to campaign against their republican....
George II
Apr 2021
#118
I am truly offended by posters attacking real democrats who are running campaigns in the real world
LetMyPeopleVote
Apr 2021
#137
Then it bad campaigning to allow an opponent to frame a candidate with something they're not
uponit7771
Apr 2021
#172
He could do that by talking directly to candidates and campaigns, rather than publicly castigating
StarfishSaver
Apr 2021
#131
You're describing a melee mouth candidate and yeah, we lose if we run people with no conviction
uponit7771
Apr 2021
#52
I read the whole interview and even in context, his comment about "wokeness" is ridiculous
StarfishSaver
Apr 2021
#76
no he's not, he's not even close. In groups usually try to deflect issue on outgroups with silliness
uponit7771
Apr 2021
#135
Again, you are refusing to tell us if you have worked on a campaign in the real world
LetMyPeopleVote
Apr 2021
#139
Continuing to post the same things over and over again, doesn't make it effective.
Caliman73
Apr 2021
#141
When I want an old White man's opinion of how people of color talk about race, I will ask for it.
Caliman73
Apr 2021
#144
How many races have you won? Have you worked on a race in the real world?
LetMyPeopleVote
Apr 2021
#151
Woke is consciousness of America's actual history of racism, sexism, pollution, and voting rights.
Marcuse
Apr 2021
#155
Awesome. And Blacks were woke long before this, even. Before the colonial period.
ancianita
Apr 2021
#157
+1, people on DU saying we can be too conscious of these things are crazy !!!
uponit7771
Apr 2021
#171
You know there's a whole thread of black people like me who says white people shouldn't
uponit7771
Apr 2021
#182
Do you have those non existent polls yet or are you going to keep doing this? No really I asked
uponit7771
Apr 2021
#184
Your lack of understanding as to how campaigns work in the real world is truly sad but amusing
LetMyPeopleVote
Apr 2021
#185
Attacking good members of the Democratic party for losing in 2020 is not a good look
LetMyPeopleVote
May 2021
#195
All that is still not empirical data, come on. It sounds like no amount of objective information is
uponit7771
May 2021
#196
It is so sad that people are defending that ignorant defund the police slogan
LetMyPeopleVote
May 2021
#192
And if we have no response to it then we are campaigning poorly, this time you they can't blame
uponit7771
May 2021
#194