History of Feminism
Related: About this forumRape Victim Can Sue for Denied Contraception
R.W., whose full name is not disclosed in court records, says she was raped on Jan. 27, 2007. After an examination at Tampa's Rape Crisis Center, a doctor gave R.W. gave two anti-contraception pills, according to the complaint.
R.W. says she took one pill immediately and held the other to ingest 12 hours later, as directed.
While taking R.W.'s report of the crime, however, a Tampa police officer learned that there was an arrest warrant for R.W. for failure to pay restitution and failure to appear. At the Hillsborough County Jail, staff confiscated her second pill.
R.W. says she requested her second pill the next morning, but jail employee Michele Spinelli refused. "Spinelli told the Plaintiff that she would not give R.W. the pill because it was against Spinelli's religious beliefs," the first amended complaint states.
Although R.W. did not get pregnant, she sued Spinelli and Hillsborough County Sheriff David Gee for gender discrimination and violations of the right to privacy and the right to equal protection under the 14th Amendment.
http://www.courthousenews.com/2012/06/25/47785.htm
seabeyond
(110,159 posts)ok, women, for this reason.
i have not bought that argument even a little since all this started.
if walking into a career, there are things that are contradictory to your religion, get a different job. that simple
LynneSin
(95,337 posts)for the soul purpose of being able to pass their moral judgement onto others. Their logic - if they get enough pharmacists that object giving out birth control pills and EC then perhaps they can change the laws to allow these right-wing religious pharmacists to play 'doctor/god' with the people using their services.
seabeyond
(110,159 posts)i started hearing about them and doing research because they were becoming a part of groups my family was in. you are absolutely right. they suggest that people get these degrees in these areas in order to take control from the bottom up. education board would be an example.
i felt long ago, that the first pharmacist and doctor that took this stance needed to be reigned in. we did not do it.
One_Life_To_Give
(6,036 posts)As more states are recognizing that when we license a medical/pharmacy facility. The state has an obligation to make certain all authorized medical procedures/pharmaceuticals are provided.
redqueen
(115,103 posts)but that officer needs to be fired.
People who pull this "religious beliefs" crap need to be fired and go work for some place where their 'beliefs' won't get in the way of them doing their flipping jobs.
Chorophyll
(5,179 posts)truebrit71
(20,805 posts)...otherwise do your fugging job..
sufrommich
(22,871 posts)" a Tampa police officer learned that there was an arrest warrant for R.W. for failure to pay restitution and failure to appear". Is it common to run backround checks on victims of rape?
Here's a tip for you ladies ,don't report that rape if you've got unpaid parking tickets.
seabeyond
(110,159 posts)Here's a tip for you ladies ,don't report that rape if you've got unpaid parking tickets.
you are absolutely right. that is appalling. and it is the reality we live today. we gave up constitutional rights without a wimper, long ago
redqueen
(115,103 posts)So don't go to the hospital if you're pregnant and have any kind of accident, either.
I think it might be only thirty something states where its a criminal offense, though. So in the other dozen or so you're ok to seek medical care without risking arrest or prosecution.
sufrommich
(22,871 posts)redqueen
(115,103 posts)Here's a link
http://news.change.org/stories/pregnant-iowa-woman-arrested-for-falling-down
Then there's Bei Bei Shuai, in jail for attempting suicide while pregnant. She lived but her baby didn't.
sufrommich
(22,871 posts)redqueen
(115,103 posts)it also scares me.
sufrommich
(22,871 posts)Death of fetus = murder is coming .
seabeyond
(110,159 posts)killing a preg woman and making it two murder counts. then you are sitting the fetus up as an independent person. that step is used to go after women in all kinds of manner, thru out her preg, where she can be charged with murder for a miscarriage.
redqueen
(115,103 posts)They were never intended to be used this way. They were supposed to be used against criminals.
seabeyond
(110,159 posts)seabeyond
(110,159 posts)SheilaT
(23,156 posts)I fell down stairs when I was seven and a half months pregnant with my first child. Broke my right ankle. I was on crutches for the next few weeks, which made me highly memorable, because AI was so very pregnant. At least I was in a walking cast when he was born.
Oh, my son came out just fine. This was nearly thirty years ago, and he's wonderful, smart, and like every other human being on this planet, uniquely himself.
southernyankeebelle
(11,304 posts)CrispyQ
(36,509 posts)Spinelli should lose her job. Only when people start getting fired for this bullshit will it stop.
MsPithy
(809 posts)When a woman comes forward and submits to the invasive collection of evidence, she is helping to protect all women and girls. If rape was really a crime, that evidence would be so important, any warrants for the woman would be ignored.
sufrommich
(22,871 posts)a check for warrants,but apparently not.Another reason to not report that rape.
seabeyond
(110,159 posts)history when coming forward with the crime of rape. it is vaguely in my mind. i do not know for sure. would be interesting if anyone knows. or if it was just an unspoken thing the police did.
redqueen
(115,103 posts)that's a very good question.
Sivafae
(480 posts)I mean if you hold your religion as the basis of action, namely withholding medication, isn't that religious discrimination? Especially if it harms someone?
seabeyond
(110,159 posts)religion the law being passed was an affront to her religion. yet she is not insisting that all live by her religion. the abortion issue. if it is the mothers life, she says her religion say must save the mother.
drm604
(16,230 posts)Spinelli should lose her job for this. Hell, maybe she should be charged with practicing medicine without a license, since she took it on herself to override a doctor's orders.
seabeyond
(110,159 posts)against.
the after pill does not let the sperm get to the egg. no abortion there. she actually set up the victim to possibly have to get an abortion. really ironic
sufrommich
(22,871 posts)Swede Atlanta
(3,596 posts)Even as a Christian I believe if I were a physician or pharmacist, etc. I am obliged by the duties of my hippocratic oath and my profession to provide generally accepted services and products.
My decision to enter those professions and where I channel my profession needs to be against the backdrop of an obligation to provide services. Perhaps being a doctor is not a good fit if I have strong religious convictions that would make it difficult for me to, for example, treat someone who had contracted a venereal disease.
Those individuals need to either avoid the professions or work for a religiously-affiliated hospital or company where a consumer is aware his or her options for treatment may be affected by religious beliefs.
But here we have someone being held against her will. She had not been found guilty of failure to pay restitution (and we know jails get warrants and the like mixed up all the time).
With all due respect to the prison guard, he/she should have either asked another guard to provide the medication or taken this up the chain. A person's religious beliefs must NOT be allowed to impinge on or be used as a defense to this kind of behavior.
seabeyond
(110,159 posts)if they have not received their vaccination because of parent conviction, and watch duers cheer and justify. or if a doctor refuses to treat a person that smokes or extremely overweight. there are plenty of people on du that will justify this.
sufrommich
(22,871 posts)There is a big difference between a woman's private right to a choice which does not have any effect on the well being of others and a potential public health fiasco caused by the anti vaccine brigade though.
seabeyond
(110,159 posts)care of the sick. it does not go beyond that.
and that includes aids patients back in the day when they were being denied by doctors.
(we may disagree, and that is ok)
sufrommich
(22,871 posts)seabeyond
(110,159 posts)i am seeing we do not see all things alike, which is more a consistency of real life. it is fun. opens the mind. all in respect. i hear ya
Swede Atlanta
(3,596 posts)There is another post today about a German court ruling that male circumcision is the same as abuse/mutilation.
My view there is, despite religious protestations, a decision to be circumcised should be left to the MAN when he is a man. That decision should not be something a parent, hoping the child will live up to be a good Jew or Muslim or Christian, should decide.
The same applies to childhood vaccinations, etc. Now I recognize that parents must make certain decisions for a child such as when to take the child to see a doctor, which treatments (preventive or otherwise) should be applied, etc. There have been numerous cases where the uber-religious parents refused to take the child to see a doctor using only prayer. Courts have convicted these parents of essentially voluntary manslaughter and rightly so. A child is not a piece of property. Good grief we charge people all the time for leaving a dog in a hot car.
seabeyond
(110,159 posts)touching on a lot of issues. shows the challenge. gonna think about it.
having two boys, and the issue of circumcision just coming up, i handed it off to my hubby to decide. it is not something i had a lot of knowledge or prior thought to. a decade and a half later and listening to people on du, i think i would think about it a little harder.
drm604
(16,230 posts)and it doesn't in any way justify what this guard did.
seabeyond
(110,159 posts)sufrommich
(22,871 posts)of these religious fanatics ( no offense to normal religious people) are putting themselves in these jobs specifically for the purpose of denying the rights of women in order to protest those rights.
SheilaT
(23,156 posts)It's all about controlling women.
seabeyond
(110,159 posts)BlueIris
(29,135 posts)Thank goodness she did not become pregnant.
Smilo
(1,944 posts)............ and I agree with other posters - when has the rape victim become the guilty party subject to background investigation when reporting the rape? At their most vulnerable - they are being "raped" again for their past behavior - this couldn't wait - shows how lacking in compassion these officers were.
drm604
(16,230 posts)Spinelli was a municipal employee and therefore was acting as a representative of the government. Spinelli acted as she did out of religious conviction, she admitted this. Therefore this was the government imposing religious restrictions on R.B. Doing so violates her 1st amendment rights.
Dawson Leery
(19,348 posts)without a license.
duhneece
(4,117 posts)But her fight is for ALL of us women. Bless her truly.
seabeyond
(110,159 posts)sufrommich
(22,871 posts)stop and recognize the bravery of a woman like this because we're so wrapped up in the outrage committed against her. Thanks for reminding us.
Texasgal
(17,047 posts)I cannot believe she had to SUE! It should have been a no-brainer!
How awful for R.W.