Geoengineering: Testing the Waters
By Naomi Klein
Source: NYTimes.com
Thursday, November 01, 2012
FOR almost 20 years, Ive been spending time on a craggy stretch of British Columbias shoreline called the Sunshine Coast. This summer, I had an experience that reminded me why I love this place, and why I chose to have a child in this sparsely populated part of the world.
The scariest thing about this proposition is that models suggest that many of the people who could well be most harmed by these technologies are already disproportionately vulnerable to the impacts of climate change. Imagine this: North America decides to send sulfur into the stratosphere to reduce the intensity of the sun, in the hopes of saving its corn crops despite the real possibility of triggering droughts in Asia and Africa. In short, geoengineering would give us (or some of us) the power to exile huge swaths of humanity to sacrifice zones with a virtual flip of the switch.
The geopolitical ramifications are chilling. Climate change is already making it hard to know whether events previously understood as acts of God (a freak heat wave in March or a Frankenstorm on Halloween) still belong in that category. But if we start tinkering with the earths thermostat deliberately turning our oceans murky green to soak up carbon and bleaching the skies hazy white to deflect the sun we take our influence to a new level. A drought in India will come to be seen accurately or not as a result of a conscious decision by engineers on the other side of the planet. What was once bad luck could come to be seen as a malevolent plot or an imperialist attack.
There will be other visceral, life-changing consequences. A study published this spring in Geophysical Research Letters found that if we inject sulfur aerosols into the stratosphere in order to dial down the sun, the sky would not only become whiter and significantly brighter, but we would also be treated to more intense, volcanic sunsets. But what kind of relationships can we expect to have with those hyper-real skies? Would they fill us with awe or with vague unease? Would we feel the same when beautiful wild creatures cross our paths unexpectedly, as happened to my family this summer? In a popular book on climate change, Bill McKibben warned that we face The End of Nature. In the age of geoengineering, we might find ourselves confronting the end of miracles, too.
http://www.zcommunications.org/geoengineering-testing-the-waters-by-naomi-klein