Quit calling Donald Trump an isolationist. Hes worse than that.
Under President Trump, American foreign policy is returning, many commentators say, to the isolationism that preceded World War II. This line of interpretation (and often attack) emerged during the election: While Hillary Clinton warned that her opponent would tear up our alliances, an array of experts supplied such fears with a historical pedigree. As Council on Foreign Relations President Richard Haass put it, Trump stood for a new isolationism, a revival of the 1930s dream of turning away from global engagement.
The problem is, Trump isnt an isolationist. He is a militarist, something far worse. And calling Trump an isolationist isnt an effective critique.
The term isolationism was coined in the 1930s to caricature Americans who wanted to stay strictly neutral in the looming war. They scarcely sought to disconnect from the world, as Voxs Zack Beauchamp recently wrote. In fact, most favored peaceful forms of overseas involvement, such as trade, and insisted on defending the Americas from foreign intervention no small feat. What united them was their opposition to entering the Second World War after the devastation of the First. Judging the United States capable of repelling any outside invasion, they wanted to steer clear of armed entanglement in Europe and Asia. To breach this tradition would embroil Americans in perpetual war for perpetual peace, in the words of historian and participant Charles Beard.
The first America Firsters, then, were antiwar more than anti-Semitic or pro-fascist, strains that recent critics of Trump overemphasize. True, the groups spokesman, aviator Charles Lindbergh, railed against Jewish influence months before Pearl Harbor. But the anti-Semitic diatribe crippled the movement rather than advanced it, and few America Firsters favored the Axis. Rather, it was the antiwar appeal the notion that involvement in European conflict was unnecessary for U.S. safety that attracted millions across the political spectrum, including pacifist-socialist Norman Thomas and future presidents Gerald Ford and John F. Kennedy.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/posteverything/wp/2017/02/17/quit-calling-donald-trump-an-isolationist-its-an-insult-to-isolationism/?tid=pm_opinions_pop&utm_term=.86603091fd3c#comments