HomeLatest ThreadsGreatest ThreadsForums & GroupsMy SubscriptionsMy Posts
DU Home » Latest Threads » Forums & Groups » Main » General Discussion (Forum) » Letter to Melania

Thu Oct 12, 2017, 05:02 PM

Letter to Melania

from https://www.expressen.se/kultur/dear-melania/


Dear Melania,
When I was younger, I looked up to girls like you. They seemed so mature. But even though they lived behind the Iron Curtain, I didn’t understand why they wanted so badly to get to the West. Western guys weren’t fairytale princes any more than the local boys, and I knew because I’d grown up on both sides of the Curtain, in Finland and Soviet Estonia. Most of the girls who wanted to leave had absolutely no idea what the West was really like. To hear them talk, Western men were a kind of dream job that would open up a new world of social and economic opportunities for them.
When the borders finally opened, that dream became a possibility, and you were one of the ones who grabbed hold of it. The desire to seem more Western is the convenient explanation for why you changed your name from Melanija Knavs to Melania Knauss. But I’d wager there’s more to it: by then, Eastern European girls had developed a certain reputation. In the West, women cast them suspicious glances, and men ogled them, all of which came as a complete surprise to the newcomers, presumably including you. Your accent alone suddenly let everyone know you were for sale, and cheap.

A woman for the cost of a pair of pantyhose
I remember the beginnings of the sexualization of Eastern European girls in Finland during the Soviet period. Back then, Tallinn, a quick ferry ride away in Estonia, was known as a city where you could buy women for the cost of a pair of pantyhose, but it wasn’t until the 1990s that flocks of Eastern European women appeared on the streets and squares of Finland carrying signs saying, “Pussy 50 marks.” That phrase became fixed in the Finnish lexicon. The incoming flood of foreign sex workers was an unprecedented sight and an embarrassment for the Estonians. No one talked about the dangers of human trafficking in those days. Even though the breakup of the Soviet Union had meant the collapse of the entire social system of the Eastern Bloc, no one was much interested in the forces that drove women into the sex trade.


Melania Trump boarding a plane to visit Lily's Place, the nation's first nonprofit infant recovery center that also provides services to parents and families dealing with addiction and notably opioid addiction.Foto: JIM WATSON / AFP

Once Estonia regained its independence, it soon became a rising star, a model Eastern European economy with more to offer than easy women and cheap booze. Tourism increased, and international press about Estonia became more varied. I didn’t get propositioned on the boat to Tallinn as often, and Russian and Estonian women no longer had to lower their voices on the street in Finland. All this made me happy.

Feeding the entertainment industry's desire
What I didn’t realize was that the sex tourism I’d seen was only the first wave in the stampede to Eastern Europe. Even though where I lived the image of Balts and Slavs had gained more nuance, elsewhere their reputation was crumbling. Brothels all over the world were filling with Eastern European girls, and their march onto the stage of Western popular culture was just beginning.
In retrospect, this all makes sense. For half a century, the nations of the Eastern Bloc had only existed for the West as part of the Evil Empire. If a Slav showed up in a movie in the West, he was just some Ivan in a fur hat. The Iron Curtain insured that few Westerners had any sense of the individual nations, whether it was Estonia or your homeland, Slovenia. There were no public narratives that reflected the realities of these countries that suddenly appeared on the map.
When the Soviet Union collapsed, Cold War stories fell out of fashion in popular culture. But titillating images of prostitutes quickly filled the void: What more does the entertainment industry need than tits, high heels, Russian mafia thugs, and damsels in distress? The fact that these girls came from a blank space on the map only increased their exoticism. News stories about the link between the sex trade and organized crime added a dash of danger, further heightening the effect. The East was the new Wild West.

The Melania effect
You are the First Lady of the United States of America, but whenever you hear a familiar accent on TV, the woman on-screen is a prostitute, a stripper, or a mail-order bride. And she doesn’t get many lines, either, because what would be the point?
Melania, despite your position, you haven’t caused any “Melania effect,” as Vanity Fair pointed out. No one is rushing out to buy the dresses you wear, no matter how beautiful the garments your stylists drape over your perfect body. You aren’t a fashion icon. You aren’t an idol. And how could you be when your face elicits #FreeMelania, #SadMelania, and #SaveMelania. Those are the hashtags of the passive victim in the stereotypical story of an Eastern European girl, not the First Lady.

A friend of mine from Slovenia says she’s started avoiding questions about her home country. If she tells men where she’s from, she gets that look. You know the one. The demeaning one. All her expertise and professional accomplishments are instantly erased by her background. That’s the effect you’re having, dear Melania.

Your husband's idea of womenhood
Unfortunately, you are the best thing that’s happened in ages for the market in Eastern European girls. You’ve become the face of the entire industry. “I’m not a nagging wife,” you say and otherwise keep your mouth shut and accept your husband’s sexist comments. Which is exactly the kind of wife men go looking for in the former Eastern Bloc. One who keeps within the boundaries of “true” femininity by fulfilling her “fundamental” role of providing pleasure for men. A woman who looks like a supermodel but was raised by her grandmother, as one matchmaking agency’s slogan puts it. Each new article about the indignities you’ve endured in your marriage sells more bachelor getaways, attracts more customers to the dating apps and interpretation services. That’s why your silence isn’t a private matter. It affects the lives and opportunities of countless other women.
The dominant narrative about Eastern European women—one of inequality and exploitation— shapes how we’re treated. It causes anxiety and depression, and makes us ashamed of our own bodies. Did you know that women with this immigrant background find it difficult to report the abuse and violence they experience? They’re afraid no one will believe them. The stories the media tells create the impression that they want to be subjugated, that being objectified brings them pleasure.
That’s your husband’s idea of womanhood, and that’s what you’re normalizing through your silence.

Lead by example
Today Eastern European girls—cheap and white—are the most desirable commodity in the sex industry the world over. They are coming from countries where the standard of living is low, the social safety nets are weak, and corruption is endemic, offering excellent ground for trafficking and sex work. But the better a country’s economy, the more gender equality we find, the fewer girls from that country turn to prostitution or to marrying a man they’ve barely met.
But we still need help, and we need it from women like you. Be the First Lady and change the world, as First Ladies before you have. Start a foundation, visit shelters, raise awareness, help people to recognize the signs of trafficking and abuse, and give courage to victims to come forward —make them feel they have the right to do so. Lead by your example, break your silence, and we will welcome you with open arms. You can do it. You can make a difference. You can be a hero to us all.

7 replies, 2559 views

Reply to this thread

Back to top Alert abuse

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum
Replies to this discussion thread
Arrow 7 replies Author Time Post
Reply Letter to Melania (Original post)
marchellojones Oct 2017 OP
hlthe2b Oct 2017 #1
mercuryblues Oct 2017 #2
madaboutharry Oct 2017 #3
smirkymonkey Oct 2017 #4
msongs Oct 2017 #5
qwlauren35 Oct 2017 #6
Lotusflower70 Oct 2017 #7

Response to marchellojones (Original post)

Thu Oct 12, 2017, 05:10 PM

1. Hard to comment on this...

But, I have to say the writer has a point.

Reply to this post

Back to top Alert abuse Link here Permalink


Response to marchellojones (Original post)

Thu Oct 12, 2017, 05:15 PM

2. It is a beautiful letter

But malaria won't do anything as 1st lady. She has a full time job and that is agreeing with her husband. He bought and paid for her and expects to get his money's worth.

Reply to this post

Back to top Alert abuse Link here Permalink


Response to marchellojones (Original post)

Thu Oct 12, 2017, 05:30 PM

3. The author is asking Melania to be someone else.

Melania is never going to be a First Lady who speaks out and presents strength.

Reply to this post

Back to top Alert abuse Link here Permalink


Response to marchellojones (Original post)

Thu Oct 12, 2017, 05:43 PM

4. Great letter, but I don't think it's going to have any effect on Melania's behavior.

She is the most useless First Lady in the history of the nation.

Reply to this post

Back to top Alert abuse Link here Permalink


Response to marchellojones (Original post)

Thu Oct 12, 2017, 06:20 PM

5. a tour through her documented actual behavior makes clear what kind of person she really is nt

Reply to this post

Back to top Alert abuse Link here Permalink


Response to marchellojones (Original post)

Thu Oct 12, 2017, 07:23 PM

6. This letter really touched me.

Sometimes I forget that there are different shades of white. Melania is one shade. A high class mail-order bride from the Eastern Bloc, where blond haired, blue eyed sex workers cross to the Western world in droves, to be taken in by white men, sick of gender equality, eager to have a trophy wife who they can show off, dominate, control, and possibly beat and rape at their leisure. And these women, knowing where they have come from, knowing the poverty they escaped, will stay silent and submissive, even as Western women implore them to be something more than they can be.

A mail-order bride, a high class sex worker, a grown up kid from an impoverished country, cannot be the kind of First Lady who champions causes, speaks with purpose, blazes trails and carves her name in stone as a woman to be remembered.

It is no wonder she did not want to be First Lady. She knows who she is, what she can be, and what she is not cut out for.

This letter was truly eye-opening, reminding me that some men cannot be happy unless they are dominating women, and so there will always be a market for such women.

I'm really not trying to call Melania a whore. But she comes from a culture where women prostituted themselves in order to carve a place for themselves in the Western world.

So, I will not expect more of her than she can be. She is Trump's trophy wife. Nothing less, and nothing more.

Reply to this post

Back to top Alert abuse Link here Permalink


Response to marchellojones (Original post)

Thu Oct 12, 2017, 10:01 PM

7. Powerful letter

Mail order brides and sex trafficking are alive and well. It's sad that Melania has had such a negative impact on the women in the Eastern bloc but not surprising. She is a mindless zombie. She is robotic. I have no expectations about her filling the First Lady role. She won't do anything. She might as well be a cardboard cutout. I have no sympathy for her whatsoever. I have sympathy for the victims that survive sex trafficking. I work with them. I see what happens as they struggle to adjust to life outside of that environment. And because of their accents and looks, some face that backlash of exotic appeal. As if their only appeal or usefulness is their appearance. As if their minds don't matter. These women are amazing. They are smart and resourceful. It's exciting to see them seize opportunities to become strong and independent. There are many guys in the United States looking for a submissive Eastern European young lady. They want her malleable. These guys are weak and pathetic. They can't handle a strong, independent. They get off on breaking her spirit. Melania doesn't care about her impact on the other side of the world. She only cares about herself.

Reply to this post

Back to top Alert abuse Link here Permalink

Reply to this thread