General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsNBC - German TV Shows Nazi Symbols on Helmets of Ukraine Soldiers
This is bad. Really really bad.
And understand ZDF is a HUGE tv station in Deutschland akin to CBS in America. And this story isn't right wing, it's from NBC.
[link:https://www.nbcnews.com/storyline/ukraine-crisis/german-tv-shows-nazi-symbols-helmets-ukraine-soldiers-n198961|]
"Germans were confronted with images of their countrys dark past on Monday night, when German public broadcaster ZDF showed video of Ukrainian soldiers with Nazi symbols on their helmets in its evening newscast. In a report on the fragile cease-fire in eastern Ukraine, Moscow correspondent Bernhard Lichte used pictures of a soldier wearing a combat helmet with the "SS runes" of Hitlers infamous black-uniformed elite corps. A second soldier was seen with a swastika on his gear. Volunteer battalions from nearly every political spectrum are reinforcing the government side, the ZDF correspondent said in his report.
The video was shot last week in Ukraine by a camera team from Norwegian broadcaster TV2. We were filming a report about Ukraines AZOV battalion in the eastern city of Urzuf, when we came across these soldiers, Oysten Bogen, a correspondent for the private television station, told NBC News. Minutes before the images were taped, Bogen said he had asked a spokesperson whether the battalion had fascist tendencies. The reply was: absolutely not, we are just Ukrainian nationalists, Bogen said.'
Kingofalldems
(38,468 posts)Not a good effort there.
AntivaxHunters
(3,234 posts)But this definitely isn't good.
Kingofalldems
(38,468 posts)Xolodno
(6,398 posts)Just pointing out the obvious, don't shoot the messenger.
There are Nazi sympathizers in Ukraine and some from WW2 are considered local hero's. IF and its a big IF Ukraine manages to expel Putin's forces or a ceasefire is reached, some of these guys would have no qualms about turning against Zelensky. Right now, its the enemy of my enemy situation, but that can change.
yardwork
(61,690 posts)This thread probably has roots in the not insignificant number of internet sites that encourage the US to give up and let Putin have his way.
Xolodno
(6,398 posts)At least not here on DU. More than enough Ukrainian flags and shouts of "Slava Ukraine" to impress on me otherwise. But at the same time, I don't think stuff like this should be swept underneath the rug just because it isn't what you want to hear. That's what Free Republic does. Here, its usually take the bad with the good and be more knowledgeable.
Lets be real, we aren't going to affect the course of the war at any level. Getting angry because of some information you don't like isn't going to do anything.
Plus its good to be informed, Zelensky has to tread cautiously with these guys as they could easily turn on him, but for now, he'll let them take bullets.
https://www.jpost.com/diaspora/antisemitism/israeli-and-polish-ambassadors-slam-ukraines-honor-of-nazi-collaborator-612967
Response to Xolodno (Reply #10)
Post removed
Tommy Carcetti
(43,189 posts)...that would pretty much disqualify, well, everybody.
This is nothing.
Celerity
(43,478 posts)marble falls
(57,150 posts)Igel
(35,337 posts)Oneironaut
(5,519 posts)Unfortunately, Ukraine does have a lot of Nazis. This was well-known before the war. However, theyre still a very small percentage, from what I understand.
Tommy Carcetti
(43,189 posts)I change my mind.
Take everything, Putin. It's all yours.
Sky Jewels
(7,131 posts)Not.
SCantiGOP
(13,871 posts)but there are Nazi sympathizers in Ukraine, some in government and military. Many in Ukraine supported Germany in WW2 because they were so opposed to the USSR, and some because they agreed with the Nazi's racism.
This does not negate that they are overwhelmingly the side to support in the conflict with Russia. We have a Nazi problem in our country too.
And don't blame the messengers in the press for presenting factual news.
WarGamer
(12,463 posts)blm
(113,082 posts)that organized itself to oppose Russias encroachment long before Zelenskyy took office.
It would be similar to a local far right militia in US taking on the task of opposing a Canadian force that invaded the most northern part of Idaho.
PortTack
(32,787 posts)Take orders from the military! They are NOT Ukrainian soldiers. They seize any and all military equipment from the Russians and groups like Wagner. They arent concerned with removing symbols or impressing the Germans.
Shame on the Germans frankly. The German citizens for the most part do not support the war effort in Ukraine and do not want to give them aide.
WarGamer
(12,463 posts)They were the fighters in Mariupol in the Azov Stahl plant.
WhiskeyGrinder
(22,387 posts)brigade. It's not some rando militia.
WhiskeyGrinder
(22,387 posts)Journeyman
(15,037 posts)40% of the USSR's material losses were in Ukraine. 700 cities and 28,000 villages were destroyed. Who can come from such a past and now glorify those who committed the atrocities? Morons, mostly, I presume. Same classless fools as we have here.
Kseniya Simonova . . .
hlthe2b
(102,331 posts)Photo at the above link.
We have a NAZI/White Nationalist problem in our military as well, so I'd pull back on the broad swath AND Russia-friendly insinuations about the Ukrainian military.
Kingofalldems
(38,468 posts)WarGamer
(12,463 posts)hlthe2b
(102,331 posts)So ignoring this WHICH IS ONGOING while pointing at the occurrences among Ukrainian volunteers is, to me, providing big-time coverage to Putin and I'm not going to shut up when I see that. Zelensky is as Jewish as a leader can be. He does not promote Nazis nor fascism. Putin does.
WarGamer
(12,463 posts)As stated above, AZOV was rolled into the UAF
hlthe2b
(102,331 posts)WarGamer
(12,463 posts)Seriously.
hlthe2b
(102,331 posts)WarGamer
(12,463 posts)I've said AZOV every time.
TheProle
(2,192 posts)must either give Ukraine a pass or you're supporting Putin is bullshit.
Cross-posted from another thread on this subject:
either side of the debate will acknowledge. Putin's invasion of Ukraine is criminal and should be condemned, but the type of apologia illustrated in the OP is revisionist history. Ukraine's far-right problem is real.
Ukraine's Nazi problem is real, even if Putin's 'denazification' claim isn't
(https://www.nbcnews.com/think/opinion/ukraine-has-nazi-problem-vladimir-putin-s-denazification-claim-war-ncna1290946)
Far-right Extremism as a Threat to Ukrainian Democracy
https://freedomhouse.org/report/analytical-brief/2018/far-right-extremism-threat-ukrainian-democracy
Congress bans arms to Ukraine militia linked to neo-Nazis
https://thehill.com/policy/defense/380483-congress-bans-arms-to-controversial-ukrainian-militia-linked-to-neo-nazis/
The letter
https://khanna.house.gov/sites/khanna.house.gov/files/Combat%20Anti-Semitism%20Letter.pdf
Democrat signatories:
Khanna, Nadler, Raskin, Jayapal, Ellison, Jackson Lee, Wasserman Schultz, Jeffries and others.
https://www.democraticunderground.com/?com=view_post&forum=1002&pid=17975738
Igel
(35,337 posts)Consider Stuelpnagel.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carl-Heinrich_von_St%C3%BClpnagel.
Clearly a Nazi. Heil Hitler and all that crap. Truly did horrible things. But was a hindrance to Hitler.
And he was in on the plot to kill Hitler.
Most of the "black orchestra" were Nazis. But wanted to end Nazi Germany. For one reason or another (let's not be simplistic--some just thought Hitler would destroy a great country and were absolute pragmatists in their loathing of the "Leader" .
No matter, he's 100% bad.
Same for a lot of the pro-Nazi groups in Ukraine in the '40s. They were fighting the Soviets before Hitler arrived on the western border, to liberate Ukraine--not to help Hitler. And Hitler's goons were liberating them from the Reds. Many turned on the Nazis months after they arrived--not all--when it was clear they weren't there to liberate the Ukrainians but to be the replacement oppressors. It turned mostly on whether they hated "them ferners" (Jews and Poles) more than they wanted freedom ... or not. But when the Nazis went away (some having essentially fought on the side of the Red Army in their absence) most promptly turned on the newly arrived "lberator" Red Army.
Anti-Soviet fighters. Nazis. Antifa. Pogrom-committers. Anti-Soviet fighters. Pick your month and year, all four or five. (Some of them were a bit more extreme--anti-Jewish and anti-Polish, and committed atrocities against one or both, sometimes by the side of the Nazis or under their "special" command ... then again, it's not like anti-Semitism was a quaint relic of the backwater at the time--just look at FDR--and the Poles had been the oppressors and colonialists before the Russians arrived.)
Which historically accurate facts you pick determine whether the group in question is good, neutral, or bad.
History is messy. Ideology is simplistic. Talking points are simplisticker.
Celerity
(43,478 posts)I file it all under 'the enemy of my enemy is my temporary ally and all that', as problematic as that is.
War makes strange bedfellows. Look at the US/UK and 'Uncle Joe' Stalin in WWII.
yardwork
(61,690 posts)I'm not sure what the point of this OP really is. There are Nazis among US military. Should we give up?
WarGamer
(12,463 posts)I don't have time for a long post but in summary...
Ukrainians do have a history of far right politics and yes, even Nazi collaboration.
Look up Stepan Bandera who is still revered in Ukraine today, particularly by Azov Battalion.
But Ukrainian far right politics is based in a hatred of Russia and Communism.
So I'd call it "Convenient Neo-Nazis"
They aren't really Nazis... but they like to poke the eye of the Bear by playing Nazis.
hlthe2b
(102,331 posts)military. Something which we can only hope is being adequately addressed. If our Putin-equivalent, Trump gets back in office, it will NOT.
WarGamer
(12,463 posts)It'd be similar to the AZOV Battalion.
It's not.
hlthe2b
(102,331 posts)But those implying the entire Ukrainian military is full of NAZIS does only one thing and that is to spread helpful propaganda for Putin.
WarGamer
(12,463 posts)It's primarily just the AZOV folks who were rolled into the UAF from being an independent volunteer militia.
And a huge % of them were killed in Mariupol.
Aristus
(66,436 posts)even as he helped defeat them on the battlefield.
This is a nothingschnitzel.
hlthe2b
(102,331 posts)that we are facilitating via dissemination.
WarGamer
(12,463 posts)This is a place and group for learning and companionship among friendly voices.
It does no good to treat DU like a public megaphone meant to influence the public at large.
No one here needs "convincing"
IMHO... DU is at it's BEST when DU'ers are well educated and on top of stories.
hlthe2b
(102,331 posts)WarGamer
(12,463 posts)I always think DU is at it's best when DU'ers are educated and on top of news stories.
hlthe2b
(102,331 posts)WarGamer
(12,463 posts)A small number of UAF fighters (AZOV) express neo-nazi beliefs and symbolism primarily as a "message" against Russia.
This is NOT widespread in the UAF or the Ukrainian Gov't.
For those willing to read a bit... Ukraine has a long and complex history with far right nationalism and even collaboration with Nazis.
Stepan Bandera was the Ukrainian version of Che Guevara.
Can you agree with that?
WarGamer
(12,463 posts)yardwork
(61,690 posts)Not a single supportive post as of yet. One series of posts pointing out Ukraine's complex history. Several informative posts about AZOV. Ours and others' posts noting that there are Nazis in the U.S. military.
All in all, a pretty good example of sunshine being the best disinfectant.
hlthe2b
(102,331 posts)Torchlight
(3,358 posts)Although this particular independent unit identifies with the symbolism (this unit was an original justification of Putin's desire to 'de-Nazify" the Ukraine), I see zero evidence to suggest the Ukrainian army echoes this as well.
The AZOV Brigade is neither an accurate measure nor reflection of the Ukrainian army as a whole.
sarisataka
(18,733 posts)It is history, not propaganda.
OTH there were many Ukrainians who fought against Nazis.
It is interesting that both this story and the report Ukraine may have been behind the Nordstream sabotage come out nearly at the same time. Unforced errors or is someone "guiding" the media...
quaker bill
(8,224 posts)while the nazi symbols are a controversy in Ukraine, they do have a different meaning there.
The Soviets occupied Ukraine first in WWII and imposed harsh measures that were starving people there. When the nazis declared war on the soviets a number of Ukrainians joined with the German Army in an effort to throw the Soviets out. Things did not really get better and eventually the Soviets came back.
So curiously, there is a certain Ukrainian patriotism tied to these symbols, so they are somewhat tolerated, while the related fascist ideals are not.
Fiendish Thingy
(15,650 posts)It was known before the war started, IIRC.
Its bad enough, but shouldnt be used to broad brush the Ukrainians as Nazis, following Putins propaganda.
IcyPeas
(21,901 posts)moondust
(20,002 posts)Last edited Tue Jun 6, 2023, 07:08 PM - Edit history (1)
The year that Russia annexed Crimea and the war in Donbas broke out.
The war (in Donbas) began in April 2014 when armed Russian-backed separatists seized government buildings and the Ukrainian military launched an operation against them. It continued until it was subsumed by the Russian invasion of Ukraine in February 2022.
~
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/War_in_Donbas_(2014%E2%80%932022)
ETA:
The (Azov) unit has drawn controversy over its early and allegedly continuing association with far-right groups and neo-Nazi ideology,[13] its use of controversial symbols linked to Nazism, and early allegations that members of the unit participated in torture and war crimes.
~
Most of the unit's members are Russian speakers from Russian-speaking regions of Ukraine. It also includes members from other countries.[9][23] In the wake of the Russian invasion of Ukraine, the regiment gained renewed attention, as one of the reasons given by Russian president Vladimir Putin for the invasion was the "denazification" of Ukraine, to remove the alleged control of the country by far-right forces such as Azov. During the Siege of Mariupol, the regiment played a prominent role in the city's defense, and made its final stand at the Azovstal steel plant.[24][25] The siege ended when a significant number of the regiment's fighters, including its commander, Denys Prokopenko, surrendered to Russian forces on orders from the Ukrainian high command.
~
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Azov_Brigade
Blaukraut
(5,693 posts)I wish people paid attention before posting.
obamanut2012
(26,094 posts)obamanut2012
(26,094 posts)obamanut2012
(26,094 posts)Happy Hoosier
(7,369 posts)And positing 9-year-old articles.
JonAndKatePlusABird
(312 posts)Articles posted without any indication theyre from 9 years ago
ripcord
(5,492 posts)Who the fuck posts 9 year old articles as proof of current wrong doing?