General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsWhy are so many Russian generals being killed in Ukraine?
Analysis: Five generals have been killed so far, highlighting the Russian army's weak and incompetent communication system
By Jonathan Jackson, Birmingham City University
Yet another Russian general, Lieutenant-General Andrei Mordvichev, is reported to have been killed by Ukrainian forces in a conflict that is less than a month old. Mordvichev's death was announced on Ukraine social media on March 20th, but has yet to be confirmed by the Kremlin. His death, if confirmed, will bring the number of Russian generals killed by the Ukrainian armed forces since the war began to five.
The role of an army general is to command and supervise strategy rather than conduct tactical actions on the ground. As a result, casualties at this rank have tended to be low. Comparing this figure of five reported dead in less than a month with the total number of US generals killed between 1965 and 1975 in Vietnam just 12 you have to ask why so many Russian generals are dying.
It is very likely that the targeting of Russian senior ground commanders forms part of a wider Ukrainian strategy to disrupt their enemies' command-and-control network. The Ukrainian forces are aware of the leadership approach that has been adopted by the Russian armed forces since 2001, much of which is based on international analysis conducted by the US and Nato agencies. Its rigid hierarchical system, overseen by an autocratic leader in Vladimir Putin, condemns junior ranks to a chain of perpetual fear, with little allocated for independent thinking or decision-making.
Putin manages the military in much the same way as he does the wider Russian state, choosing loyalty to him above professional competence. This is no more clearly illustrated than the choice of Sergei Shoigu as Russian defence minister in 2012. Lacking any military experience or understanding, Shoigu was chosen as he posed little political threat to Putin or established military tradition. He has been criticised by many for failing to introduce major reforms after the Georgian campaign in 2008, which highlighted key failings in the Russian military in carrying out combat operations.
https://www.rte.ie/brainstorm/2022/0323/1287913-russian-generals-deaths-ukraine/
Lovie777
(14,003 posts)mucifer
(24,527 posts)Amishman
(5,680 posts)Walleye
(33,908 posts)LiberalFighter
(53,123 posts)Duncanpup
(13,516 posts)The old saying is NCO sgts run the army and Ive read Russian army doesnt have a decent NCO program. So maybe the generals and officers are micromanaging the operation.
Sherman A1
(38,958 posts)without a NCO system in place the officers and senior officers need to lead the poorly trained, conscript army from the front, hence they make good targets for the opposition.
marie999
(3,334 posts)lagomorph777
(30,613 posts)marie999
(3,334 posts)ProudMNDemocrat
(18,420 posts)Little men with rows of ribbons for medals they NEVER earned for battles they were NEVER in.
What I call....IRONIC.
gibraltar72
(7,597 posts)to insure discipline. They too are just cannon fodder.
wishstar
(5,473 posts)Lieutenant General Yakov Rezantsev just reported killed in strike by Ukraine army. He was one who had claimed war would be over quickly.
Ukraine has reportedly intercepted many unsecure communications between Russian military leaders so they know a lot about their locations due to Russians failure to have secure intelligence.
mitch96
(14,428 posts)A dictators strategy...
m
Iggo
(48,062 posts)And theyre up to no good.
dawg
(10,693 posts)so they'd know exactly where to find them.
Quite uncanny, but just blind luck I guess.
Also, some of them could be getting fragged when they order their subordinates to march into death traps. That's always a possiblity as well.
Russia's lack of secured comms probably plays a big part as well.