General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsPakistan's Pyrrhic Victory in Afghanistan Islamabad Will Come to Regret Aiding the Taliban's Resur
Pakistans security establishment is cheering the Talibans recent military gains in Afghanistan. The countrys hard-liners have funneled support to the Taliban for decades, and they can now envision their allies firmly ensconced in Kabul. Pakistan got what it wished forbut will come to regret it. A Taliban takeover will leave Pakistan more vulnerable to extremism at home and potentially more isolated on the world stage.
The end of the United States 20-year war in Afghanistan also promises to mark a turning point in its relationship with Islamabad. Pakistan has long veiled its ambitions in Afghanistan to maintain relations with Washington, but that balancing actseen in Washington as a double gamewill prove impossible in the event that a reconstituted Islamic emirate is established in Kabul. This would not be the vindication that Pakistans military is expecting: the Taliban are less likely to defer to Pakistan in their moment of triumph, and the Americans are not likely to reconcile with the group over the long term. Pakistans nightmare scenario would be to find itself caught between an uncontrollable Taliban and international demands to rein them in.
The Talibans victory will have an equally disastrous effect on Pakistans domestic peace and security. Islamist extremism has already divided Pakistani society along sectarian lines, and the ascendance of Afghan Islamists next door will only embolden radicals at home. Efforts to force the Talibans hand might result in violent blowback, with Pakistani Taliban attacking targets inside Pakistan. And if fighting between the Taliban and their opponents worsens, Pakistan will have to deal with a new flow of refugees. A civil war next door would further damage the countrys struggling economy. Pakistani critics of their countrys involvement with the Taliban have long feared and predicted this scenario. But Pakistans generals see the Taliban as an important partner in their competition with India. Weak civilian leaders in Islamabad, meanwhile, have acquiesced to a policy that prioritizes the elimination of real or perceived Indian influence in Afghanistan.
Pakistans security establishment has long obsessed about imposing a friendly government in Kabul. That fixation is rooted in the belief that India is plotting to break up Pakistan along ethnic lines and that Afghanistan will be the launching pad for antigovernment insurgencies in Pakistans Balochistan and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa regions. These fears have their roots in the fact that Afghanistan claimed parts of Balochistan and Pakistans Pashtun regions at the time of Pakistans creation in August 1947. Afghanistan recognized Pakistan and established diplomatic relations a few days later but did not acknowledge the British-drawn Durand Line as an international border until 1976. Afghanistan also remained friendly with India, leading Pakistan to allow Afghan Islamists to organize on its territory even before the Soviet occupation of Afghanistan in 1979.
https://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/afghanistan/2021-07-22/pakistans-pyrrhic-victory-afghanistan?utm_campaign=tw_daily_soc&utm_source=twitter_posts&utm_medium=social
Klaralven
(7,510 posts)The name derives from "Punjab, Afghan, Kashmir - istan".
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pakistan
The addition of small minorities of Tajiks, Uzbeks, Turkmen and Hazara won't add much to Pakistan's difficulties in managing ethnic competition.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ethnic_groups_in_Pakistan
Vogon_Glory
(9,132 posts)our treacherous, lying, double-dealing so-called allies in the Pakistani military and intelligence services. They consistently undermined our effort to defeat the Taliban and harbored Osama bin Laden and other terrorists.
Should the political winds shift in Pakistan and these (expletives) go seeking sanctuary abroad, I vehemently oppose letting those treacherous snakes take refuge in the USA.
roamer65
(36,747 posts)PM Khan would not be getting involved without support from Beijing.
Irish_Dem
(47,495 posts)They benefited a great deal from the US presence in Afghanistan which contained the violence to that country. Now the violence could spread to other areas. China has invested a huge amount of money into Pakistan and has big economic interests in the region. It is going to be working very hard at establishing ties with Afghan leaders. And stabilizing the region the best it can.
A lot is at stake for China in terms of economics and power.