Because if you want to keep eating Gulf seafood, you're going to have to go down the food chain. Way down.
This oil spill has been manna from heaven for bacteria that can digest hydrocarbons. Unfortunately, they need oxygen to wash down their lunch of petroleum and to do that, they take it out of the water, leaving none for any of the other organisms. I've written before here of the chemistry of oil consumption: CH2 + 3/2 O2 ---> CO2 + H2O. I've also noted that this equates roughly to a requirement of 15 cubic feet of air to metabolize one ounce of crude oil.
Now no one is taking up my suggestion to pump massive amounts of air into the waters of the Gulf to help the bacteria metabolize this oil, so the oxygen is going to have to come from natural processes -- oxygen exchange at the surface. Let's ask the question another way, how much water is going to be deoxygenated by bacteria feeding on one ounce of crude oil? To do that, we need to know the oxygen concentration in the water, which is conveniently charted here:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oxygen_saturation This map tells us that we would need 5 cubic meters of water to scrape up one mole of dissolved oxygen. So let's continue the calculation:
Amount of oil leaked___________________Amount of water deoxygenated
1 mole (14 gm)---------------------------5 cu. meters
1 ounce (28 gm)--------------------------10 cu. meters
1 gallon (~2800 gm)----------------------1000 cu. meters
1 'barrel'------------------------------42000 cu. meters
5000 barrels (1st estimate of leak)-------210 cu. kilometers (per day)
50000 barrels (closer to the truth)------2100 cu. kilometers (per day)
Since the water column is about 1.5 km at the well, this means that the well is poisoning an area of 1400 sq km at the surface every day, from the sea floor right up to the waves (that's 550 square miles for you non-metric types). When we get to 91 days of oil leak, we will be at 50,000 square miles of deoxygenated water -- that's just about the size of Louisiana.
Of course, the oil is not being metabolized as fast as it is being spewed out. These calculations are just to give you some idea of the remediation required. Imagine if all the life in the state of Louisiana was choked out and only the bacteria were left. No trees, no animals, just bacteria. That is what is happening 90 miles offshore.