Reply #56: I wasn't talking about America really, but far more abstract...

[Oregone]

What is YOUR opinion? Have YOU weighed this? How do YOU reconcile conflicts?

If we just claim that something is an "American" concept or tenet, that is the same as defending morality because it is written in the Bible. The constitution is man made, not God given, and rights change, evolve, and disappear continually. I think its important for people who are pro-gun or anti-gun (or in favor of any rights) to both look at the entire concept of freedom and rights in society, their consequences and their justifications.

"Give me Freedom or Give me Death" is an interesting statement, because certain Freedoms can foster conditions for Death in the right environments. On the other hand, we can look at less "free" societies that have low murder rates, high levels of health and happiness (as rated via survey). If freedom is not the universal determinant (but merely one of the factors) of happiness, contentedness and fulfillment, then many Americans may of missed the boat.