Reply #55: Because it's my home. I'm an AMERICAN

[RazzleDazzle]

We don't hate our country as much as hate its current government's ACTIONS (and maybe some of its so-called "leaders").

And then there's this little bit of confusion:

Most patriotism seems to to be more like nationalism, so I'm not suggesting you need to swoon every time you see a flag.

Swooning over the flag en masse -- and requiring others to do the same -- is more like nationalism, NOT patriotism.

But you may be right: Love it or leave it is more nationalism than patriotism. (And far more rightwing than left, as already mentioned.)

I believe it is the DUTY of "good citizens" to question their government, criticize it, and do what's necessary to make it better. You can't make something BETTER if you don't identify (and criticize!) what's bad or deficient or lacking.

Why does it bother you so much? Really -- what difference does it make to you? Is it that you think everyone should be equally pro-U.S. without questioning? Are you concerned that the criticism = hatred with no underlying devotion? I'd really like to know: what's it to ya, specifically?