Israel/Palestine

kayecy

(1,417 posts)

10. Over to you holdencaufield.....Why has the IDF not investigated the matter?

Sun May 13, 2012, 12:55 AM

May 2012

... written by reporters who weren't there, who interviewed only one side in the event

Very true......but if they hadn't written about it, no one ever know about the incident....The IDF who were there apparently had no intention of investigating the matter.

Over to you holdencaufield....The IDF have not denied that something like the action reported took place....A Palestinian was killed.........Why has the IDF not apparently investigated the matter?.......Why is shooting Palestinians treated so lightly by the IDF?

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

35 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

Unnecessary killing in West Bank [View all] kayecy May 2012 OP

Good question: Jefferson23 May 2012 #1

More: Scurrilous May 2012 #2

Was the murder... holdencaufield May 2012 #3

Of course the Itmar murders were unecessary .... kayecy May 2012 #4

Do you know the precise circumstances WRT this killing? What evidence... shira May 2012 #5

The source for this OP is a Ha'aretz editorial azurnoir May 2012 #6

An op ed... holdencaufield May 2012 #7

I must have missed that particular bit of the editorial... Violet_Crumble May 2012 #9

Over to you holdencaufield.....Why has the IDF not investigated the matter? kayecy May 2012 #10

And you know... holdencaufield May 2012 #11

I'll ask again. Where's yr evidence that the accounts of the incident are wrong? Violet_Crumble May 2012 #12

You apparently, without any evidence to the contrary, do not believe the Haretz report..... kayecy May 2012 #13

I've already asked them several times to come up with some evidence and they've not done so... Violet_Crumble May 2012 #14

Haaretz and +972 are not credible sources. shira May 2012 #15

Evidence dear Shira....Do you have any or are you merely speculating? kayecy May 2012 #16

Here's a load... shira May 2012 #17

My goodness, Shira, you are scraping the barrel......... kayecy May 2012 #18

See, I knew you'd do this. That's why I wrote it's pointless trying to convince someone... shira May 2012 #19

What an earth have Islamists, clubs & knives got to do with your claim? kayecy May 2012 #20

The point is no amount of evidence would ever be good enough for you. shira May 2012 #21

Shira – You have chosen to change a political discussion into an attack on my integrity kayecy May 2012 #29

Based on previous discussions with you, I have reason to believe that no amount of... shira May 2012 #30

But nevertheless you cannot produce a single example of such a discussion....... kayecy May 2012 #31

This example should suffice, and you haven't answered the question yet... shira May 2012 #32

Shira.....I await an apology for your public slur on my integrity...... kayecy May 2012 #33

Yep, sorry. And I must say I'm shocked @ your answer... shira May 2012 #34

An admission of a wrongful acusation from Shira!...... kayecy May 2012 #35

let's ask a central question just what does the Dudivan unit do? azurnoir May 2012 #22

I don't think know enough to say either way, do we? n/t shira May 2012 #23

so Ynet must lie too? azurnoir May 2012 #24

What you cited is a separate issue. The soldier who kicked the face... shira May 2012 #25

no it's not in fact according to most accounts the 2 Palestinians were brothers n/t azurnoir May 2012 #28

A totally different narrative from... holdencaufield May 2012 #26

perhaps you should ummm read the OP because that is not what it says n/t azurnoir May 2012 #27

No, of course not. Now, back to the OP, do you think that killing was unnecessary? Violet_Crumble May 2012 #8