Israel/Palestine

PDJane

(10,103 posts)

40. I don't.

Reply to holdencaufield (Reply #32)

Mon Jul 16, 2012, 11:23 AM

Jul 2012

And if that many people die or are displaced, Israel will not survive it.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

69 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

Are Israeli Settlements Legal? Electronic Intifada’s Ali Abunimah vs. Commentary’s Jonathan Tobin [View all] shira Jul 2012 OP

Mr. Tobin Conflates Two Things Here, Ma'am The Magistrate Jul 2012 #1

Confiscated from whom? holdencaufield Jul 2012 #2

International Law Is Pretty Clear, Sir, And Dates Back More Than a Century In Current Form The Magistrate Jul 2012 #3

You seem to disagree with the Levy report. Bradlad Jul 2012 #6

Not A Very Impressive Document, Sir: Netanyahu Appointed People To Write What He Wanted To Read The Magistrate Jul 2012 #7

I don't have any problem with your opinions. Bradlad Jul 2012 #8

It Is A Military Occupation, Sir The Magistrate Jul 2012 #9

Yes Bradlad Jul 2012 #10

The Argument Has No Merit Whatever, Sir, And Israel Does Not Hold Legal Sovereignty The Magistrate Jul 2012 #11

In my comment . . Bradlad Jul 2012 #15

Israel Is Engaged In Military Occupation, Sir, Of Territory It Had, And Has, No Sovereignty Over The Magistrate Jul 2012 #17

Wow! Bradlad Jul 2012 #21

That Article, Sir, Does Not Remotely Support Your Claim The Magistrate Jul 2012 #22

Hidden in your deflection about "loyalty" . . Bradlad Jul 2012 #23

When You Have Reviewed The 1907 Hague Convention, Sir, Try 'The Blind Men And The Elephant'... The Magistrate Jul 2012 #24

Your comment . . Bradlad Jul 2012 #25

would you agree that sabbat hunter Jul 2012 #65

You would concede that none of this applies to Israel's settlements in Syrian territory? shaayecanaan Jul 2012 #35

Well . . Bradlad Jul 2012 #37

Our debate opponents here refuse to see the difference b/w Syria & the WB.... shira Jul 2012 #38

Yes Bradlad Jul 2012 #39

So in other words, if I offer $10,000 for the murder of X shaayecanaan Jul 2012 #41

Yes, in that case . . Bradlad Jul 2012 #42

unless of course you are in occupied Syrian territory... shaayecanaan Jul 2012 #43

Article 46 Bradlad Jul 2012 #44

You're almost getting into "Yes Minister" territory there Brad... shaayecanaan Jul 2012 #45

Article 46 Bradlad Jul 2012 #46

My apologies, Brad... shaayecanaan Jul 2012 #47

Your question is still confusing. Bradlad Jul 2012 #48

Article 49 refers to forced deportations... shaayecanaan Jul 2012 #49

No. I believe that is prohibited by Article 49. n/t Bradlad Jul 2012 #50

Here's one for you. Bradlad Jul 2012 #52

Its an interesting question... shaayecanaan Jul 2012 #59

And that's an interesting answer. Bradlad Jul 2012 #62

The rest of my answer: Bradlad Jul 2012 #63

I'm not sure that you're being consistent, Brad... shaayecanaan Jul 2012 #64

I think you're being very consistent. Bradlad Jul 2012 #66

I think you're starting to lose the plot, Brad... shaayecanaan Jul 2012 #67

I think the plot is easily visible to anyone . . Bradlad Jul 2012 #68

Goodbye, Brad (nt) shaayecanaan Jul 2012 #69

The Palestinians don't have legal sovereignty either. And Jews do have rights to settlement... shira Jul 2012 #16

The Point You Are Missing, Ma'am The Magistrate Jul 2012 #19

Israeli govt inducements for Israelis to live beyond the green line is not forceful transfer.... shira Jul 2012 #29

Yes and no. aranthus Jul 2012 #18

Military Occupation Does Not Presume A State's Prior Sovereignty, Nor Is That Necessary For It The Magistrate Jul 2012 #20

Shira,I am 100% behind Israel,you can tell by my posts here. The settlements need to be dismantled. Swede Jul 2012 #4

They need to negotiate... holdencaufield Jul 2012 #5

The current borders are no more or no less defensible than the 1967 borders... shaayecanaan Jul 2012 #33

Nor is time on Israel's side Scootaloo Jul 2012 #56

Agreed LeftishBrit Jul 2012 #12

Why? Bradlad Jul 2012 #26

No... shaayecanaan Jul 2012 #34

because there is no other possibility. Shaktimaan Jul 2012 #51

"when we can trust them"? are you Israeli ? your profile says Canada azurnoir Jul 2012 #28

I presume he was inferring that Jews are unable to trust Muslims... shaayecanaan Jul 2012 #36

If either Abunimah or Tobin said that the sky was blue and the grass was green LeftishBrit Jul 2012 #13

True, Ma'am The Magistrate Jul 2012 #14

Israel's settlements are illegal, and it is an illegal occupation. PDJane Jul 2012 #27

"Israel ...will end in annihilation" holdencaufield Jul 2012 #30

Read it again. Palestinians are going to be the ones annihilated......... PDJane Jul 2012 #31

Given that... holdencaufield Jul 2012 #32

I don't. PDJane Jul 2012 #40

"Israel will not survive it." holdencaufield Jul 2012 #54

I'm an apostate Jew. I've been listening to the brainwashing and the altered history. PDJane Jul 2012 #57

"I'm an apostate Jew" holdencaufield Jul 2012 #58

Indeed Israel started in terrorism. Shaktimaan Jul 2012 #53

The conflict couldn't have been avoided, because the Ergun started the terrorism PDJane Jul 2012 #60

Well, that's just absurd. Shaktimaan Jul 2012 #61

Tobin's reading the flash cards Scootaloo Jul 2012 #55