Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Little Tich

(6,171 posts)
17. Antisemitism is definitely on the rise, but I'm not very happy with the report.
Tue May 5, 2015, 03:25 AM
May 2015

I read the chapter about Scandinavia by Dr. Mikael Shainkman, and I think he managed to cover most of the antisemitic incidents, at least all the ones I know about were included. At least that chapter was alright.

Now to the bad part. The definition of antisemitism used in the study is flawed, because it conflates criticism of Israel with antisemitism. It seems to be the former working definition of antisemitism of the EUMC, which was retracted. This definition is the darling of all those who try to accuse those who criticize Israel of being antisemites.

For example, the report contains several caricatures that are supposed to be antisemitic. The problem is that most of them are not even remotely antisemitic. This really shows how the definition leads to flawed conclusions.

It seems as if the Kantor Center for the Study of Contemporary European Jewry is trying to append pro-Israel BS onto what should have been a serious study on anti-Semitism. Not good.

If there's anyone out there who disagrees with me, please look at the caricatures in the report before you respond.

... shenmue May 2015 #1
Unfortunately these incidents will be minimized by some nt King_David May 2015 #2
Undoubtedly shenmue May 2015 #3
There is no justification for targeting people of a particular guillaumeb May 2015 #4
We not talking about that here, King_David May 2015 #5
It is the "anti" part that I was responding to. guillaumeb May 2015 #8
Start another thread about it instead of attempting to hijack this one King_David May 2015 #9
Please calm down, dave. R. Daneel Olivaw May 2015 #31
you mean like this one? azurnoir May 2015 #32
Heavy is the Head That Wears the kettle R. Daneel Olivaw May 2015 #34
Well said guillaumeb...... Israeli May 2015 #20
Yes he is right King_David May 2015 #21
Just more deflection leftynyc May 2015 #26
Unbelievable how desperate some people want to change the subject King_David May 2015 #28
All too believable leftynyc May 2015 #30
Electronic Intifada is working on "debunking" these incidents oberliner May 2015 #6
EI and quite a few posters in this group should take the German Chancellor's words to heart King_David May 2015 #7
Some posters think there are groups whose purpose is to exaggerate anti-semitic incidents oberliner May 2015 #10
That's an obnoxious thing to say ( whoever said that) nt King_David May 2015 #11
Anything to minimize leftynyc May 2015 #19
Agreed King_David May 2015 #36
Get on the track. Rolando May 2015 #12
That argument is becoming tedious . King_David May 2015 #13
What's tedious Rolando May 2015 #14
What's next? King_David May 2015 #15
Nothing Rolando May 2015 #16
Antisemitism is only about racism against Jews. Little Tich May 2015 #18
Antisemitism is definitely on the rise, but I'm not very happy with the report. Little Tich May 2015 #17
We talking about "Anti-Semitic violence" King_David May 2015 #22
I really think you should read the report. It's called “Antisemitism Worldwide 2014”. Little Tich May 2015 #23
. King_David May 2015 #24
Don't be grumpy because I'm right and you're wrong. Little Tich May 2015 #25
Minimimizing Antisemitism is what that is. King_David May 2015 #29
I’m the only one in this thread who actually has referred to the contents of the report. n/t Little Tich May 2015 #35
Barely oberliner May 2015 #39
Yep King_David May 2015 #41
You can't be surprised leftynyc May 2015 #27
Agreed King_David May 2015 #33
Nothing that you've written here about the report is true oberliner May 2015 #38
Great post King_David May 2015 #40
Some anti-Semites support Israel, like evangelical christians. Little Tich May 2015 #42
In 2015, Anti-Semitism Should No Longer Be a Reality in Europe oberliner May 2015 #37
Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Israel/Palestine»Anti-Semitic violence sur...»Reply #17