Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
Israel/Palestine
In reply to the discussion: Ahead of elections, Green Party stands by Israel boycott stance [View all]shira
(30,109 posts)4. England’s Green Party Has an Anti-Semitism Problem
http://forward.com/opinion/world/218737/england-s-green-party-has-an-anti-semitism-probl/
At a forum with voters in February, Green Party leader Natalie Bennett was asked what she would do to ensure that Jews feel safe in Britain. Bennett rambled on vaguely about funding inter-communal dialogue without even mentioning Jews, indicating that the problem of anti-Semitism was one she had never thought about before.
The Greens have emerged in recent years in England as a left-wing alternative to Labor and the Liberal Democrats, but increased representation has also brought closer scrutiny, including how their commitment to a society free from discrimination relates to Jews.
Weve known for a while that the Greens have an Israel problem. Their current manifesto includes pledges to halt arms sales to Israel equating them with Saudi Arabia as a violator of human rights and suspend the E.U.-Israel Association Agreement, which grants Israel economic benefits and closer scientific and cultural cooperation with Europe.
The Greens support either a one- or two-state solution, and call on Israel to repeal its Law of Return as it is incompatible with the full exercise of human rights and discriminates against Palestinians because they are not Jewish. They also favor the full implementation of U.N. Resolution 194, with all that would portend for Israels status as a Jewish state.
Internal party communications reveal that articles by the fascist British National Party and white supremacist David Duke have been circulated on party discussion forums. Other posts on these forums have referred to the Board of Deputies of British Jews as the Zionist lobby, adding we must smash the Zionists. Zionism in these discussions has been characterized as a form of racial discrimination, incompatible with Green views, and an ancient theological fantasy. During Operation Protective Edge, Israel was accused of visiting a second Holocaust upon the Palestinians.
At a forum with voters in February, Green Party leader Natalie Bennett was asked what she would do to ensure that Jews feel safe in Britain. Bennett rambled on vaguely about funding inter-communal dialogue without even mentioning Jews, indicating that the problem of anti-Semitism was one she had never thought about before.
The Greens have emerged in recent years in England as a left-wing alternative to Labor and the Liberal Democrats, but increased representation has also brought closer scrutiny, including how their commitment to a society free from discrimination relates to Jews.
Weve known for a while that the Greens have an Israel problem. Their current manifesto includes pledges to halt arms sales to Israel equating them with Saudi Arabia as a violator of human rights and suspend the E.U.-Israel Association Agreement, which grants Israel economic benefits and closer scientific and cultural cooperation with Europe.
The Greens support either a one- or two-state solution, and call on Israel to repeal its Law of Return as it is incompatible with the full exercise of human rights and discriminates against Palestinians because they are not Jewish. They also favor the full implementation of U.N. Resolution 194, with all that would portend for Israels status as a Jewish state.
But the Greens dont just have issues with Zionism. As early as 2010, observers noted that too often a sympathy for the plight of Palestinians spills over into full-blown anti-Semitism.
Internal party communications reveal that articles by the fascist British National Party and white supremacist David Duke have been circulated on party discussion forums. Other posts on these forums have referred to the Board of Deputies of British Jews as the Zionist lobby, adding we must smash the Zionists. Zionism in these discussions has been characterized as a form of racial discrimination, incompatible with Green views, and an ancient theological fantasy. During Operation Protective Edge, Israel was accused of visiting a second Holocaust upon the Palestinians.
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
72 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
Boycotts take a long time to reach the desired outcome. I don't think there is time, regardless.
Jefferson23
Apr 2015
#2
Is Israel the Jewish State, a name which completely discounts and devalues 20+% of it's citizens
azurnoir
Apr 2015
#8
Your article is good humor in January of 2014 ToI had Obama determining a key negotiating point
azurnoir
Apr 2015
#15
think you're grasping at straws Livni and Lapid refused to sign on to a Jewish State bill
azurnoir
Apr 2015
#20
or you can not argue that Livni and Lapid's refusal to sign onto the Jewish State bill
azurnoir
Apr 2015
#37
sigh and the Black African population of Soth Africa speaks English as it's chosen language?
azurnoir
Apr 2015
#63
That's what Apartheid was all about but you don't really know what's going on there or in Israel
King_David
Apr 2015
#64
yes they support the Jewish state bill so much they caused the government to fold
azurnoir
Apr 2015
#35
Does it itself THE Macedonian State? Does it have laws that give ethnic Macedonians advantage over n
azurnoir
Apr 2015
#25
Are non-ethnic Macedonian citzens of Macedonian called Macedonians or Albanians?
azurnoir
Apr 2015
#28
I'm pretty sure his knowledge of Macedonia equals your knowledge on The Jewish state nt
King_David
Apr 2015
#50
Calling Israel a Jewish state doesn't discount or devalue any of its citizens.
aranthus
Apr 2015
#60
So you're thinking of a binational disaster like Lebanon, Yugoslavia, Cyprus, Pakistan, Sri Lanka...
shira
Apr 2015
#11
I'm not a proponent of the binational solution, I was merely correcting someone
Little Tich
Apr 2015
#19
Tell us shira by what means is the ProIsrael community acquiring internal communications ?
azurnoir
Apr 2015
#9
I'd tell you, but my fellow Elders of Zion have protocols, and giving away our secrets....
shira
Apr 2015
#32
Lol it strikes that the internal communications of oh so many 'anti-Israel' organizations
azurnoir
Apr 2015
#33
That is not surprising, they have issues as other groups have as well. When you look
Jefferson23
Apr 2015
#52