Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

HuckleB

(35,773 posts)
55. New AAP Policy on Circumcision
Wed Feb 3, 2016, 04:30 PM
Feb 2016

Last edited Wed Feb 3, 2016, 07:11 PM - Edit history (1)

https://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/new-aap-policy-on-circumcision/

"Back in 2008, I tried to look objectively at the scientific evidence for and against circumcision. I got a lot of flak from commenters who focused on the ethical issues rather than the scientific evidence. I concluded that the evidence showed small benefits and small risks, and I didn’t advocate either for or against the procedure. At the time, the American Academy of Pediatrics’ position was:

Existing scientific evidence demonstrates potential medical benefits of newborn male circumcision; however, these data are not sufficient to recommend routine neonatal circumcision. In circumstances in which there are potential benefits and risks, yet the procedure is not essential to the child’s current well-being, parents should determine what is in the best interest of the child.

On August 27, 2012, the American Academy of Pediatrics issued a revised Circumcision Policy Statement saying that the benefits outweigh the risks.

The revised policy is based on the findings of a multidisciplinary task force that did a systematic evaluation of the peer-reviewed literature from 1995 through 2010. The new statement has been endorsed by the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists.

..."


----------------------------------------

One more link: http://www.skepticalraptor.com/skepticalraptorblog.php/circumcision-separating-science-opinion/

Just FYI.

I'm satisfied with allowing parents to make medical decisions for their children. WillowTree Feb 2016 #1
It seems like a vanity thing more many these days PersonNumber503602 Feb 2016 #9
Religious reasons aren't any better... TipTok Feb 2016 #56
Doesn't AIDS virus happen more frequently with those with foreskin? yeoman6987 Feb 2016 #130
Yep. BigDemVoter Feb 2016 #132
Thanks! yeoman6987 Feb 2016 #133
There are so many factors at play there, you can't legitimately claim a causal connection. /nt Marr Feb 2016 #175
It ain't medical... MellowDem Feb 2016 #13
Really nichomachus Feb 2016 #52
Is there routinely illness involved regarding the necessity of cutting babies' genitalia? Quantess Feb 2016 #115
I've come to the opinion that it's not medical, it's aesthetic. lumberjack_jeff Feb 2016 #59
Me too. Doremus Feb 2016 #65
Yep. Mariana Feb 2016 #148
i doubt whether my dad was DesertFlower Feb 2016 #153
Back in the day, it was strongly recommended by many doctors. Mariana Feb 2016 #156
my dad was born in 1921. i don't think DesertFlower Feb 2016 #158
My dad was born later, 1938 Mariana Feb 2016 #164
From what I've seen as a health care worker, most men born in the 1920s have been intact. Crunchy Frog Feb 2016 #190
I work in a hospital, and they circumcise children like they're on a factory line! BigDemVoter Feb 2016 #159
Well, it is supported by the AAP, after a long exploration of pros and cons. HuckleB Feb 2016 #60
+1000 nt Mojorabbit Feb 2016 #81
To be fair: Act_of_Reparation Feb 2016 #86
It is not purely science. Ms. Toad Feb 2016 #199
And the US... MellowDem Feb 2016 #87
Would you be OK with parents not vaccinating their kids? davidn3600 Feb 2016 #100
I think not vacciniating kids is not a good decision. WillowTree Feb 2016 #161
Are you comparing not vaccinating with not circumcising? uppityperson Feb 2016 #186
It is not medically necessary. Boudica the Lyoness Feb 2016 #104
perhaps men should make the decision for themselves Skittles Feb 2016 #149
Message auto-removed Name removed Feb 2016 #2
Only if you're also going to spank them while smoking in an Olive Garden with a Pit Bull and yodermon Feb 2016 #3
I guess it shows some bias... MellowDem Feb 2016 #16
I am actually against circumcision as well.. Just, good luck getting a discussion going on DU yodermon Feb 2016 #34
Well hello, yodermon! Quantess Feb 2016 #64
Go team Mushroom Head... lame54 Feb 2016 #4
+1,000,000. HughBeaumont Feb 2016 #43
So we're okay with body shaming now? Crunchy Frog Feb 2016 #191
Shrug. Erich Bloodaxe BSN Feb 2016 #5
that's my response too hfojvt Feb 2016 #15
You wouldn't be... MellowDem Feb 2016 #21
many things are done to children hfojvt Feb 2016 #26
And yet... MellowDem Feb 2016 #30
Not illegal for a parent to consent to an infant's tattoo in most states. LanternWaste Feb 2016 #71
You didn't have the choice to do it... MellowDem Feb 2016 #19
I imagine it would be far more painful for an adult KamaAina Feb 2016 #24
Maybe he wouldn't have gotten it done... MellowDem Feb 2016 #27
My husband converted to Judaism as an adult but had thankfully had the circumcision CTyankee Feb 2016 #72
It's painful for a tiny infant too. lumberjack_jeff Feb 2016 #61
You don't know anything different. Boudica the Lyoness Feb 2016 #105
And unless they decide to get snipped as adults, neither do the uncut guys know any different. nt Erich Bloodaxe BSN Feb 2016 #112
.... Laffy Kat Feb 2016 #6
It may fall out of favor HassleCat Feb 2016 #7
50/50 now Doremus Feb 2016 #69
But it's a beautiful tradition commanded by the genocidal misogynist God of ancient warlords! killbotfactory Feb 2016 #8
Apparently, if your OWN culture says a knife cutting a baby's genitals is proper and healthy Quantess Feb 2016 #141
Dude, I was just asking what you planning to eat for dinner. nt Tommy_Carcetti Feb 2016 #10
I like these threads because I like finding out that I've been traumatized Orrex Feb 2016 #11
Me too TexasProgresive Feb 2016 #14
Many Muslim women... MellowDem Feb 2016 #25
I have participated in many of these threads over time Orrex Feb 2016 #36
I haven't said either... MellowDem Feb 2016 #40
Message auto-removed Name removed Feb 2016 #44
I think that is some of it... MellowDem Feb 2016 #48
Great tool for if one thinks you've been cheated: Your-skin cone emulatorloo Feb 2016 #57
Nor did I claim that you had. Orrex Feb 2016 #49
But the reasoning is the same... MellowDem Feb 2016 #68
The comparison is still invalid, whatever the reasoning Orrex Feb 2016 #92
As cultural practices... MellowDem Feb 2016 #99
But that comparison is so broad as to have no meaning Orrex Feb 2016 #111
You make no sense MellowDem Feb 2016 #117
That's garbage Orrex Feb 2016 #120
You're the one defending a "minor surgical procedure" MellowDem Feb 2016 #140
You pretend it's about consent, but I don't believe you. Orrex Feb 2016 #157
Nothing cosmetic like circumcision... MellowDem Feb 2016 #160
So you don't have a list. Got it. That's called "special pleading" Orrex Feb 2016 #170
I gave you a list... MellowDem Feb 2016 #178
You gave yet another list of bogus analogies Orrex Feb 2016 #179
How is it bogus? MellowDem Feb 2016 #180
Your list is bogus for a bunch of reasons Orrex Feb 2016 #181
You're making my point... MellowDem Feb 2016 #182
Are you a pediatrician? No? Then your opinion is close to meaningless. Orrex Feb 2016 #184
Lots of pediatricians... MellowDem Feb 2016 #185
I think many people consider the very presence of a foreskin Mariana Feb 2016 #183
They are indeed victims. Doremus Feb 2016 #74
No shit. Good thing I made no claims about botched circumcisions. Orrex Feb 2016 #96
My parents are rich, I am not.... Drahthaardogs Feb 2016 #144
They say I have diminished sensitivity. Codeine Feb 2016 #126
Yea GummyBearz Feb 2016 #134
I actually mean it seriously, after having 2 uncircumcised boyfriends. Quantess Feb 2016 #12
you didn't mention that hfojvt Feb 2016 #23
By chopping off the foreskin... MellowDem Feb 2016 #31
You are obviously free to imagine whatever you want to, no matter what I said or didn't say. Quantess Feb 2016 #35
I'm happy, I'm cut. woolldog Feb 2016 #17
Compared to what? MellowDem Feb 2016 #37
Comparisons between infant & adult circumcision are invalid Orrex Feb 2016 #53
How is the nerve involvement different? MellowDem Feb 2016 #84
People will do UglyGreed Feb 2016 #107
"Intact" is offensive term in this context Orrex Feb 2016 #108
And calling me not normal UglyGreed Feb 2016 #114
Let me add those UglyGreed Feb 2016 #116
Who said it's fine? Anyone who calls you abnormal for that is an asshole. Orrex Feb 2016 #118
I used the term intact UglyGreed Feb 2016 #121
It is a big deal, because you're using a term without knowing what it means Orrex Feb 2016 #122
Intact also UglyGreed Feb 2016 #123
example UglyGreed Feb 2016 #124
it's cleaner, cuter, and more mouth-friendly. UglyGreed Feb 2016 #127
Erect penises look the same, whether circumcised or not. They are quite easy to keep clean too. And uppityperson Feb 2016 #187
It was someone else's comment in this thread UglyGreed Feb 2016 #188
Comparisons between appendectomy and circumcision are invalid Orrex Feb 2016 #113
i predict that by the end of this day this p[ost will have a hundred responses saturnsring Feb 2016 #18
You were correct! jonno99 Feb 2016 #167
thank you very much. saturnsring Feb 2016 #171
My father was circumcised when he was 80... meaculpa2011 Feb 2016 #20
Guys in europe, after a few drinks, when the topic comes up... Quantess Feb 2016 #22
Guys in Europe also ask... meaculpa2011 Feb 2016 #32
I appreciate your humor. This is a serious topic. Quantess Feb 2016 #41
Yes it is, and this is a serious answer... meaculpa2011 Feb 2016 #47
Circumcision is unnecessary, it just is. Quantess Feb 2016 #51
Wow !!! TubbersUK Feb 2016 #58
Because culture and because doctors recommend it - or at least don't object. n/t lumberjack_jeff Feb 2016 #62
Thanks :) TubbersUK Feb 2016 #70
"culture" so so sons will look like their dads? Quantess Feb 2016 #136
I don't think it's quite that high. subterranean Feb 2016 #82
I'm circumcised as are both of are sons. If I had another son we would make the decision to Waldorf Feb 2016 #28
The real question... MellowDem Feb 2016 #39
I don't have a foreskin in this debate. Tierra_y_Libertad Feb 2016 #29
There are pros & cons to male circumcision. Female circumcision? I'm not aware of any "pros". jonno99 Feb 2016 #33
There are no pros.... MellowDem Feb 2016 #38
You appear to have strong feelings on this topic. What I wonder is - if you could - would jonno99 Feb 2016 #42
Would you deny a husband the choice... MellowDem Feb 2016 #46
I think the boys should have a choice. nt. Mariana Feb 2016 #151
. UglyGreed Feb 2016 #45
John Harvey Kellogg PufPuf23 Feb 2016 #106
And after his fine UglyGreed Feb 2016 #128
I was shocked by what I found about Kellogg after watching the video you posted PufPuf23 Feb 2016 #145
Strange how somethings UglyGreed Feb 2016 #147
+1 DetlefK Feb 2016 #177
I didn't mind, my son didn't seem to mind. ileus Feb 2016 #50
My son's slicing UglyGreed Feb 2016 #54
"didn't seem to mind" lumberjack_jeff Feb 2016 #63
New AAP Policy on Circumcision HuckleB Feb 2016 #55
Apparently many on this board only... meaculpa2011 Feb 2016 #78
It's certainly a debate within the world science community, still. HuckleB Feb 2016 #80
The AAP... MellowDem Feb 2016 #89
That may be. HuckleB Feb 2016 #90
Other organizations have explored it... MellowDem Feb 2016 #97
I know that fully well. HuckleB Feb 2016 #98
Thanks for your very informative input - it's greatly appreciated. nt jonno99 Feb 2016 #165
I'm certain this particular topic has not been discussed fewer than 21 times on DU LanternWaste Feb 2016 #66
A funny story about circumcision nichomachus Feb 2016 #67
Mine went OK, and I'm glad I had it. But I asked my sons ... 11 Bravo Feb 2016 #73
Foreskin Sexual Function/Circumcision Sexual Dysfunction UglyGreed Feb 2016 #95
Is it circumcision week on DU already? Sheesh! MineralMan Feb 2016 #75
I thought we had 5 more shopping days before Circumcision Day NightWatcher Feb 2016 #76
they had to jam it in before the swimsuit issue week. nt msanthrope Feb 2016 #172
You can take the people out of the stone age, but you can't take the stone age out of the people. ZombieHorde Feb 2016 #77
Male circumcision is analogous to female circumcision only if the glans penis is removed, Aristus Feb 2016 #79
Finally! R.A. Ganoush Feb 2016 #83
because hygine is something little boys are really, really good at... Sen. Walter Sobchak Feb 2016 #85
You don't bathe regularly? Quantess Feb 2016 #138
I've let my daughters and their adult husbands, elleng Feb 2016 #88
It's weird... MellowDem Feb 2016 #93
'Immoral?' elleng Feb 2016 #94
FGM3, FGM type3 Quantess Feb 2016 #102
There is NO comparison between male circumcision and FGM. None at all. smirkymonkey Feb 2016 #119
There is when it comes to the reasoning behind it... MellowDem Feb 2016 #196
Erection looks circumcised, nonerect looks like I have a protective cover... pbmus Feb 2016 #91
CDC Encourages Circumcision even for Adult Men doxyluv13 Feb 2016 #101
Sounds like an American thing. (no text) Quantess Feb 2016 #110
it usually depends on the father shanti Feb 2016 #103
I'm a father who was circumcised, and we didn't circumcise our son. HuckleB Feb 2016 #109
Happily circumcised. Codeine Feb 2016 #125
If I have sons I don't plan to circumcise them... JPnoodleman Feb 2016 #129
Wow it is circumcision debate month already? Time flys GummyBearz Feb 2016 #131
never been a problem for me & wildbilln864 Feb 2016 #135
What gives an adult the right to do cosmetic surgery on a baby? Quantess Feb 2016 #137
Oh please, the answer is right in your own thread. But of course you know that... jonno99 Feb 2016 #166
circumcision is not cruel Takket Feb 2016 #139
I had outpatient surgery without anaesthetic with a few days old. I can't remember of course, LeftyMom Feb 2016 #143
when my son was born in 1961, my ob suggested it and I deferred to my husband. CTyankee Feb 2016 #174
Having no memory of something... MellowDem Feb 2016 #197
There are health benefits. I know of none in FGM. Yo_Mama Feb 2016 #142
I am glad I was cut. bigwillq Feb 2016 #146
I love my Little General. cherokeeprogressive Feb 2016 #150
I am very happy with mine NowSam Feb 2016 #152
I don't think anyone should be circumcised while eating at Olive Garden if there are CBGLuthier Feb 2016 #154
You win! beac Feb 2016 #193
my first husband was not and sometimes DesertFlower Feb 2016 #155
I couldn't agree more, which is why, liberalhistorian Feb 2016 #162
It's not just "cosmetic". It's functional impairment for both sexes. Manifestor_of_Light Feb 2016 #163
I don't care one way or another bhikkhu Feb 2016 #168
The real reason was it was a lucrative sideline for doctors after WWII That and Protestants wanted Monk06 Feb 2016 #169
got to go with the cut version, based simply on mouth feel. nt msanthrope Feb 2016 #173
i agree. Prefer uncircumcized myself. MariaThinks Feb 2016 #176
Agreed on all counts. Fearless Feb 2016 #189
When I see such intense discussion by a few making huge post numbers, Jim Beard Feb 2016 #192
I thought insurance normally doesn't pay Mariana Feb 2016 #194
Circumcision Cost Jim Beard Feb 2016 #195
For me, it's because... MellowDem Feb 2016 #198
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Male circumcision is wron...»Reply #55