Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

General Discussion

Showing Original Post only (View all)
 

Liberal_in_LA

(44,397 posts)
Sun Feb 26, 2012, 06:02 PM Feb 2012

Drunk Woman Hands Over Car Keys to Boyfriend & Faces 30 Years in Prison for It! [View all]

She probably thought she was doing the right thing. When 21-year-old Erin Brown was too wasted to drive her Toyota Scion home after a night out on the town, she gave the keys to her boyfriend, Trevor Bradshaw. Which would’ve been a responsible decision, except he was drunk too — and ended up hitting and killing two pedestrians as he swerved through the streets of Nashville. That’s tragic in and of itself.

But prosecutors are now dusting off a rarely used law to charge Brown with vehicular homicide right along with her man, citing that anyone who knowingly hands over their keys to an intoxicated person is just as liable for any damages as the individual behind the wheel. Now she’s facing 30 years in jail because she wasn’t astute enough in her drunkenness to realize that her boo was too tipsy to drive.

So what we’re basically saying here is that it was up to Brown to discern how far gone Bradshaw was rather than it being up to him to admit that he was too stewed to play chauffeur. Under that line of thinking, it must be a mugging victim’s fault for wearing a super snazzy handbag and tempting a renegade thief to steal it.

The sad fallout from their bad decision-making means two young men are now dead: Michael Brooksher, 22, and Tommy Allen, 23. The best friends both suffered injuries that killed them shortly after they were plowed down at 2:30 in the morning back in December. If the D.A.’s office has its way, this incident will also claim the lives of two more young people, with Brown and Bradshaw serving three decades behind bars, which puts them darn near in their golden years by the time they get out if they serve full sentences.
http://thestir.cafemom.com/in_the_news/133358/drunk_woman_hands_over_car

59 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Good. If you go out drinking for an evening with someone, you should know that they can't drive. JVS Feb 2012 #1
I'm with you on this one. She knew before they went out drinking that there wouldn't be Honeycombe8 Feb 2012 #33
I don't buy it MrBig Feb 2012 #2
Don't you have to assume that her boyfriend was drinking with her? Cali_Democrat Feb 2012 #3
I've been out with people who will swear that they aren't impaired... Luminous Animal Feb 2012 #10
Many people will claim they are fine when they are not. liberalhistorian Feb 2012 #17
It can be tough when you're drunk Cali_Democrat Feb 2012 #19
That's the thing about being drunk... diminished capacity to Luminous Animal Feb 2012 #29
I have totally BTDT laundry_queen Feb 2012 #50
After an experience similar to that when I was 22. After that Luminous Animal Feb 2012 #53
How about someone you drink with regularly? cherokeeprogressive Feb 2012 #56
if you can't really give consent when you are drunk La Lioness Priyanka Feb 2012 #11
probably not Liberal_in_LA Feb 2012 #13
I was thinking about that part, too. Robb Feb 2012 #6
If they were drinking together, which sounds like the case, liberalhistorian Feb 2012 #16
no it wouldn't qazplm Feb 2012 #21
The "facts" are that two innocent people liberalhistorian Feb 2012 #25
This is what comes of Privatizing prisons. AND promising to keep them stocked with prisioners. Justice wanted Feb 2012 #4
nailed it. miyazaki Feb 2012 #27
They're going to have to prove she wasn't drunk enough to not know how drunk he was. rug Feb 2012 #5
Yeah, they are going to have a hard time threading that needle. morningfog Feb 2012 #22
Agreed. rug Feb 2012 #24
I don't know of any crime where you're absolved just because you're drunk Major Nikon Feb 2012 #23
If the statute requires knowing conduct they have to prove the mens rea of knowledge. rug Feb 2012 #28
Manslaughter doesn't require criminal intent Major Nikon Feb 2012 #35
Recklessness also requires a mens rea. moriah Feb 2012 #36
The fact that alcohol impairs judgement is common knowledge Major Nikon Feb 2012 #40
Yep. Negligence can be easily proven. moriah Feb 2012 #41
That's a strict liability crime. rug Feb 2012 #48
No, but you must be aware of the risk of death and consciously disregard it,. rug Feb 2012 #47
There's a bit more to the story Major Nikon Feb 2012 #49
That's what the case will pivot on - if they can prove it. rug Feb 2012 #52
I'm not really feeling much sympathy for this woman or her boyfriend. Skinner Feb 2012 #7
some people can drink and not seem drunk. Maybe her boyfriend was that Liberal_in_LA Feb 2012 #8
I have two friends like that. Luminous Animal Feb 2012 #12
Just because you don't "seem" drunk liberalhistorian Feb 2012 #18
Back in my 20's I was like that. RC Feb 2012 #38
I can see a penalty,but nothing as severe as the person who did the driving.nt athenasatanjesus Feb 2012 #9
why not.how many bars have been sued b/c they continued to serve someone who was "obviously" tipped leftyohiolib Feb 2012 #14
A trial to face 30 years in prison, or being killed without trial.... boppers Feb 2012 #15
voluntart intoxication is a defense qazplm Feb 2012 #20
two people are dead. it was her car, her keys, her permission. you think she could walk away free? unblock Feb 2012 #26
It would be helpful to know BAC JonLP24 Feb 2012 #30
Both these idiots deserve jail time. Odin2005 Feb 2012 #31
Thirty years worth? Comrade Grumpy Feb 2012 #37
They KILLED people. Odin2005 Feb 2012 #44
Yes. Chan790 Feb 2012 #54
well, the mugging analogy doesn't make much sense fishwax Feb 2012 #32
This fails every test I can think of in terms of why you would want to prosecute something stevenleser Feb 2012 #34
+1 You nailed it on perfectly rational grounds. Joe Shlabotnik Feb 2012 #42
I agree JonLP24 Feb 2012 #46
No death that is the result of a drunk driver should be considered "ACCIDENTAL". cherokeeprogressive Feb 2012 #57
lol. i think you forgot the sarcasm thingy. stevenleser Feb 2012 #59
Maybe it's time to make breathalizers available to restaurant patrons? ecstatic Feb 2012 #39
I raised that once 20 something years ago and found out the reason why places dont do it. stevenleser Feb 2012 #51
This is the sort of injustice Americans love. Vattel Feb 2012 #43
No sympathy here. Sorry, I have no problem with it. aaaaaa5a Feb 2012 #45
I think the prosecutor is making the right decision. n/t Chan790 Feb 2012 #55
This reminds me of an episode of The Simpsons... Drunken Irishman Feb 2012 #58
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Drunk Woman Hands Over Ca...