2016 Postmortem
Related: About this forumCeding The Nation To Conservatism
Recently while pointing out the political leanings of the two candidates I was berated for placing them in "fake" positions on the political spectrum (I didn't place them anywhere, Political Compass did) and presented with this chart showing how they're both really just way out on the left with Sanders a bit more so.... but come on! Really they're both just big old leftist liberals!
Now... I want you to look at that chart. Look at where Bernie is on it. Think about that for a minute. A lot of people on this board look at that chart and thinnk "uh-huh... looks about right! Bernie sure is a big old leftie!"
Those people have handed the country to Conservatism and they are so far gone they don't even understand what they are doing.
That chart says Bernie Sanders is as far to the left as it is possible for a human being to be. The guy who just wants a little more regulation of a still free market capitalist system and *some* increase in government involvement in critical areas like provision of health care.
As. Far. Left. As. Humanly. Possible.
Let that sink in for a minute, and then wake the fuck up people. If you think this graph is credible then you have simply internalized the massively rightwardly skewed political environment of the United States so thoroughly it no longer even registers to you what you are doing. Because the truth is Bernie Sanders is not some radical fringe leftist. Plotted on the full spectrum of political positions he's center left. He's the most centrist of any candidate running in this election. To think anything else is to accept the Republican frame that their policies are "center right" rather than radically right. If you accept the VoteMatch frame of the political landscape then you also accept this from the same source using the same assumptions:
That's their graph for Donald Trump. You may notice that using their definition of the political spectrum, which is what it takes to plot Clinton and Sanders as both way out on the left, he is significantly closer to a Moderate than Hillary Clinton. Anyone buying that? No? Of course not, when it's thrown in your face in clear terms.
If you accept this framing then what you have done is taken reality:
...and you have let the Republicans hand you a set of blinders to reshape that reality to this:
If you find yourself living in that reality, you've already given up. If that's how you want to proceed that's your call, but please don't try to drag everyone else on the left down with you by trying to convince them to surrender too.
merrily
(45,251 posts)gcomeau
(5,764 posts)Would rather just focus on the undeniable fact that people embracing things like Votematch are implicitly accepting a frame of the political spectrum that defines Republicans as "center right" and Trump as more of a moderate than Clinton as opposed to the reality of the radical right lunacy that is the modern GOP.
merrily
(45,251 posts)given issue, like Medicare for All. to use that issue just as one example.
http://www.democraticunderground.com/12777036
When Obama ran in 2008, over 70% favored Medicare for All. Then it went to slightly over a majority. Before, only Republicans were attacking it. Now that Democrats are attacking it, too, combined efforts may get the number down even further. But, it started at over 70%, until the propaganda machine began whirring. (Remember, Bush left office with about a 30% approval rating.) (I have not said a word about anyone's motivation, only what people say.)
gcomeau
(5,764 posts)I meant the post to be referring to what people on this forum were doing by accepting this ridiculous frame, not a commentary on the general driving factors forcing American politics rightward. So in that context I read "forcing" as an accusation that people here were trying to drive to the right rather then being duped into yielding ground to it.
Matariki
(18,775 posts)UglyGreed
(7,661 posts)confusing
hifiguy
(33,688 posts)Doctor_J
(36,392 posts)thereismore
(13,326 posts)Ron Green
(9,825 posts)when I saw that. Good work!
Ferd Berfel
(3,687 posts)and as I write this I"m listening to Hartmann on the radio tell us how there is no real difference between Sanders and Clinton
I hope if I ever run for elected office that I don't have any "supporters" like Hartmann. You can't win with 'supporters' like this.
highprincipleswork
(3,111 posts)You know, the kind of pissed off people that are willing to donate over 40 million dollars in small amounts over a month!
Not to mention all the volunteering and door to door.
Ferd Berfel
(3,687 posts)highprincipleswork
(3,111 posts)fredamae
(4,458 posts)"we" ceded long ago....we're trying to reverse it...now. But we can't progress when the people who Still Can Vote-Don't VOTE.
Response to gcomeau (Original post)
Ferd Berfel This message was self-deleted by its author.
Land Shark
(6,346 posts)gcomeau
(5,764 posts)But they had to put him *somewhere*. So they used him to define the most extreme possible left position.
UglyGreed
(7,661 posts)when I takes these tests I am little bit to the left of Sanders yet many of the Hillary supporters call me a right winger
tk2kewl
(18,133 posts)UglyGreed
(7,661 posts)I'm a right winger!!!!! Oh I better include tag or this post will be back to haunt me
Doctor_J
(36,392 posts)much of a lie as calling Mrs Clinton principled
gcomeau
(5,764 posts)Their view of the political landscape has become so skewed they actually believe center right policies are "liberal" and solidly right policies are moderate.
It's like they've been so traumatized by the last 30 years of US politics that they've lost the ability to rationally evaluate what is left and what is right.