Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

DonViejo

(60,536 posts)
Thu Oct 18, 2012, 08:36 PM Oct 2012

Scott Brown Exaggerated Afghanistan Military Service, Says Man Who Inspired Medal Bill

Source: Huffington Post

WASHINGTON -- The man who inspired Sen. Scott Brown to write a bill making it illegal to falsely claim military honors said he thinks the Massachusetts Republican is stretching the truth when he claims to have "served in Afghanistan."

Brown made the Afghanistan declaration in his recent debate with his Democratic opponent for the Senate seat, Elizabeth Warren. But Brown's service in Afghanistan was not combat. It was part of his annual two-week stint with the National Guard, in which he requested, in a highly unusual move, to serve in Afghanistan.

-snip-

"I thought it was seriously misleading," said Sterner, whose website outing heroes was the basis for Brown's "Stolen Valor" bill. Sterner's criticism echoes a Boston Globe editorial published Thursday morning. "I think it does go to an issue of personal character and that concerns me," added Sterner, who earlier this year broke with Brown and has endorsed Warren.

-snip-

"I would be the last person to denigrate anybody's National Guard service, but I thought the claim, putting himself on par with men and women who have done combat tours, often in excess of a year, 14 months, was a pretty cheesy thing to do," Sterner said.

more

Read more: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/10/18/scott-brown-afghanistan-military-service_n_1982921.html?utm_hp_ref=politics

33 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Scott Brown Exaggerated Afghanistan Military Service, Says Man Who Inspired Medal Bill (Original Post) DonViejo Oct 2012 OP
The 50-50 guy stretch the truth .... MindMover Oct 2012 #1
LOL... DonViejo Oct 2012 #2
very heaven05 Oct 2012 #3
Thank you for your service as well, heaven05. Yours is for real and his can't begin to compare. calimary Oct 2012 #5
see your 13, and raise you 3 pasto76 Oct 2012 #10
true on the bearings heaven05 Oct 2012 #30
One week actually in Afghanistan karynnj Oct 2012 #11
no no. you're not allowed to talk about your service in the military. mopinko Oct 2012 #18
two weeks with his feet up on a desk Submariner Oct 2012 #16
LOL nt SunSeeker Oct 2012 #19
Scotty was there only SEVEN days, mostly meeting commanders he has oversight of FailureToCommunicate Oct 2012 #23
same here roscoeroscoe Oct 2012 #24
yep heaven05 Oct 2012 #25
Thank you for your service! We will not let this Pretty-boy's tall tales denigrate your sacrifice. calimary Oct 2012 #4
Republicans really do have trouble telling the truth Berlum Oct 2012 #6
So what did he DO in A'stan? DissidentVoice Oct 2012 #7
Having secret meetings with ashling Oct 2012 #12
Unlike you, he as a Senator, sitting on the Armed Services committee, karynnj Oct 2012 #13
Lemme summarize your post: "Nothing. He did nothing. For 2 weeks." DRoseDARs Oct 2012 #22
Before my time DissidentVoice Oct 2012 #28
Brown aspires to be "cheesy". Cheesy is not flattering, but still much better than Brown. Scuba Oct 2012 #8
This a Pattern of gross exaggeration with Scott Brown.. Cha Oct 2012 #9
We have a similar problem up in Maine. 4bucksagallon Oct 2012 #14
Republicans or Ferengi? n/t dragonlady Oct 2012 #26
snakes! heaven05 Oct 2012 #27
I worked with these 2 weeks a year guys itsrobert Oct 2012 #15
Fuckwad better hope he doesn't have to go back again! lonestarnot Oct 2012 #17
He'll have plenty of time soon to go back! SunSeeker Oct 2012 #20
He requested to be sent their for his own personal and political benefit. olddad56 Oct 2012 #21
Boston Globe editorial calls out Brown's hypocrisy: “faux-fighters” who lie to “obtain FailureToCommunicate Oct 2012 #29
Did I ever tell you all about the time I earned a Navy Cross and DSM from a covert mission? Blue_Tires Oct 2012 #31
From a seperate article, about the same subject southshore Oct 2012 #32
Kick! n/t Tx4obama Oct 2012 #33

DonViejo

(60,536 posts)
2. LOL...
Thu Oct 18, 2012, 08:45 PM
Oct 2012

my thoughts EXACTLY LOL

As a veteran, I am personally insulted by Snotty Scotty though.

But, thanks for the laugh!

 

heaven05

(18,124 posts)
3. very
Thu Oct 18, 2012, 08:51 PM
Oct 2012

insulted. 13 months in the combat zone. He's a POS. two weeks with his feet up on a desk in a LARGE base camp probably.

calimary

(81,238 posts)
5. Thank you for your service as well, heaven05. Yours is for real and his can't begin to compare.
Thu Oct 18, 2012, 08:56 PM
Oct 2012

Two weeks isn't NEARLY comparable to 13 months!!!!!

You've got class and he's got a lot of nerve. I've never served and even I am outraged by this!

pasto76

(1,589 posts)
10. see your 13, and raise you 3
Thu Oct 18, 2012, 09:25 PM
Oct 2012

mortar round coulda made a bullseye on him in those 2 weeks, but in a typical tour, 2 weeks you are just getting your bearings.

 

heaven05

(18,124 posts)
30. true on the bearings
Fri Oct 19, 2012, 03:59 PM
Oct 2012

it took me two weeks to finally say on the mortar rounds, he's an prima donna diva. fuck him he woulda been in the bunker first screaming for his momma. ten-four on the 16.

karynnj

(59,503 posts)
11. One week actually in Afghanistan
Thu Oct 18, 2012, 09:30 PM
Oct 2012

and much of that in the role as a typical Senator. The thing that is stupid is that he really would get some credit just for his years in the national guard - especially if he spoke modestly of it turning down praise from his supporters.

But, the fact is that he is not the Senator who has spent the most time working in Afghanistan - he is not even the MA Senator who has spent the most time there. Not to mention, Kerry's time was far better spent and far more important. (Not to mention - many in MA remember that the same people impressed with Brown's week in Afghanistan criticized as too little the time Kerry spent being a hero in a real war.)

mopinko

(70,090 posts)
18. no no. you're not allowed to talk about your service in the military.
Thu Oct 18, 2012, 10:03 PM
Oct 2012

just ask deadbeat joe walsh.

Submariner

(12,503 posts)
16. two weeks with his feet up on a desk
Thu Oct 18, 2012, 09:55 PM
Oct 2012

not even that long. 3 days transition training in DC, then 10 to 11 days in country. Probably playing billiards and ping pong because base commander didn't want a Senator hurt on his watch.

FailureToCommunicate

(14,013 posts)
23. Scotty was there only SEVEN days, mostly meeting commanders he has oversight of
Thu Oct 18, 2012, 11:42 PM
Oct 2012

as ranking member of Arms Services Committee.

More links in this thread:

http://www.democraticunderground.com/10021542286

roscoeroscoe

(1,370 posts)
24. same here
Fri Oct 19, 2012, 04:40 AM
Oct 2012

two tours, 24 months away from my wife. pretty lame move, scott brown, you didn't even qualify for family separation pay.

 

heaven05

(18,124 posts)
25. yep
Fri Oct 19, 2012, 11:07 AM
Oct 2012

glad you made it brother. Peace to you and your family. I appreciate your loyalty and service. But I guess you know that goes without saying. You brothers today with your 2-3 tours, fucking amazing, the strength of the american protectors!

calimary

(81,238 posts)
4. Thank you for your service! We will not let this Pretty-boy's tall tales denigrate your sacrifice.
Thu Oct 18, 2012, 08:53 PM
Oct 2012

DissidentVoice

(813 posts)
7. So what did he DO in A'stan?
Thu Oct 18, 2012, 09:11 PM
Oct 2012

I was in the Air National Guard. I did not serve in a combat zone. All I did was show up, do what I was told, and walk away with a piece of paper saying "Honorable Discharge."

If the balloon had gone up and the Soviets would have sent Tupolevs and ICBM's at CONUS, chances are I would have been in a bunker somewhere like Cheyenne Mountain or Keflavik Iceland (comms puke).

There is no way I would put my service in the same category with those who actually got shot at, not to mention made the ultimate sacrifice.

My question is: OK, he went to A'stan as part of his AcDuTra (Active Duty For Training). What did he do, especially given that he was a Lieutenant Colonel?

I'm not going to call him a REMF because I was one myself.

karynnj

(59,503 posts)
13. Unlike you, he as a Senator, sitting on the Armed Services committee,
Thu Oct 18, 2012, 09:36 PM
Oct 2012

ASKED to have his training in Afghanistan. I doubt there has been another JAG sent for one week to Afghanistan. The cost would be prohibitive. For the most part, he did what any SENATOR would do on a trip to a foreign country - and they also visit the troops from their state. He spoke of sleeping in their place and having meals with the MA national guard.

The key thing though is that this was a Scott Brown designed trip - and there are suspicions that it was for political reasons.

 

DRoseDARs

(6,810 posts)
22. Lemme summarize your post: "Nothing. He did nothing. For 2 weeks."
Thu Oct 18, 2012, 11:33 PM
Oct 2012

Like you said, he's a senator in a combat zone. "Suspicions" is not the word you're looking for. If Warren really wanted to play Dirty, Nasty Politics (tm) she could make a lot of hay of this. But that is entirely beneath her and that's a good thing. Hmm, where's Michael Moore these days...

DissidentVoice

(813 posts)
28. Before my time
Fri Oct 19, 2012, 01:47 PM
Oct 2012

When I was in the military, A'stan was basically known as "the Soviet graveyard." There's no way I could have had my training there...because at that time I could never have foreseen the U.S. Military, not to mention our NATO and British Commonwealth allies, shedding blood there.

I honestly didn't know he was a JAG officer. I live in Michigan, not Massachusetts, so I'm not as familiar with his background. Wikipedia (as trustworthy or not as that may be) says that he is now a Colonel and that when he was in A'stan he spent most of his time in Kabul. I wore stripes, not brass, so, as we used to say, that's way above my paygrade.

Cha

(297,190 posts)
9. This a Pattern of gross exaggeration with Scott Brown..
Thu Oct 18, 2012, 09:23 PM
Oct 2012

wannabe senator.

What was that about him bragging he met with kings and queens?

Brown pushed back on the accusation, saying on the air, “Each and every day that I’ve been a United States senator, I’ve been either discussing issues, meeting on issues, in secret meetings with kings and queens and prime ministers and business leaders and military leaders talking, voting, working on issues every single day.”


Read more: http://www.politico.com/news/stories/0612/77697.html#ixzz29hh7zNqD

Brawawaa later he was said to have Misspoke about the kings and queens part. Rofl

4bucksagallon

(975 posts)
14. We have a similar problem up in Maine.
Thu Oct 18, 2012, 09:44 PM
Oct 2012

Republican Chuckles Summers was a Public Affairs Officer, who once got near where there was some shooting and now proudly wears a CAB, no one is sure if it is from the one shot or from an extremely deep paper cut. One thing is for certain if a Republican makes claims of being a veteran check out their claims. They are usually spreading BS. When I was in Nam the large majority of what would be called Republicans, we called them juicers, were in the rear selling our supplies to the Commies on the black market. So yes one could say that Republicans are more capitalistic than most. If not for the fact that they don't always sell what is theirs to sell. After all greed is good and business is business. LOL!

 

heaven05

(18,124 posts)
27. snakes!
Fri Oct 19, 2012, 11:37 AM
Oct 2012

Last edited Fri Oct 19, 2012, 04:10 PM - Edit history (1)

A CIB-CAB(combat infantryman's badge) is not to be worn lightly and in my day was won in extremely stressful situations to put it mildly. Heads and juicers. Which one did I trust? Both most times. Peace.

itsrobert

(14,157 posts)
15. I worked with these 2 weeks a year guys
Thu Oct 18, 2012, 09:46 PM
Oct 2012

Those two week includes their travel time. So knock 3 days off it. Than their unpacking all their gear and their training. They must attend briefings. Packing their gear back up. And so on. You get about 5 days of work out of them, if you're lucky.

olddad56

(5,732 posts)
21. He requested to be sent their for his own personal and political benefit.
Thu Oct 18, 2012, 10:55 PM
Oct 2012

he is such a loser that even the goppers are starting to see through him.

Blue_Tires

(55,445 posts)
31. Did I ever tell you all about the time I earned a Navy Cross and DSM from a covert mission?
Fri Oct 19, 2012, 04:21 PM
Oct 2012

I really, really wish I could tell you, but the mission didn't "officially" exist, and I wasn't "officially" enlisted in any "official" armed forces...

 

southshore

(43 posts)
32. From a seperate article, about the same subject
Fri Oct 19, 2012, 04:42 PM
Oct 2012

In the past two years, the senator has also won a much-coveted promotion to colonel, one notch below general.

He secured it after a surprising transfer to the Maryland National Guard. Veteran ­observers of the Maryland Guard say it is the first time the state’s main judge advocate general corps, the military’s equivalent of a law firm, has had four colonels attached to it. Military manning documents authorize it for one.

Brown’s dual roles and transfer have created a rare phenomenon: a US senator from Massachusetts sworn as a military officer to uphold the constitution of Maryland and, should the need arise, to take orders from Governor Martin O’Malley of Maryland.

Brown’s uniform bears a Guard emblem for Maryland, a state where he does not live, work, or fulfill his duty.


[link:http://www.boston.com/news/politics/2012/10/11/brown-guard-service-has-taken-political-patina-since-joined-senate/10YtaEcoRONsXFD0Zok7QJ/story.html?camp=pm|

Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»Scott Brown Exaggerated A...