General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsA Letter to Edward Snowden
A Letter to Edward Snowden
...
No matter whats written about him here in the mainstream, the spectacle of a single remarkably articulate and self-confident individual outwitting the last superpower has been, in its own way, uplifting. Although the first global polls havent come in, I think its safe to assume that from Bolivia to Hong Kong, Germany to Japan, Washington is taking a remarkable licking in the global opinion wars. Even at home, we know that, among the young in particular, opinion seems to be shifting on both Snowdens acts and the surveillance state whose architecture he revealed.
Given its utter tone-deafness and its flurry of threats against various foreign governments, the downing of Bolivian President Evo Moraless plane, and ever more ham-handed moves against Snowden himself, Washington is clearly building up a store of global anger and resentment, including over the way its scooping up private communications worldwide. In the end, this twenty-first-century spectacle may truly make a difference. As Rebecca Solnit, TomDispatch regular and author of the new book The Faraway Nearby, writes today, its been a moving show so far. One man against the machine: if youve ever been to the local multiplex, given such a scenario you cant for a second doubt where global sympathies lie. Tom
http://www.tomdispatch.com/post/175726/tomgram%3A_rebecca_solnit%2C_emerging_from_darkness%2C_the_edward_snowden_story/
Prometheus Among the Cannibals
A Letter to Edward Snowden
By Rebecca Solnit
Dear Edward Snowden,
...
Pity the country that requires a hero, Bertolt Brecht once remarked, but pity the heroes too. They are the other homeless, the people who dont fit in. They are the ones who see the hardest work and do it, and pay the price we charge those who do what we cant or wont. If the old stories were about heroes who saved us from others, modern heroes -- Nelson Mandela, Cesar Chavez, Rachel Carson, Ella Baker, Martin Luther King, Aung San Suu Kyi -- endeavored to save us from ourselves, from our own governments and systems of power.
The rest of us so often sacrifice that self and those ideals to fit in, to be part of a cannibal system, a system that eats souls and defiles truths and serves only power. Or we negotiate quietly to maintain an uneasy distance from it and then go about our own business. Though in my world quite a few of us strike our small blows against empire, you, young man, you were situated where you could run a dagger through the dragons eye, and that dragon is writhing in agony now; in that agony it has lost its magic: an arrangement whereby it remains invisible while making the rest of us ever more naked to its glaring eye.
Private Eyes and Public Rights
Privacy is a kind of power as well as a right, one that public librarians fought to protect against the Bush administration and the PATRIOT Act and that online companies violate in every way thats profitable and expedient. Our lack of privacy, their monstrous privacy -- even their invasion of our privacy must, by law, remain classified -- is what you made visible. The agony of a monster with nowhere to stand -- you are accused of spying on the spies, of invading the privacy of their invasion of privacy -- is a truly curious thing. And it is changing the world. Europe and South America are in an uproar, and attempts to contain you and your damage are putting out fire with gasoline.
...
You said, "I know the media likes to personalize political debates, and I know the government will demonize me." Who you are is fascinating, but what youve exposed is what matters. It is upending the world. It is damaging Washingtons relations with many Latin American and some European countries, with Russia and China as well as with its own people -- those, at least, who bother to read or listen to the news and care about what they find there. Edward Snowden Single-Handedly Forces Tech Companies To Come Forward With Government Data Request Stats, said a headline in Forbes. Your act is rearranging our world. How much no one yet knows.
...
Prometheus and Being Burned
I think of a man even younger than you, Edward Snowden, who unlike you acted without knowing what he did: 26-year-old Mohammed Bouazizi, whose December 2010 self-immolation to protest his humiliation and hopelessness triggered what became the still-blooming, still-burning Arab Spring. Sometimes one person changes the world. This should make most of us hopeful and some of them fearful, because what I am also saying is that we now live in a world of us and them, a binary world. Its not the old world of capitalism versus communism, but of the big versus the little, of oligarchy versus democracy, of hierarchies versus swarms, of corporations versus public interest and civil society.
...
Love,
Rebecca
Like Edward Snowden, Rebecca Solnit has a GED, not a high-school diploma. She lives in Silicon Valley's shadow, in a city where billionaires race $10 million yachts and austerity is closing the community college. Her newest book is The Faraway Nearby.
http://www.tomdispatch.com/post/175726/tomgram%3A_rebecca_solnit%2C_emerging_from_darkness%2C_the_edward_snowden_story/
grasswire
(50,130 posts)This is a writer I will savor. nt
Catherina
(35,568 posts)I had the same reaction. And another "high-school drop-out" too
Catherina
(35,568 posts)Published on Jul 18, 2013
http://www.democracynow.org - As Congress holds its second major public hearing on the National Security Agency's bulk spying, we speak with Glenn Greenwald, the Guardian journalist who first published whistleblower Edward Snowden's revelations. The NSA admitted their analysis of phone records and online behavior far exceeded what it had previously disclosed. "The fact that you now see members of both political parties increasingly angry over the fact that they were misled and lied to by top level Obama administration officials, that the laws that they enacted in the wake of 9/11 -- as broad as they were -- are being incredibly distorted by secret legal interpretations approved by secret courts, really indicates exactly that Snowden's motives to come forward with these revelations, at the expense of his liberty and even his life, were valid and compelling," Greenwald says. "If you think about whistleblowing in terms of people who expose things the government is hiding that they shouldn't be, in order to bring about reform, I think what you're seeing is the fruits of classic whistleblowing."
See our recent interviews with Glenn Greenwald about his NSA/Snowden reporting at
http://www.democracynow.org/appearances/glenn_greenwald
Democracy Now!, is an independent global news hour that airs weekdays on 1,100+ TV and radio stations Monday through Friday.
FOLLOW DEMOCRACY NOW! ONLINE:
Facebook: http://www.facebook.com/democracynow
Twitter: @democracynow
Subscribe on YouTube: http://www.youtube.com/democracynow
Listen on SoundCloud: http://www.soundcloud.com/democracynow
Daily Email News Digest: http://www.democracynow.org/subscribe
Please consider supporting independent media by making a donation to Democracy Now! today, visit http://www.democracynow.org/donate/YT
Waiting For Everyman
(9,385 posts)this may be the only way to confront its abuses. Why should we so easily accept that the very nature of security and privacy are completely different because of the ubiquitousness of technology, but yet still expect that whistleblowing should have to always remain as it traditionally was. Frankly that isn't logical.
Until the Surveillance State is cut way down to size, I don't think we can expect that whistleblowing can be what it used to be either. We should probably just get used to it this way, just like we're told to about everything else.
Edward Snowden thought outside the box and saw a perfect shot at the "Star Wars Death Star" and took it. Bravo!
The machine will always be vulnerable to fortuitously placed individuals who can and will do that, and the machine will always have to buy their creativity... because neither machines nor systematized people can do that kind of thinking. It is a built-in flaw of any machine, and it's little enough for us individuals to have on our side.
I don't need for Snowden to be a perfect person, to call what he did uplifting. Oh hell yes, it sure was. And he did it very well. If we all took the similar opportunities we have, in our own way, and in our own spots in life, this world might change a great deal. It doesn't necessarily even have to mean anything illegal, just being original in aid of the individual against the monolith.
Catherina
(35,568 posts)Waiting For Everyman
(9,385 posts)more a propos of the piece you posted. That is some of the best writing I've read in a long while. Just want to add... I thought this too, and agree with it 100%...
Don't know about about today, but that used to be called "centers of influence". And you are one of those, Catherina. So are quite a few others here, and that is a very valuable thing to be. I hope no DUers here believe anyone who says that spreading ideas (such as posting here) is a waste of time. That couldn't be more false.
Catherina
(35,568 posts)I try hard, which is why I refuse to get affected or distracted by attacks. Between DU and twitter, I learn more than anywhere else thanks to the hard work of many posters here. I know NSA already has a nice thick file on me, made 100% legal since I reside overseas now. I might as well make the best of it, especially with all the solidarity we have here. Thank you for being an important link in that solidarity and always speaking out.
I'm happy you appreciated that letter. I was very impressed with its quality and thoughtfulness. I hope Ed Snowden sees it soon, if he hasn't already.
Waiting For Everyman
(9,385 posts)have lived a long time on their radar screen, as you say, with deep files. In the old days, it used to be done by the Rand Corporation. But the truth is, the Surveillance State isn't nearly as clever as it likes us to believe. It has lots of money and toys, and that is formidable. But it isn't very bright. Case in point, grounding Morales' plane, or trying to boycott the Olympics.
It stands to reason that would be true because at the end of the day, what it's always trying to do -- a power trip -- is stupid.
AnotherDreamWeaver
(2,850 posts)But I see you already had. Thank you.
Catherina
(35,568 posts)Luminous Animal
(27,310 posts)sabrina 1
(62,325 posts)So true, those who admonish Snowden for not 'staying and facing the consequences of his actions' are living in the past.
As Drake pointed out this week at the National Press Club, he did it the old way, he tried to follow the rules, and they in return, tried to and nearly succeeded, in destroying HIM.
He spoke honestly to the FBI, trusting in the system he knew, THEY twisted his words and used them to base their false charges on.
As he said he spent 'five years in Hell' and offered his advice to future Whistle Blowers 'do not speak to the FBI, you cannot trust them'.
He stated that Snowden should be free. This is a man who spent forty years inside the system, in Intel and in the Military and trusted them. But he found out the hard way that he was living in the past. He advises others to adapt to the real world we now live in as Snowden did.
Cali_Democrat
(30,439 posts)morningfog
(18,115 posts)One "it" does not preclude or negate the discussion of another "it".
shawn703
(2,702 posts)If you criticize Snowden. You should know the rules by now.
Cleita
(75,480 posts)will have to read later.
markpkessinger
(8,401 posts). . . that appeared on TheNation.com, with a commenter who claimed to be supportive of what Snowden did, but suggested he was a "coward" for not returning to the U.S. to face charges.
Hero worship of Snowden like this is just nauseating. I think he did the right thing by leaking what he did, but that does not make him a hero. This letter is offensive to real heroes like Martin Luther King and Nelson Mandela, who were willing to go to prison for what they stood for, by comparing Edward Snowden to them. Hell, Martin Luther King gave his own life.
Snowden, though? Snowden has proved himself a coward. He's all too happy to be throwing rocks at the US government from his refuge in the police states of China and Russia, and letting the clown show of his fugitive hot potato game overshadow the issue he exposed. A real hero like MLK or Mandela would have let the government arrest him, let his trial be a rallying point, and have actually stood for something. A real hero wouldn't have fled to China and Russia and given over US secrets to them in exchange for sanctuary.
Yesterday 01:12 PM
Your ignorance of history is astounding. Nelson Mandela did not willingly submit to arrest. When Mandela was arrested, he had recently been in another part of Africa receiving military training. He sneaked back into South Africa to lead a band of saboteurs, having grown frustrated with the lack of positive results from the ANC's previous, peaceful efforts. On the day he was an associate, he and an associate were driving from Johannesburg to Durban, when a police car swerved in front of them, stopping the car. Mandela initially tried to pose as a chauffeur, using the alias David Motsamayi, but the police did not believe him. The only thing Mandela willingly did in all of this was choose not to use the revolver in the glove compartment of the car he was in (which probably would have been suicidal). None of this takes away from the greatness of the man, but the suggestion that he willingly submitted to arrest is pure fiction. The realization he came to, which your quote above references, came after he was arrested, not before.
And Martin Luther King, Jr. didn't give his life, it was taken from him by a murderer. Yes, he was willing to go to jail, but he wasn't facing the likelihood of spending most of the rest of his life in prison either.
Whether or not one believes Snowden is on par with the likes of King or Mandela, the U.S. government is seeking to make an example of him (indeed, much as they are doing with Bradley Manning). The suggestion that anybody who has -- as you concede Snowden has -- done the right thing should willingly submit to that is simply insane.
19 minutes ago
Catherina
(35,568 posts)The people who call Snowden a coward are the funniest ones. How come we never EVER see calls from them for all the criminal asylees we're harboring in this country to go home and face the music?
Ed Snowden will go down in history as a hero, unless we let them win this fight and rewrite history their way.
woo me with science
(32,139 posts)This is a piece worth sending on to everyone possible.
Thank you.