Any ranking list generates disagreement, but I've never understood the hype around Terrelle Pryor. I've watched him a few games and thought "he's okay, but nothing special". Maybe I've watched the wrong games.
Brantley of Florida and Newton of Auburn in the top 10 and they've never even started?
The one kid I do think will be impressive is Harris from Miami. Hate the Hurricanes but that kid will be special if he has a good work ethic.
http://www.collegefootballsaturday.com/?p=1809Rank Player Position Class Team
1 Ryan Mallett QB Jr. Arkansas
2 Terrelle Pryor QB Jr. Ohio State
3 Kellen Moore QB Jr. Boise State
4 Jake Locker QB Sr. Washington
5 Case Keenum QB Sr. Houston
6 Jacory Harris QB Jr. Miami (FL)
7 Robert Griffin QB So. Baylor
8 John Brantley QB Jr. Florida
9 Colin Kaepernick QB Sr. Nevada
10 Cameron Newton QB Jr. Auburn
11 Tyrod Taylor QB Sr. Virginia Tech
12 Landry Jones QB So. Oklahoma
13 Jerrod Johnson QB Sr. Texas A&M
14 Christian Ponder QB Sr. Florida State
15 Andrew Luck QB So. Stanford
16 Andy Dalton QB Sr. TCU
17 Zach Collaros QB Jr. Cincinnati
18 Matt Barkley QB So. USC
19 Russell Wilson QB Jr. N. C. State
20 Ricky Stanzi QB Sr. Iowa
21 Garrett Gilbert QB So. Texas
22 Greg McElroy QB Sr. Alabama
23 Scott Tolzien QB Jr. Wisconsin
24 Jordan Jefferson QB Jr. LSU
25 Taylor Potts QB Sr. Texas Tech
26 Tate Forcier QB So. Michigan
27 Nick Foles QB Jr. Arizona
28 Josh Nesbitt QB Jr. Georgia Tech
29 Kevin Riley QB Sr. California
30 Blaine Gabbert QB Jr. Missouri
31 Stephen Garcia QB Jr. South Carolina
32 Dwight Dasher QB Sr. Mid Tennessee St
33 Dayne Crist QB Jr. Notre Dame
34 Ricky Dobbs QB Sr. Navy
35 Robert Marve QB Jr. Purdue
36 Tom Savage QB So. Rutgers
37 Zac Lee QB Sr. Nebraska
38 Dave Shinskie QB So. Boston College
39 Aaron Murray QB Fr. Georgia
40 T. J. Yates QB Sr. North Carolina
41 Nate Costa QB Sr. Oregon
42 Nathan Enderle QB Sr. Idaho
43 B. J. Daniels QB So. South Florida
44 Kirk Cousins QB Jr. Michigan State
45 Ryan Colburn QB Sr. Fresno State
46 Brandon Weeden QB Jr. Oklahoma State
47 Ben Chappell QB Sr. Indiana
48 Geno Smith QB So. West Virginia
49 Kevin Newsome QB So. Penn State
50 G.J. Kinne QB Jr. Tulsa