My feeling is that a draft would galvanize the country against bushco's war mongering because then and only then would the public have something to lose. It would be like Vietnam. The tide would then turn against the Neo-Cons. Their children would have to serve too. what do you think? Would this stop UN-necessary wars?
...do you believe that Congress would blindly allow * to attack Iran, Syria, North Korea --- if there was even a chance that their constituents would have to go? I don't.
I do know that we have an army disproportionately comprised of minorities and poor (disadvantaged) people-----fighting for the advantaged. I'd like to see us get the hell out of there and never enter into an immoral "war" again! With * at the helm I don't trust that to happen on it's own.
29. How much innocent life are you willing to sacrifice...
> How much innocent life are *you* willing to sacrifice to "galvanize the people"?
How much innocent life are you willing to sacrifice while America blunders on, starving people, denying them clean water, blowing them to itty-bitty-pieces, denying them medication, education, and housing, and so on?
And I'm only talking about Americans; then we can talk about Iraqis next...
Any draft proposed by these neocon shitbags will never allow their own kids, or the kids of their rich contributors to pay the price. They didn't go the last time either. Hell, I'm surprised Poppy served in World War II, to be honest. Especially given their role in starting the thing.
I think we've got to find a better way to do it. It's bad enough to be sending those who signed up...well...sort of signed up...for something. When I was raising my son, one of the things that made me happiest was that he wasn't going to have to face a draft and he could make his own choices. I don't want to see that freedom disappear for young people, regardless of the benefits of a reality check. And no matter what the draft laws, the wealthy, powerful and connected will serve only to the extent they want to. That will never change.
I want this war over with so if they are drafted it is to defend this country...not attach others. I bet the war would end faster when everyones kids are in peril as opposed to now. The amount of protesters in the street would grow exponentially too.
14. But it sounds like you are still talking about "other people's kids"
Why don't YOU wake up. I hope you not only protest in the street, but write letters to the editor, call your senator, representative, join an activist group, walk the talk, drive a fuel efficient car (not an SUV), etc. etc. Start your kids' Conscientous Objector files today.
First: The neo-con propaganda machine would go to work to convince people that it is good, and right, and proper to send their kids off. And second: The children of the rich and influential would not have to go.
I'm more worried about waking up the throngs of non-rich average joe freeper bush voters who really believe that Bush is good for them yet haven't had to pay the piper yet. They most certainly will be suffering and feeling much pain- remember there are millions of them...
Rich White Christian Neo-Cons will always find a way around the draft for their children. A L W A Y S. Count on it.
The draft is meant for the un/under-educated, poor, people of color, or others, not the children of the Rich White Christian Neo-Con Elite. Their fathers, at least most of them, dodged the bullet figuratively in Vietnam, and their father before them did so in Korea.
All a draft does is provide convenient and expedient fodder for the Neo-Con wars. Trust me... that's ALL.
Galvanize the country? How many draftees would have to die before it is determined the country has been "Galvanized" enough? Now that's a noble cause worth dying for. Are the signs not clear enough already?
with round the clock news coverage and media outrage, and vengeful Bush soundbytes will reset 70 % of the populace back into unquestioned flag waving/let's kill the fuckers mode. The majority will embrace the draft if they see the effects of a nuclear explosion or something similiar. It's not hard to manipulate the masses, it's a time-honored science. Why do you all think they keep Bin Laden alive out there
And that is why they won't do it. They are smart enough to know not to start a draft. Instead they will use recruitment to get uninformed kids to join up. They control the press and media, so it is easy to keep the real truth from most people.
I find it difficult to believe that so many on this board would support the draft. I find it difficult to believe that some are so naive that the draft would be re-instated and that the rich will be subject to the law. There will always be an out for people with money. Perhaps they will have to serve. Perhaps they will have to serve in an office in DC or if they are really unlucky an office in the boonies but somewhere in the good ole US of A.
Meanwhile my son, who like his mother did not support this President or his evil war will be subject to serve a year or more in Iraq or Iran when the asshole decides to invade that.
So how kind of you to stand on the side of re-instating the draft to prove a political point. How kind of you to put other people's children, at risk so that you can prove something. It truly is noble of you to think that someone elses sacrifice of life and limb is acceptable as long as the rich repukes learn a lesson. I am sure with full control that the Republican party now enjoys the draft bill you dream of will come true.
Edited on Mon Mar-21-05 11:57 AM by Stand and Fight
However, I really am not so sure either way... I have found that I am becoming increasingly more pessimistic about the state of things in our country. It seems to me that Bush and the Republicans can get away with anything, and I am not COMPLETELY certain that even a draft would stop them. I am not COMPLETELY certain that even a draft would cause their constituents to rise up and call for an end to the madness, because they are in the grips of the very same malady. It is an interesting thought to ponder -- as those who recall my posts a month back -- but it will not likely happen because of the risks involved. However, the Neo-Conservatives have managed to continue to trample on the Constitution left and right and no one has really opposed them. The scenario that the two camps here may be ignoring is the fact that the American people may just be dumb enough to agree with a draft if the packaging is changed.
While I would agree that a draft would probably galvanize support against the war, the price is too high. US troops executing every man, woman and child in Iraq SUSPECTED of aiding the insurgents would also galvanize support against the war. Would anyone advocate that? I've seen a few threads in the past few days where I've found some of the opinions very disturbing, such as hoping for a draft or hoping for a recession or depression. I know that this isn't how most people feel, but I've started to see growing sentiments.
I, personally, want to get our people elected so that these things don't happen, rather than wanting these things to happen so we can get our people elected.
Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.1 Copyright 1997-2002 DCScripts.com
Software has been extensively modified by the DU administrators
Important Notices: By participating on this discussion
board, visitors agree to abide by the rules outlined on our Rules
page. Messages posted on the Democratic Underground Discussion Forums are the
opinions of the individuals who post them, and do not necessarily represent
the opinions of Democratic Underground, LLC.