Two editors - David Landau of Haaretz and Alan Rusbridger of the Guardian - strongly defended their newspapers in a session at Jewish book weekJewish Book Week culminated a week ago with a stormy session, in which Alan Rusbridger and David Landau took to the stage in front of a largely hostile crowd, several hundred-strong, to discuss reporting from the Middle East. Winning over an audience made up in the main of conservative Jews was never going to be easy for the editors of the Guardian and Haaretz, given the dubious reputations of both their papers in Anglo-Jewish circles.
Against a backdrop of renewed hostilities in Gaza, and outrage at the Guardian's handling of recent Israel-related stories, the two men were required to answer some serious criticism from the floor. Thanks to his position as kipa-wearing Israeli Jew and leftwing newspaper editor, David Landau was able to act as middleman between the audience and Alan Rusbridger, and he stood his ground firmly when making his defence.
He launched an impassioned tirade against the "misguided" Diaspora Zionists who "invest an inordinate amount of time bashing the Guardian, the BBC, and others, rather than helping Israel solve its existential dilemma". He castigated the "pro-Israel community
" for its "nascent McCarthyism" when it comes to their witchhunt against media outlets and individual journalists, describing their actions as both "dangerous and anti-democratic".
Instead of spending so much effort demonising those reporting the conflict, he said, true supporters of Israel ought to be trying to cure the cause of the problems in the region, not wasting time focusing on the symptoms, such as how the papers report on the troubles. Ignoring the hecklers, he ploughed on with his message, citing his own moral journey as reason for others to face up to reality, rather than burying their heads in the sand and claiming that the world is irredeemably biased against Israel.
He spoke of his initial outrage when he read Chris McGreal's infamous piece comparing Israel to apartheid South Africa. On re-reading the article recently, he found that his outrage had all but disappeared. "Now I think he does have a point," Landau explained to a hushed room. "Israel is heading towards a South Africa style dilemma."
He then pointed out that the Israeli press was full of stridently critical articles towards the incumbent government, and exposés of their crimes, yet their publication caused barely a ripple among diaspora Jews. However, when organisations like the BBC or the Guardian reported exactly the same stories, suddenly the gloves were off and everyone was up in arms. "But it doesn't register with them that they can see the same thing on Israeli TV, since they are obsessed with Guardian-bashing ," he said.
http://commentisfree.guardian.co.uk/seth_freedman/2008/03/jewish_book_week.html
Printer-friendly format
Email this thread to a friend
Bookmark this thread
(1000+ posts)
Send PM |
Profile |
Ignore
