Nip/Tuck Who's The Carver Poll

[Liberalynn]

Poll question: Nip/Tuck Who's The Carver Poll

So next week is the big reveal. Who are you betting on and why?

[Liberalynn]

1. My case for Kimber

With all of us thinking she is being tortured by the Carver, we certainly wouldn't suspect that she might actually be the carver.

This theory has been going around on the E-Entertainment Watch With Kristin message boards among some of the posters and in other sites that talk about Nip/Tuck and I think it has merit.

Things people have pointed out, there was no blood on the "Dear John" letter the Carver "made" her write to Christian even though she appeared to be bleeding pretty bad.

She wacked out and tried to cut him once before.

She didn't want to give up her "career" but he made that a condition of the marriage.

More and More Christian has become the target.

It could also be Kimber has an accomplice in Merril. Christian hurt both of them and they could be plotting to pay him back.

The scenes of her "with" the Carver could be her in a drug induced haze, as she was a cocaine user before. So she could still be doing that and other drugs.

[Liberalynn]

2. Thanks

for the vote on Quentin.

He was pretty suspicious this season. I think he might end up a victim from the look of the previews but then again they might be trying to throw us off.

[Mojambo]

3. Quentin almost feels too obvious to me, but that's my vote.

Matt's a definite dark horse though.

This has been a great season.

[Liberalynn]

11. Matt

is in the running for me too. He's definitely been more bizzare than ever this season.

It sure has been a great season. I hate to see it end. Also too, I am so ticked they didn't get any Golden Globes nods this year. Julian especially got ripped. He's been acting his big heart out. Especially the stuff with Christian's mother, then thinking he got dumped at his wedding.

[Liberalynn]

19. It has definitely been a lot darker this season

Sometimes you wonder how they are going to top themselves next season.

They've all gone through and caused a lot of trauma this season that's for sure.

[leftofthedial]

14. it's definitely continued a trend toward much darker plot lines

and character development

[Yavin4]

4. I Vote Liz

The key evidence is Christian's seeman at the murder scene. How did the Carver get access to that? Liz had samples of his seeman because they were trying to conceive a child.

[Yavin4]

5. Did You Catch The Carver's Profile?

on myspace\thecarver.com? His favorite show? The World According to Jim. Hysterical.

[Liberalynn]

8. That site

is wild, eerie, and yest hysterical.

Kristin of E online asked if Nip/Tuck fans had read "She's Come Undone" by Wally Lamb and I notice that the Carver lists Wally Lamb as one of his favorite authors.

I haven't read the book but others say it could link to either that Kimber is the carver, or what the Carver is doing to Kimber.

[Liberalynn]

12. Liz is a definite suspect

On the seemen thing I was wondering whether it could have been Kit, Kimber, or Quentin. The night of the quartet, hee-hee, one of them could have stolen one of Christian's used condoms. YICKKKKKKKKKKKK. Maybe Kit stole it and then planted it in the murder victim's apartment as an excuse to arrest Christian because she believed he was the Carver, but she didn't have the evidence to back up her theory.

I like Roma Maffia though. I think she and Julian Mcmahon are so funny together. They immediately re-started their on-screen chemistry from their Profiler days. So I hope she isn't the guilty one.

[YellowRubberDuckie]

16. Well, she's the obvious choice, so it can't be her.

It could be Gina...and if it's not a female, then it could be Matt.
Duckie

[leftofthedial]

15. umm, about half the population of Miami

has samples of Christian's semen.

[Liberalynn]

20. True

He sure gets around. :rofl:

[liontamer]

17. i don't think the carver did that

remember the carver was upset that christian got credit. why frame someone and then be upset that your plan worked?

[Liberalynn]

21. This is true

I don't think Kit is the carver, but I think she was so convinced that Christian was guilty she tried to plant evidence to use against him.

[Blaukraut]

6. Kimber

Because I want her to be. I can't stand that stupid cow. Beyond that, though, it could be anyone of them, really. :shrug:

[Liberalynn]

10. I've wondered

if Kimber and Kit may be working together? Kit seemed more attracted to Kimber than she did to Christian, even though she claimed she was only doing undercover, ahem, work.

I personally prefer Christian myself but to each his or her own. :toast:

[msanthrope]

7. It's Merrill Bobbalit. Bet on it. n/t

[Liberalynn]

9. I think

Merrill is going to figue in there somehow. Either as the carver or a carver accomplice.

[Liberalynn]

13. Just wanted to remind other Nip/Tuckers

that the finale is going to be two hours long. In case your recording.

[Liberalynn]

18. Just got a clue from

Kristin V on E online.com chat transcript.

Any one have any ideas what "Jay Z" might be hinting at?

Tomorrow night should be interesting.