War Called Riskier Than Vietnam

[cal04]

Military Experts Fretful Over Long-Term Consequences
By Thomas E. Ricks

President Bush recently said that "there's a lot of differences" between the current war in Iraq and the Vietnam War.

As fighting in Iraq enters its fifth year, an increasing number of experts in foreign policy and national strategy are arguing that the biggest difference may be that the Iraq war will inflict greater damage to U.S. interests than Vietnam did.

"In terms of the consequences of failure, the stakes are much bigger than Vietnam," said former defense secretary William S. Cohen. "The geopolitical consequences are . . . potentially global in scope."

About 17 times as many U.S. troops died in the Vietnam War -- the longest war in U.S. history -- as have been lost in Iraq, the nation's third-longest war. Also, despite widespread public dissatisfaction with the Iraq war, the debate over it has not convulsed American society to the extent seen during the Vietnam conflict. However, Vietnam does not have oil and is not in the middle of a region crucial to the global economy and festering with terrorism, experts say, leading many of them to conclude that the long-term effects of the Iraq war will be worse for the United States.

"It makes Vietnam look like a cakewalk," said retired Air Force Gen. Charles F. Wald, a veteran of the Vietnam War. The domino theory that nations across Southeast Asia would go communist was not fulfilled, he noted, but with Iraq, "worst-case scenarios are the most likely thing to happen."

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/04/28/AR2007042801167.html

[Monkeyman]

1. What Would Bush know about Vietnam he cut and ran while I bled

:grr:

[1620rock]

3. yeah, he got daddy to pull strings to get him into the Texas ANG...

...and then skipped out on that...the chicken-shit bastard.

[ngant17]

2. If this was Vietnam and the year was 2007

these idiots would be saying the same thing. Anything to get the public to support a hopeless and lost cause.

The sooner the withdrawal, the less KIAs and civilian 'collateral damage'. It's a win-win situation for everyone but the Pentagon and the military-industrial complex like Halliburton and KBR.

Whatever happens in Iraq after the pull-out, that's going to be part of the mess we are already in. IMHO worst case scenario will be something like North Korea but speaking Arabic. Can't do anything about North Korea so why worry about it.

[bemildred]

4. Well, he's right, but staying is still stupid.

Just because it is bad doesn't mean you can fix it.