Reply #100: I've been amused

[fujiyama]

by some of the anti immigration folks here, not because they advocate strengthening border security, but because they view this as a simple problem and many resort to hyperboles and hystrionics.

"Just send 'em back" isn't a solution and if you advocate that, you should not be taken seriously because you have little understanding of how complex the problem is. This is not the party of Tom Tancredo. If you support him, there is another forum.

We have millions of people here undocumented and yes, border security is a problem. A country can't function with completely open borders because resources are stretched and preference must go to those that stay here legally.

However, It would not be practical or morally right to deport anyone that doesn't have "proper papers". Many at this point do have children, who were born here - and are American citizens. You technically can't say the kid broke the law just for being born here. If you want children of illegal immigrants to not be citizens, then you amend the constitution.

The only practical thing is to set up SOME sort of amnesty program. If a person has stayed in the US for a certain number of years with a clean record, then a case can be made to let that person apply for permanent legal residency. Preference should be given to those with children though for obvious reasons.

We should deport some illegal immigrants undoubtably - anyone involved in criminal activity that has illegally entered should obviously be immediately deported.

Also, I would strengthen border security, with a much larger number of agents stationed at the border - we don't need the military at the border, because we are not at war. But we need better law enforcement for sure.

Eventually enact a policy that will no longer allow illegal immigrants to apply for permanent residency - and will entitle them for deportation.

Finally, crack down on all employers. This is the most important thing. If illegal immigrants can't find work here, they will not come. More labor oversight is vital.

Increase legal immigration quotas to realistic levels - allow those workers with special skills in demand to immigrate, regardless of the nation.