Reply #55: This thread is a perfect example of why non-engineers / physicists / etc. are not...

[Realityhack]

normally included in technical discussions. The posters criticizing Bazant don't even understand the purpose of the paper. They do not understand it much less are equipped to analyze it on a technical level.

It honestly is exactly like watching creationists try to talk about DNA when they don't even know the difference between a gene and a genome. In both cases the 'critics' are simply not equipped to even enter the discussion never mind make any meaningful contribution to it.