Reply #154: You're sounding desperate

[procopia]

Especially when you disparage the competence of someone with Griscom's resume. I'm aware Griscom has been ridiculed for his survivor theory, but all 9/11 theories have been ridiculed, and none sound more absurd than the OCT.

Bentham does not allow authors to select their own peer reviewers, the editors do. As in other journals, authors may recommend reviewers, but editors choose at least some reviewers not recommended by the authors. The reviewers remain anonymous.

"when I pointed you to very specific logic errors and shortcomings that you can examine for yourself? Did you even attempt to see if I was correct?"

If the errors are as obvious as you say, why don't you submit a rebuttal paper to a scientific journal? It's the only way your criticism is meaningful. Until then, I will rely on the opinion of those who have been published (and cited)--many, many, many times.