In the discussion thread: New poll finds overwhelming support for an annual wealth tax [View all]
Response to Demsrule86 (Reply #19)
Fri Nov 8, 2019, 10:51 PM
Buzz cook (1,958 posts)
22. A wealth tax apportioned by class
Just as the progressive income tax is apportioned by class.
Just as a gas tax is paid only by those who only use gasoline and a tax on carriages is only paid by those with carriages. https://www.americanbar.org/groups/taxation/publications/abataxtimes_home/19aug/19aug-pp-johnson-a-wealth-tax-is-constitutional/ The Constitution, Article I, section 9, clause 4, requires that a “direct tax” must be apportioned among the states by population.3 For the Founders, a necessary element to be a direct tax is that apportionment among the states by population must be reasonable and just. Thus import taxes (the impost), excise taxes, duties, carriage taxes and now real estate and wealth taxes have been expelled from the definition of direct tax, sometimes by the operation of ordinary language and sometimes by Supreme Court decision. snip Hamilton put it quite clearly. ![]() primary today, I would vote for: Elizabeth Warren |
Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum
Replies to this discussion thread
![]() |
Author | Time | Post |
Hassin Bin Sober | Nov 8 | OP | |
guillaumeb | Nov 8 | #1 | |
CentralMass | Nov 8 | #3 | |
guillaumeb | Nov 8 | #4 | |
Red Oak | Nov 8 | #2 | |
Demsrule86 | Nov 8 | #12 | |
Buzz cook | Nov 8 | #14 | |
Demsrule86 | Nov 8 | #19 | |
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Buzz cook | Nov 8 | #22 |
Uncle Joe | Nov 8 | #5 | |
world wide wally | Nov 8 | #6 | |
BeyondGeography | Nov 8 | #7 | |
redqueen | Nov 8 | #8 | |
Buzz cook | Nov 8 | #16 | |
Hoyt | Nov 8 | #9 | |
tirebiter | Nov 8 | #10 | |
Hassin Bin Sober | Nov 8 | #13 | |
tirebiter | Nov 8 | #15 | |
Buzz cook | Nov 8 | #17 | |
tirebiter | Nov 8 | #20 | |
Buzz cook | Nov 8 | #21 | |
colsohlibgal | Nov 8 | #11 | |
Gothmog | Nov 8 | #18 | |
tirebiter | Nov 9 | #23 |
Edit History
Please login to view edit histories.