In the discussion thread: The Root: Pipe Down, Bernie Sanders [View all]
Response to Orsino (Reply #274)
Wed Jan 18, 2017, 04:40 PM
Gothmog (93,749 posts)
276. I like the real world and for me Sanders' platform was not realistic and was based on a "revolution"
I live in a deep red state and so I am faced with the real world on a daily basis. A number of Sanders proposals sounded great but they were not realistic in the real world. Sanders based his unrealistic proposals on a mythical voter revolution where millions/billions/trillions of new voters would magically appear and somehow forced the GOP to be reasonable. That revolution exists only in a fantasy world and has not been evident in the real world http://www.usnews.com/opinion/blogs/robert-schlesinger/articles/2016-04-15/bernie-sanders-bad-delegate-math-and-fantasy-revolution
He went on to argue that he's going to win because he'll pile up votes now that the contest has moved out of the Deep South. This is a shorthand version of an argument that Sanders and his allies have been deploying recently in an attempt to downplay Clinton's lead in pledged delegates – "having so many Southern states go first kind of distorts reality" he told Larry Wilmore, host of "The Nightly Show," earlier this week.
There's a lot wrong with this formulation, as Paul Krugman wrote in The New York Times this morning. It suggests a world view redolent of former half-term Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin's toxic pandering to "real America." In Sanders' case, he's saying that red-state Democrats should be discounted because they're too conservative. But that's simply wrong, Krugman notes: Clinton isn't "riding a wave of support from old-fashioned Confederate-flag-waving Dixiecrats," she ran up the score by scoring lopsided victories among black voters ("let's be blunt, the descendants of slaves," he writes). And the fact that the Deep South is conservative should be irrelevant, given that Sanders argues the principle obstacle to his super progressive agenda is campaign finance corruption rather than, say, ideology. Either he's leading a national movement, as he claims, or he's not. Thus more broadly, his attempt to delegitimize a swath of voters lays bare a fundamental inconsistency of the Sanders campaign: One of his basic answers about how he's going to accomplish his aims – whether winning the Democratic nod, winning the general election or enacting his agenda – is the forthcoming revolution. His super-ambitious agenda will prove to be achievable substance rather than unicorns-and-rainbows fantasy, he said Thursday night, "when millions of people stand up, fight back and create a government that works for all of us, not just the 1 percent. That is what the political revolution is about. That is what this campaign is about." And that's fine: If he can summon the revolution, then more power to him, literally and figuratively. But the Sanders revolution is breaking on the hard realities of math. The revolution will not be televised, the old song goes; but it can be fantasized – and it can be measured, in votes and delegates. And in every calculable respect, it's coming up short. That leaves Sanders to bank on an anti-democratic sleight of hand to secure the nomination. That's not a broad-based revolution; that's a palace coup. You are welcomed to support Sanders but some of us have to live in the real world. Sanders platform turned me off in that it was based on a revolution that was unlikely at best. Clearly the millions/billions/trillions of new voters that sanders promised never showed which is why he lost so badly in the primary. It is hard to take Sanders positions seriously when such positions all require a political revolution that has not materialized and will not materialize. |
Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum
Replies to this discussion thread
![]() |
Author | Time | Post |
bravenak | Jan 2017 | OP | |
tecelote | Jan 2017 | #1 | |
bravenak | Jan 2017 | #3 | |
tecelote | Jan 2017 | #4 | |
bravenak | Jan 2017 | #11 | |
LisaM | Jan 2017 | #16 | |
bravenak | Jan 2017 | #29 | |
LisaM | Jan 2017 | #36 | |
radical noodle | Jan 2017 | #58 | |
BlueCaliDem | Jan 2017 | #102 | |
brush | Jan 2017 | #152 | |
JTFrog | Jan 2017 | #92 | |
redstatebluegirl | Jan 2017 | #242 | |
bravenak | Jan 2017 | #243 | |
liquid diamond | Jan 2017 | #84 | |
womanofthehills | Jan 2017 | #281 | |
otohara | Jan 2017 | #86 | |
lunamagica | Jan 2017 | #105 | |
MrPurple | Jan 2017 | #106 | |
jonno99 | Jan 2017 | #275 | |
KPN | Jan 2017 | #204 | |
R B Garr | Jan 2017 | #278 | |
tecelote | Jan 2017 | #17 | |
bravenak | Jan 2017 | #24 | |
tecelote | Jan 2017 | #32 | |
bravenak | Jan 2017 | #34 | |
tecelote | Jan 2017 | #35 | |
George II | Jan 2017 | #66 | |
Eliot Rosewater | Jan 2017 | #76 | |
Gothmog | Jan 2017 | #101 | |
bravenak | Jan 2017 | #173 | |
George II | Jan 2017 | #175 | |
sheshe2 | Jan 2017 | #177 | |
mcar | Jan 2017 | #225 | |
sheshe2 | Jan 2017 | #228 | |
mcar | Jan 2017 | #229 | |
KPN | Jan 2017 | #206 | |
George II | Jan 2017 | #212 | |
KPN | Jan 2017 | #216 | |
George II | Jan 2017 | #218 | |
KPN | Jan 2017 | #219 | |
George II | Jan 2017 | #226 | |
Gothmog | Jan 2017 | #236 | |
Gothmog | Jan 2017 | #235 | |
Exilednight | Jan 2017 | #199 | |
KPN | Jan 2017 | #207 | |
aikoaiko | Jan 2017 | #73 | |
bravenak | Jan 2017 | #163 | |
WhiteTara | Jan 2017 | #85 | |
MadCrow | Jan 2017 | #143 | |
WhiteTara | Jan 2017 | #151 | |
k8conant | Jan 2017 | #182 | |
sheshe2 | Jan 2017 | #183 | |
KPN | Jan 2017 | #213 | |
bravenak | Jan 2017 | #247 | |
LenaBaby61 | Jan 2017 | #187 | |
KPN | Jan 2017 | #208 | |
WhiteTara | Jan 2017 | #210 | |
NWCorona | Jan 2017 | #88 | |
bravenak | Jan 2017 | #156 | |
NWCorona | Jan 2017 | #157 | |
Cha | Jan 2017 | #142 | |
Gothmog | Jan 2017 | #93 | |
sheshe2 | Jan 2017 | #158 | |
bravenak | Jan 2017 | #174 | |
sheshe2 | Jan 2017 | #178 | |
LanternWaste | Jan 2017 | #223 | |
kacekwl | Jan 2017 | #8 | |
bravenak | Jan 2017 | #12 | |
KPN | Jan 2017 | #211 | |
Uponthegears | Jan 2017 | #20 | |
bravenak | Jan 2017 | #26 | |
Uponthegears | Jan 2017 | #39 | |
Eliot Rosewater | Jan 2017 | #81 | |
krawhitham | Jan 2017 | #68 | |
bettyellen | Jan 2017 | #145 | |
KPN | Jan 2017 | #209 | |
secondwind | Jan 2017 | #126 | |
RBInMaine | Jan 2017 | #285 | |
bravenak | Jan 2017 | #286 | |
EffieBlack | Jan 2017 | #15 | |
tecelote | Jan 2017 | #19 | |
bravenak | Jan 2017 | #30 | |
tecelote | Jan 2017 | #33 | |
bravenak | Jan 2017 | #37 | |
tecelote | Jan 2017 | #40 | |
bravenak | Jan 2017 | #41 | |
tecelote | Jan 2017 | #46 | |
bravenak | Jan 2017 | #49 | |
KPN | Jan 2017 | #215 | |
bravenak | Jan 2017 | #244 | |
forjusticethunders | Jan 2017 | #273 | |
bravenak | Jan 2017 | #277 | |
EffieBlack | Jan 2017 | #71 | |
Gothmog | Jan 2017 | #94 | |
brush | Jan 2017 | #153 | |
LisaM | Jan 2017 | #21 | |
randome | Jan 2017 | #18 | |
tecelote | Jan 2017 | #22 | |
randome | Jan 2017 | #25 | |
tecelote | Jan 2017 | #28 | |
betsuni | Jan 2017 | #42 | |
tecelote | Jan 2017 | #48 | |
betsuni | Jan 2017 | #59 | |
mcar | Jan 2017 | #118 | |
randome | Jan 2017 | #44 | |
tecelote | Jan 2017 | #51 | |
randome | Jan 2017 | #54 | |
tecelote | Jan 2017 | #57 | |
randome | Jan 2017 | #61 | |
tecelote | Jan 2017 | #65 | |
randome | Jan 2017 | #67 | |
Gothmog | Jan 2017 | #98 | |
kacekwl | Jan 2017 | #139 | |
kacekwl | Jan 2017 | #141 | |
RazBerryBeret | Jan 2017 | #133 | |
randome | Jan 2017 | #202 | |
RazBerryBeret | Jan 2017 | #237 | |
Gothmog | Jan 2017 | #250 | |
womanofthehills | Jan 2017 | #282 | |
LisaM | Jan 2017 | #60 | |
tecelote | Jan 2017 | #64 | |
SMC22307 | Jan 2017 | #260 | |
LisaM | Jan 2017 | #268 | |
SMC22307 | Jan 2017 | #271 | |
brush | Jan 2017 | #154 | |
Orsino | Jan 2017 | #274 | |
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Gothmog | Jan 2017 | #276 |
George II | Jan 2017 | #63 | |
Gothmog | Jan 2017 | #96 | |
Gothmog | Jan 2017 | #91 | |
GreenPartyVoter | Jan 2017 | #122 | |
putitinD | Jan 2017 | #252 | |
melman | Jan 2017 | #2 | |
betsuni | Jan 2017 | #5 | |
Cha | Jan 2017 | #7 | |
bravenak | Jan 2017 | #9 | |
betsuni | Jan 2017 | #43 | |
bravenak | Jan 2017 | #45 | |
SidDithers | Jan 2017 | #80 | |
Uponthegears | Jan 2017 | #6 | |
bravenak | Jan 2017 | #10 | |
Uponthegears | Jan 2017 | #23 | |
Gothmog | Jan 2017 | #97 | |
Uponthegears | Jan 2017 | #114 | |
Gothmog | Jan 2017 | #131 | |
tonedevil | Jan 2017 | #147 | |
Uponthegears | Jan 2017 | #160 | |
Gothmog | Jan 2017 | #191 | |
yardwork | Jan 2017 | #195 | |
Uponthegears | Jan 2017 | #197 | |
Gothmog | Jan 2017 | #220 | |
yardwork | Jan 2017 | #194 | |
Uponthegears | Jan 2017 | #198 | |
yardwork | Jan 2017 | #224 | |
Uponthegears | Jan 2017 | #238 | |
bravenak | Jan 2017 | #245 | |
Uponthegears | Jan 2017 | #267 | |
Gothmog | Jan 2017 | #222 | |
Uponthegears | Jan 2017 | #161 | |
Gothmog | Jan 2017 | #189 | |
seaglass | Jan 2017 | #13 | |
bravenak | Jan 2017 | #14 | |
UCmeNdc | Jan 2017 | #31 | |
bravenak | Jan 2017 | #38 | |
George II | Jan 2017 | #72 | |
Quayblue | Jan 2017 | #112 | |
Chasstev365 | Jan 2017 | #27 | |
Buckeye_Democrat | Jan 2017 | #47 | |
bravenak | Jan 2017 | #50 | |
Gothmog | Jan 2017 | #100 | |
Red Oak | Jan 2017 | #52 | |
bravenak | Jan 2017 | #53 | |
JHan | Jan 2017 | #55 | |
bravenak | Jan 2017 | #56 | |
JCanete | Jan 2017 | #230 | |
JHan | Jan 2017 | #231 | |
JCanete | Jan 2017 | #232 | |
JHan | Jan 2017 | #233 | |
JCanete | Jan 2017 | #234 | |
JHan | Jan 2017 | #239 | |
George II | Jan 2017 | #62 | |
baldguy | Jan 2017 | #70 | |
baldguy | Jan 2017 | #69 | |
Post removed | Jan 2017 | #74 | |
JHan | Jan 2017 | #77 | |
Buckeye_Democrat | Jan 2017 | #78 | |
Talk Is Cheap | Jan 2017 | #75 | |
liquid diamond | Jan 2017 | #87 | |
Talk Is Cheap | Jan 2017 | #89 | |
liquid diamond | Jan 2017 | #146 | |
Gothmog | Jan 2017 | #99 | |
immoderate | Jan 2017 | #107 | |
Gothmog | Jan 2017 | #134 | |
Talk Is Cheap | Jan 2017 | #110 | |
JHan | Jan 2017 | #115 | |
Talk Is Cheap | Jan 2017 | #119 | |
JHan | Jan 2017 | #121 | |
Gothmog | Jan 2017 | #125 | |
Talk Is Cheap | Jan 2017 | #128 | |
Gothmog | Jan 2017 | #132 | |
Talk Is Cheap | Jan 2017 | #138 | |
R B Garr | Jan 2017 | #192 | |
Talk Is Cheap | Jan 2017 | #201 | |
R B Garr | Jan 2017 | #203 | |
R B Garr | Jan 2017 | #193 | |
guillaumeb | Jan 2017 | #79 | |
SidDithers | Jan 2017 | #82 | |
NobodyHere | Jan 2017 | #83 | |
Gothmog | Jan 2017 | #95 | |
Gothmog | Jan 2017 | #90 | |
HassleCat | Jan 2017 | #103 | |
baldguy | Jan 2017 | #120 | |
HassleCat | Jan 2017 | #149 | |
Post removed | Jan 2017 | #155 | |
HassleCat | Jan 2017 | #159 | |
baldguy | Jan 2017 | #162 | |
HassleCat | Jan 2017 | #164 | |
baldguy | Jan 2017 | #165 | |
HassleCat | Jan 2017 | #166 | |
m-lekktor | Jan 2017 | #127 | |
HassleCat | Jan 2017 | #150 | |
50 Shades Of Blue | Jan 2017 | #104 | |
Post removed | Jan 2017 | #108 | |
JHan | Jan 2017 | #111 | |
Post removed | Jan 2017 | #109 | |
hollowdweller | Jan 2017 | #113 | |
Garrett78 | Jan 2017 | #116 | |
mcar | Jan 2017 | #117 | |
BlueMTexpat | Jan 2017 | #123 | |
LenaBaby61 | Jan 2017 | #148 | |
BlueMTexpat | Jan 2017 | #181 | |
alittlelark | Jan 2017 | #124 | |
treestar | Jan 2017 | #129 | |
bravenak | Jan 2017 | #172 | |
democratisphere | Jan 2017 | #130 | |
Gothmog | Jan 2017 | #135 | |
JCanete | Jan 2017 | #137 | |
democratisphere | Jan 2017 | #140 | |
JCanete | Jan 2017 | #144 | |
JCanete | Jan 2017 | #136 | |
Vermijelli | Jan 2017 | #167 | |
bravenak | Jan 2017 | #171 | |
Vermijelli | Jan 2017 | #185 | |
bravenak | Jan 2017 | #186 | |
R B Garr | Jan 2017 | #168 | |
bravenak | Jan 2017 | #170 | |
R B Garr | Jan 2017 | #188 | |
melman | Jan 2017 | #190 | |
ismnotwasm | Jan 2017 | #169 | |
Post removed | Jan 2017 | #176 | |
bravenak | Jan 2017 | #179 | |
Arazi | Jan 2017 | #180 | |
bravenak | Jan 2017 | #184 | |
HRC2020 | Jan 2017 | #196 | |
Chitown Kev | Jan 2017 | #200 | |
LexVegas | Jan 2017 | #205 | |
bravenak | Jan 2017 | #240 | |
yardwork | Jan 2017 | #241 | |
hueymahl | Jan 2017 | #214 | |
SMC22307 | Jan 2017 | #221 | |
R B Garr | Jan 2017 | #256 | |
SMC22307 | Jan 2017 | #259 | |
R B Garr | Jan 2017 | #264 | |
SMC22307 | Jan 2017 | #270 | |
R B Garr | Jan 2017 | #272 | |
SMC22307 | Jan 2017 | #279 | |
R B Garr | Jan 2017 | #280 | |
bravenak | Jan 2017 | #246 | |
Gothmog | Jan 2017 | #248 | |
bravenak | Jan 2017 | #249 | |
Gothmog | Jan 2017 | #251 | |
bravenak | Jan 2017 | #253 | |
R B Garr | Jan 2017 | #257 | |
Gothmog | Jan 2017 | #258 | |
hueymahl | Jan 2017 | #265 | |
bravenak | Jan 2017 | #266 | |
hueymahl | Jan 2017 | #269 | |
SMC22307 | Jan 2017 | #217 | |
Gothmog | Jan 2017 | #283 | |
bettyellen | Jan 2017 | #284 | |
sheshe2 | Jan 2017 | #227 | |
Larkspur | Jan 2017 | #254 | |
bravenak | Jan 2017 | #255 | |
Larkspur | Jan 2017 | #261 | |
bravenak | Jan 2017 | #263 | |
Larkspur | Jan 2017 | #287 | |
bravenak | Jan 2017 | #288 | |
Blue_Tires | Jan 2017 | #262 |
Edit History
Please login to view edit histories.