Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
Religion
In reply to the discussion: Militant atheism has become a religion [View all]Phillip McCleod
(1,837 posts)198. When? Every time. 1995, the New Age movement.
Nothing makes progressives look more ridiculous than our religious revivals.
THAT'S what's wrong with Kumbaya. It's cacophony.
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
292 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
This seems a good time to point out that was marions ghost's 1st post in this thread
muriel_volestrangler
Mar 2013
#32
"We all know that organized religion's achilles heel is what SOME of its practitioners get up to"
AlbertCat
Apr 2013
#71
Personally, I think people are referring to emergent properties of physical things, when they use
patrice
Apr 2013
#248
When it comes to personal religious beliefs, those who feel the need to convert others are insecure.
Starboard Tack
Mar 2013
#63
Reality is that not everyone shares your world view. Deal with it, Albert.
Starboard Tack
Apr 2013
#88
I'm not trying to disprove objectivity, only it's relevance to the perception of reality.
Starboard Tack
Apr 2013
#116
"Reality is merely an illusion, albeit a very persistent one." - Albert Einstein
patrice
Apr 2013
#234
No, not really--the Interfaith SOP doesn't marry well with topics that involve challenges to belief
MADem
Apr 2013
#105
It's not a "play nice" group, it's a "generally agree with me or leave" group.
cleanhippie
Apr 2013
#109
I made fun of no one. When ideas are not open to scrutiny and criticism and left to stand or fall
cleanhippie
Apr 2013
#111
You don't have any clue as to my beliefs or lack thereof. I've made it a point to not share
MADem
Apr 2013
#138
Blah blah blah. You wanted an "agree with me or leave" group and you got it. Enjoy.
cleanhippie
Apr 2013
#140
Thanks SO much for your demonstration of incivility! You are working SO hard to prove my point!
MADem
Apr 2013
#141
Thanks SO much for demonstrating that you are unable to see past your own prejudices.
cleanhippie
Apr 2013
#143
I told you--I don't think you'll find that here. It's not an issue. If it becomes one,
MADem
Apr 2013
#142
So, since you're determined to dodge my questions and project upon me for asking simple questions,
deucemagnet
Apr 2013
#172
No. We simply don't tolerate rudeness and name-calling in the group. You get your drama on here.
MADem
Apr 2013
#173
I answered it from the git-go, you just didn't like the answer and pretended to not understand.
MADem
Apr 2013
#176
It's not ironic, it's fucking hypocritical. Shows the true "agree with me or leave" nature
cleanhippie
Apr 2013
#188
Which is worse, calling creationism absurd or calling people who believe creationism dumbasses?
cleanhippie
Apr 2013
#186
I don't really care--you can call anyone whatever you want, you just aren't going to do it in a
MADem
Apr 2013
#189
Exactly. You don't care if one of your own does it, just those you hate, like me.
cleanhippie
Apr 2013
#206
Sounds to me like you're choking on a fishbone, with all this snark and phony ROFL-ing.
MADem
Apr 2013
#212
Enjoy your "agree with me or leave group." And continue to have a nice day.
cleanhippie
Apr 2013
#216
Atheists have used things like guns and bombs to enforce their ideas
Fortinbras Armstrong
Mar 2013
#21
The two examples that I gave were of atheists who enforced atheism BY FORCE
Fortinbras Armstrong
Mar 2013
#46
Ok, change it to Stalin and Hoxha tried really, really hard to force atheism on their peoples.
Fortinbras Armstrong
Apr 2013
#132
We're "arseholes"? That's rich, coming from a bigoted moron. Fuck off back to church,
mr blur
Apr 2013
#222
There are no moderators. There are hosts who can block the poster if they all agree.
MADem
Apr 2013
#249
Hold the ad-hominems if you want anyone to take your arguments seriously. n/t
backscatter712
Apr 2013
#250
Not much use to deny Stalin took extreme measures. After he ended his stay in seminary for politics
dimbear
Mar 2013
#61
Did these figures from history act because they believed in atheism or because they despised
dimbear
Apr 2013
#69
The elimination of religion was a major a ideological goal of the Soveit Union
SpartanDem
Apr 2013
#91
For the record, I do not believe anyone suggested this be posted in interfaith group.
cbayer
Mar 2013
#6
Yes, I saw that. I was also involved in the hosts discussion about the lock and the
cbayer
Mar 2013
#11
Agree. I tink it would be a trainwreck to have something this divisive in that fledgling group.
cbayer
Mar 2013
#26
Another guy attacking an non-existent strawman, also sick of the "militant" label...
Humanist_Activist
Mar 2013
#15
By the time you reposted here, the title and subtitle on Salon had changed
muriel_volestrangler
Mar 2013
#17
A good article that was completely mistitled, and misrepresented by it's headline.
kwassa
Mar 2013
#54
That's certainly a polite attitude, but occasionally I point out that where there is much religion
dimbear
Apr 2013
#106
Who does that? Who "proclaim(s) absolutely and loudly that there are no gods..."?
cleanhippie
Apr 2013
#81
No, I want you to find them for you. You say they exist, yet refuse to provide any evidence at all
cleanhippie
Apr 2013
#83
You make a claim to disparage an entire group then refuse to support that claim with evidence.
cleanhippie
Apr 2013
#85
I never said that atheists had a dogma, unless they are hard atheists, of course.
kwassa
Apr 2013
#151
I've spent endless time on this group talking to atheists who think they have no beliefs and are not
kwassa
Apr 2013
#178
Given the persecution of atheists in places like Bangladesh, maybe we should be militant.
backscatter712
Apr 2013
#191
What happened in 1995? And how do you equate the New Age movement with progressive
cbayer
Apr 2013
#205
you can't claim the civil rights movement or anti-vietnam as religious revivals.
Phillip McCleod
Apr 2013
#207
I don't claim anything at all. You, on the other hand, would be wildly off base
cbayer
Apr 2013
#208
I will agree not to make this about you, as it really does not serve any purpose.
cbayer
Apr 2013
#211
No matter how wrong religion is, INDIVIDUAL religious persons CAN stand at the nexus between
patrice
Apr 2013
#230
Ha, ha. I was actually referring to previous usages, by others & then you proved THEIR point. wow.
patrice
Apr 2013
#239
A rationalist reads my mind???? wow, again. You don't know shit about what I think. nt
patrice
Apr 2013
#242
we don't get to define words for ourselves and impose them on the world.
Phillip McCleod
Apr 2013
#238
So, words have no connotative meanings. Poetry means nothing. & Usage NEVER changes.
patrice
Apr 2013
#241
my point is one individual cannot unilaterally make up terms and impose them.
Phillip McCleod
Apr 2013
#243
I get along with the athiests here because I try to be respectful of their views.
hrmjustin
Apr 2013
#270
Would you agree there are atheists that are hard edge and are uncomprimising as some religious folk.
hrmjustin
Apr 2013
#254
i would agree that there are some atheists who are willing to speak openly..
Phillip McCleod
Apr 2013
#263